Game Day Round 10 WC v GWS: RIP in Peace Nic Nat's knee

[Chris_6678]

We need Nelson to just annoy the hell out of Greene.

 

[RookiePick]

Nervous poo oracle indicates cautious ploptimism.

 

[Keys]

You'd think the MC would have been aware of concerns over Lecras and, if the rumours are true, Shuey when naming the 25 on Thursday so it'd be Karpany to come in for Shuey

You'd think

 

[Biggie]

You'd think the MC would have been aware of concerns over Lecras and, if the rumours are true, Shuey when naming the 25 on Thursday so it'd be Karpany to come in for Shuey

You'd think

Simpson and the MC planning for today

 

[JordanWCE]

If it's Redden over Karpany I'll something something

 

[Ochre]

You'd think the MC would have been aware of concerns over Lecras and, if the rumours are true, Shuey when naming the 25 on Thursday so it'd be Karpany to come in for Shuey

You'd think

If that was the case surely we don't bother with Mackenzie in the 25 then.

 

[dajesmac]

If that was the case surely we don't bother with Mackenzie in the 25 then.

You usually want at least one KPP in the emergency list for balance.

 

[FLETCH41]

Not feeling confident just wondering which West Coast will turn up today! Please don't let Shuey be injured I couldn't take it if Redden gets another game FFS!!

 

[FLETCH41]

Simpson and the MC planning for today

Holy shit that would hurt ! I had a similar feeling watching last weeks game

 

[Keys]

You usually want at least one KPP in the emergency list for balance.

He was just being his contrary self following a discussion we had during the podcast

 

[Hawkthorn33]

So is it true with the murmurings that Shuey is out today? What is the injury he is carrying? Massive out if he doesn't get up today, makes me sad as I was really hoping you guys would get the win.

With Shuey out who is going to drive the ball forward out of the packs in the midfield?

 

[dajesmac]

Not feeling confident just wondering which West Coast will turn up today! Please don't let Shuey be injured I couldn't take it if Redden gets another game FFS!!

This would be the worst case scenario and significantly diminish my interest in the game. Fingers crossed Karps is in, if Shuey really is out.

 

[Ochre]

You usually want at least one KPP in the emergency list for balance.

Sure but if they are expecting Lecras and Shuey to come out, you're left with one genuine emergency then, and it seems silly to make them a KPP.

 

[Eaglespur]

So is it true with the murmurings that Shuey is out today? What is the injury he is carrying? Massive out if he doesn't get up today, makes me sad as I was really hoping you guys would get the win.

With Shuey out who is going to drive the ball forward out of the packs in the midfield?

Hutchings

 

[Keys]

Sure but if they are expecting Lecras and Shuey to come out, you're left with one genuine emergency then, and it seems silly to make them a KPP.

And if a KPP unexpectedly can't play then what

Edit : Or as I said in the podcast he's there as cover in case GWS went in taller than expected and we wanted the option of being able to bring another tall in

 

[Ochre]

And if a KPP unexpectedly can't play then what

What if a mid/small is unexpectedly out?

Surely that's more likely.

 

[dajesmac]

Sure but if they are expecting Lecras and Shuey to come out, you're left with one genuine emergency then, and it seems silly to make them a KPP.

I'm just trying to understand your point - are you just simply saying WC have erred in their decision to make Emac an emergency? Or are you suggesting the Shuey rumour can't have any real truth to it, because we would have picked our emergencies better?

If it's the former, I dunno. I think on the balance of probabilities we may have thought we'd be unlucky to have both LeCras and Shuey miss. If a KPP goes down during the warm-up we at least have Eric there. If he comes in, send Yeo to play on-ball and play three KPD.

 

[Keys]

What if a mid/small is unexpectedly out?

Surely that's more likely.

Then redden who came into the 25 when Lecras withdrew plays

Not sure if you're being stupid or obtuse

 

[Ochre]

Then redden who came into the 25 when Lecras withdrew plays

Not sure if you're being stupid or obtuse

Ah, I forgot about Redden being added. Play on.

 

[FLETCH41]

Seriously debating whether to have a bit of a kip before the game! Hate this 4.40 time slot absolute rubbish!! We should play when I want us to play god damn it!! What a waste of a Sunday! Piss farting around till 20 to 5!!

 

[WCErevival]

Seriously debating whether to have a bit of a kip before the game! Hate this 4.40 time slot absolute rubbish!! We should play when I want us to play god damn it!! What a waste of a Sunday! Piss farting around till 20 to 5!!

They should abolish the Sunday arvo games. Must be horrible for the players too.

 

[FLETCH41]

Anyone else in sunny Melbourne?? It's so freaking cold here I can't feel my toes!! Got the heater on going flat knacker, wrapped up in a big blanket and have a water bottle !! Least the Collingwood v Brisbane game is heating up

 

[Ochre]

Scully Out, Mohr In for GWS. No word on us yet.

 

[Bouq]

@WestCoastEagles 13s13 seconds ago
LATE CHANGE: Luke Shuey is OUT. Malcolm Karpany is IN. #AFLEaglesGiants

 

[Biggie]

LATE CHANGE: Luke Shuey is OUT. Malcolm Karpany is IN. #AFLEaglesGiants