Round 17 Trades

[Seluro]

No trades for you

Put Witherden emergency

yeah, I'm waiting until later in the week to look at the bench and VC/C options in an attempt to create some sense of strategy and excitement now that I'm stuck in the no trades until case of emergency/glass box of misery.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Is he injured ?

Maybe - that's the issue - unconfirmed!

 

[samFFC]

Maybe - that's the issue - unconfirmed!

Not on the injury list so should be ok!!

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Pretty quiet on the trades thread this week. Everyone has either run out or is holding on to them for the carnage to come?

Yeah, it's died in the arse and I miss it! Perhaps we can post some imaginary trades:
If I had more than my 1 trade left I'd go Hibberd (NM) to Nyhuis, and Nank to Heeney.

 

[jjsmitty8]

I'm in a bit of a dilemma. I don't wanna be left with trades if I miss finals, I'm not going for overall, just a league win. I really wanna turf Tuohy, he has a last 5 average of about 79. I almost feel like I'd be better off loopholing a rookie there. Other parts of me still aren't sure about Steele and Riewoldt, and then there's the obvious m8 issue. I kind of wanna get Titch just to finish it off.

Help?

Edit - looking at my H2H this week I have Pendlebury, JPK, Selwood, Tuohy and Steele vs his Fyfe, Gawn, Rockliff, Titch and Shaw.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Can't decide whether to go:

CRIPPS -> JELWOOD
or
CRIPPS -> LAIRD (via ADAMS)

So effectively, JELWOOD v LAIRD??

 

[JuddgementDay]

Not on the injury list so should be ok!!

I'm looking at trading out and injured Cripps
So not too keen on taking a risks with another potentially injured player
But, I'm pretty keen on Kelly

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-07-12/sore-giant-fails-to-train-but-club-says-hell-play

Injured trio Toby Greene (ankle), Steve Johnson (knee) and Zac Williams (hamstring) all trained strongly in the hour-long session.

All three appear certain to return against the Swans if they pull up well on Thursday, and would be important inclusions against an in-form Sydney side that has won eight of its past nine games.

 

[Falchoon]

I need to trade to get that extra 5%, see graph (Hannebery, Dahlhaus) but can't afford to trade.



My RDT is paying the price of no trades already (Cripps, JPK, Adelaide Lynch, Greene etc)

 

[samFFC]

yeah, I'm waiting until later in the week to look at the bench and VC/C options in an attempt to create some sense of strategy and excitement now that I'm stuck in the no trades until case of emergency/glass box of misery.

 

[juddola]

Can't decide whether to go:

CRIPPS -> JELWOOD
or
CRIPPS -> LAIRD (via ADAMS)

So effectively, JELWOOD v LAIRD??

Who would you bee playing instead of Laird in defence?

 

[Suma Magic]

Is Rocky done?

I need to trade Scooter to a premo sometime before finals.

Trading him to Rocky this week would be interesting, as I'd be making a trade this week... And if he bounced back I'd be getting him at bargain basement prices. I already have Jelwood.

I'm probably better off holding off but no trades is no fun.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Who would you bee playing instead of Laird in defence?

I would just keep Adams down there....

 

[goondog]

Any word on JPK injury?

Was it just soreness, or could he miss again?

Was a late withdrawal due to illness, so should be good to go this week you'd hope.

 

[BigRang]

Yeah nah not really sure what to do this week, thinking I may aswell go SPP < Jelwood seeing as peppa pig has run his race it seems.
Other than that I don't think theres really much that needs attending to? Everyone has jumped on the Newman<Jloyd trade but they score the same every bloody week so I'm not sure I want to wast the trade. Next week probably one or two of Ryan/Cousins/Brown will get the chop for a K Simpson type and Newman will move to the pine.
FWIW 7 trades and $300k remaining.

 

[Sargey]

Just the one trade for me at this stage.

Newman -> Hurley

6 trades left now. Next week I cash in a rookie and upgrade Greenwood to Heeney, and then team complete with 4 trades left.

Though I may move Treloar to Jelwood the week after, depending on the landscape. He has given me the shits all season.

 

[Sargey]

Yeah nah not really sure what to do this week, thinking I may aswell go SPP < Jelwood seeing as peppa pig has run his race it seems.
Other than that I don't think theres really much that needs attending to? Everyone has jumped on the Newman<Jloyd trade but they score the same every bloody week so I'm not sure I want to wast the trade. Next week probably one or two of Ryan/Cousins/Brown will get the chop for a K Simpson type and Newman will move to the pine.
FWIW 7 trades and $300k remaining.
View attachment 391663

Yep def do Peppa-Pig to Jelwood. Then you're looking sweet as.

I'm with you, I don't think I'd bother with Newman to JLoyd. Save the trade for a luxury (or emergency) swap later. Perhaps a Nank upgrade could be in order come finals?

 

[Listclogger]

Was a late withdrawal due to illness, so should be good to go this week you'd hope.

No was quad soreness.

Expected to be back this week

 

[j0rdy1]

Sandilands > Yeo via Ryder.

Leaves me with 7 trades and 1 spot to fill with a premo. Still waiting on cows to moo, so I can go Cousins to Selwood or a better premo. As I'd rather keep Moutford/Witherden on my mid bench.

 

[juddola]

I would just keep Adams down there....

Bring in Selwood imo.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Playing for league mainly, 6 trades left
Pending team selection:

• Trade 1 locked: Cripps to Kelly
• Thinking about Trade 2: Treloar to Zorko/ Zerrett

BTW - It would be great to have Hibberd (nth) omitted this week - I want that loopy damn it!

 

[gh172]

With a breakeven of 165, is it worth waiting a week to bring in Selwood?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[leng jai]

With a breakeven of 165, is it worth waiting a week to bring in Selwood?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

No one can answer that except yourself. Who are you trading out to get him and what are their break evens? Are you going for overall? Do you need him to win a league match this week? How many trades left? How strapped for cash are you?

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Opinions sought on defenders - I want to choose a D6 and have no idea who to pick (I'm guessing I'm not the only one in this pickle).

Assuming money is no object (i.e just looking at output for the rest of the year) after Doc, laird and Adams rank the next 6 defenders in order

Extract from Footywire


Mine is:
Hurley, Simpson, Lloyd, Howe, Hibberd, Montagna - done without any reference to team draws or ladder position.

Would be keen for more people to share their thoughts/have a punt.

 

[toxic]

Option 1:
Shaw or Newman to Doch
Treloar to T.Mitch

Option 2:
Parsons to Macrae
Newman or Shaw to Hurley

Option 3:
Parsons to Wingard/Nroo
Newman or Shaw to Doch

Option 1

Not Shaw tho