Redo the 2009 draft.

[The Joker]

He is 4 years younger. One is on the way down the other up.......

Shit i might use that one for Fyfe vs GAJ

 

[Wild Bill]

Shit i might use that one for Fyfe vs GAJ

Fyfe went past him this year. It's happens - see Barlow v Cunners

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Sheppard with a bullet this season

Hopefully he backs it up next year as well - has put himself right into the mix of the bottom half of the top 10

Sheppard has been excellent. Jamie MacMillan is another from this draft who has really come on, especially in the second half of the year. Kind of makes up for Black and Bastinac regressing significantly.

 

[The Joker]

Fyfe went past him this year. It's happens - see Barlow v Cunners

Oh so this is no longer a redo the draft thread but who is playing better now, in that case Shephard is 2 behind only Fyfe.

 

[Wild Bill]

Oh so this is no longer a redo the draft thread but who is playing better now, in that case Shephard is 2 behind only Fyfe.

Lol - sure he is.

 

[The Joker]

Lol - sure he is.

Sorry i just though you were talking shit too...

 

[Wild Bill]

Sorry i just though you were talking shit too...

Gee their stats at the same age are similar - Cunners tripled his clearances. B&F in a top 4 side last year showed the level he went to.

 

[tonywilson43]

Martin is ahead of tahlia and gunston would have him second

 

[The Joker]

Gee their stats at the same age are similar - Cunners tripled his clearances. B&F in a top 4 side last year showed the level he went to.

You are comparing Barlow in his 1st & 2nd seasons (he came back from a broken leg in his 2nd) to a guy in his 5th & 6th seasons, seems fair

LOL trippled his clearances, he played 12 more games. Surely with that many more games he would have Barlow covered in every stat known especially since it was a BnF year and all, but we both know thats just not true.

Barlow had 12 Brownlow votes from 13 games in 2010 and 2014 Cunnington got 13 from 22, im not sure you seen much of Barlow in 2010.

 

[Wild Bill]

No 2012. He played a full year. Cunners is coming into his prime. His last 2 year have been as good if not better.

Triple - averages - not total numbers. Cunners is a much better inside clearance mid.

 

[BPikkers]

Same reason you prefer Fyfe. You follow freo. Dont kid yourself, it isnt that cut and dried.

Yes it is. Fyfe by a country mile. You r kidding yourself if u think Martin is better.

Fyfe v Martin.....I know who I would rather take any day of th week.

 

[Bazzar]

Yes it is. Fyfe by a country mile. You r kidding yourself if u think Martin is better.

Fyfe v Martin.....I know who I would rather take any day of th week.

haha a three year old bump. ur clever

 

[The Joker]

No 2012. He played a full year. Cunners is coming into his prime. His last 2 year have been as good if not better.

Triple - averages - not total numbers. Cunners is a much better inside clearance mid.

You said at the same age did you not, just here...

Gee their stats at the same age are similar

so 2010 vs 2014 & 2011 vs 2015

Trippled his "average" in clearances, oh so this one is about this year not same age. Nice pick a stat that one, what about the others.

 

[Wouldbetackler]

Fyfe
M

With 3 full seasons under their belts we can now start to see who made some big mistakes but more importantly who got the picks right and who got really lucky.

Here is how the top 20 from 2009 AFL Draft was played out.
1 Tom Scully
2 Jack Trengove
3 Dustin Martin
4 Anthony Morabito
5 Ben Cunnington
6 Gary Rohan
7 Brad Sheppard
8 John Butcher
9 Andrew Moore
10 Jake Meltsham
11 Jordan Gysberts
12 Kane Lucas
13 Daniel Talia
14 Lewis Jetta
15 Christian Howard
16 Jasper Pittard
17 Daniel Menzel
18 Luke Tapscott
19 Benjamin Griffiths
20 Nathan Fyfe

Here are a few that went after.

21 Ryan Bastinac
24 Jake Carlisle
26 Travis Colyer
27 Callum Bartlett
28 Mitch Duncan
38 Sam Reid
40 Allen Christensen
42 Nathan Vardy
45 Sam Shaw

And the Rookie Draft

2 Michael Coad
3 Sam Iles
8 Michael Barlow
9 Majak Daw
24 Alex Silvagni
40 Ashton Hams
43 Stewart Crameri
46 Matthew Jaensch
50 James Podsiadly
76 Claye Beams

A few major talking points I would like to here is, how do Dee's supporters rate Scully, would they have taken him at 1 now (not knowing he was leaving) and how your top 20 would be.



P.S. I hope this thread lasts a bit longer than the last one.[/

Fyfe
Martin
Talia
Barlow
Duncan
Cunnington
Christensen
Carlisle
Reid
Jetta

 

[00Stinger]

Big Maxy Gawn would be flying up this list at bullet pace

Sent from my SM-P555 using Tapatalk

 

[Bazzar]

Big Maxy Gawn would be flying up this list at bullet pace

Sent from my SM-P555 using Tapatalk

Playing great at the moment.

 

[Mitchell54]

I'm astonished that everyone rated Jetta. I have never rated Jetta and never will.
He just isn't clean with his disposal when under great pressure. Only performs well when his team is on top(passenger).

 

[Wild Bill]

Big Maxy Gawn would be flying up this list at bullet pace

Sent from my SM-P555 using Tapatalk

Fighting Goldy for the number 1 ruck title.

 

[Wild Bill]

You said at the same age did you not, just here...



so 2010 vs 2014 & 2011 vs 2015

Trippled his "average" in clearances, oh so this one is about this year not same age. Nice pick a stat that one, what about the others.

He looks shot to pieces. He is barely best 22 in a bottom 4 side.

 

[Mitchell54]

Gawn has to be #3 in the list now. Behind Fyfe and Martin.

 

[gandaal]

Has there been a worse draft in recent times? One great player, a few excellent ones but overall it's total trash.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Gawn has to be #3 in the list now. Behind Fyfe and Martin.

Started off well but isn't ahead of Talia yet.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Gawn has to be #3 in the list now. Behind Fyfe and Martin.

Jenny Talia is very very underrated. Been one of the best key defenders in the comp for years now, Gawn needs to sustain his consistency to be considered on par with Talia.

 

[The Joker]

He looks shot to pieces. He is barely best 22 in a bottom 4 side.

Strange time to say this when he had 32 possessions n 14 tackles. How has Cunnington been going

 

[Wild Bill]

Strange time to say this when he had 32 possessions n 14 tackles. How has Cunnington been going

V Carlton. Saw him live v the Roos.

Cunners has been ok - 2nd best in our great win over the Crows.