I worry about Clarks status as a keeper. He isn't a seasoned premium, he was only one for the second half of last year at which point burger wasn't in the side. Now that he is back, his scores have fallen and I don't see any other reason for it.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 2 Trading
- Thread starter BlazingDon#9
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I worry about Clarks status as a keeper. He isn't a seasoned premium, he was only one for the second half of last year at which point burger wasn't in the side. Now that he is back, his scores have fallen and I don't see any other reason for it.
I agree, it's the reason why no one should have paid 410 for clark full stop (i did)...
clark to sandi is a done deal if you don't have him.
Moses01
Club Legend
Veteran
Port Adelaide - Jack Watts Player Sponsor 2018
Port Adelaide - Jesse Palmer Player Sponsor 2017
Port Adelaide - Riley Bonner Player Sponsor 2016
Port Adelaide - Nathan Krakouer Player Sponsor 2015
Port Adelaide - Brendon Ah Chee Player Sponsor 2014
Port Adelaide - Jarrad Redden Player Sponsor 2014
Port Adelaide - Matthew Broadbent Player Sponsor 2013
- Feb 28, 2010
- 1,518
- 961
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
I realllllly don't want to trade. But... I don't think I can resist Clark > Sandi. I have Clark/Tippett in the ruck and .. its just not doin it for me!
I'd like to have the stones to keep clark and hope for the best but with leuenberger and clarks current scoring.... I think I'll have to trade. Knowing my luck Clark will start to own it up :<
I'd like to have the stones to keep clark and hope for the best but with leuenberger and clarks current scoring.... I think I'll have to trade. Knowing my luck Clark will start to own it up :<
i have clark also, and personally i will be sticking with him. i recon he can bump his average up to about 85-90 as the season goes on and someone like seaby will probably drop his average to around the same, or maybe even less. so its probably a completely side ways trade apart from the bonus of having a lot more extra cash to spend on another upgrade.
i need to cut my losses with sam wright and the only way i can do that is by getting rid of someone like ball. having started the year with only 2 rookies on the field i feel its a risk i can take.
having problems with who to trade ball for out of
trengove
jetta
howlett
..already have shuey,bastinac,martin and barlow.
is howlett/jetta going to last in their respective sides long enough to be good cash cows or am i better going with a safe bet like trengove (22 games guaranteed).
cheers
i need to cut my losses with sam wright and the only way i can do that is by getting rid of someone like ball. having started the year with only 2 rookies on the field i feel its a risk i can take.
having problems with who to trade ball for out of
trengove
jetta
howlett
..already have shuey,bastinac,martin and barlow.
is howlett/jetta going to last in their respective sides long enough to be good cash cows or am i better going with a safe bet like trengove (22 games guaranteed).
cheers
BlazingDon#9
Debutant
- Thread starter
- #431
My faith in Clark has been wavering but after a weeks of deliberation I'm going to hang onto him and hopefully he repays the faith. Only other concerns are Tippett and Gray at this stage for injury/form. Tippett has been in shocking form yet he is up against Carlton and Melbourne in the next two weeks a great way to score goals, but apparently he hasn't been training properly with some knee injury will be interesting to see if his named. Gray looks like a good chance to play according to the Power board.
- Apr 23, 2006
- 2,018
- 2
- AFL Club
- GWS
Hi guys would appreciate some feedback on the following:
Which one would be more benificial in your thoughts?
OPTION 1
Mitch Clark> Aaron Sandiland
OPTION 2
Jobe Watson> Trent Cotchin
Robbie Gray> Ryan O Keefe
OPTION 3
Jobe Watson> MIchael Rischatelli
Robbie Gray> Jonathon Brown
Which one would be more benificial in your thoughts?
OPTION 1
Mitch Clark> Aaron Sandiland
OPTION 2
Jobe Watson> Trent Cotchin
Robbie Gray> Ryan O Keefe
OPTION 3
Jobe Watson> MIchael Rischatelli
Robbie Gray> Jonathon Brown
Wright named for the roos
albeit in the back pocket
no trades 4 me this week
albeit in the back pocket
no trades 4 me this week
Why did you pick Hall up initially and what has happened that has made it a mistake so far?
In both games he has been triple teamed at times and he has kicked poorly which is odd for him. Last week he scored 55 with 1 goal and the Dogs rarely got out of 2nd gear.
I'll look to trade Hall out when he has made 90k instead of before he loses 15k.
CuriousObsession
Senior List
Wright named for the roos
albeit in the back pocket
no trades 4 me this week
The problem is that unless he scores 56, he's going to fall in price, but hey he might finally pull out a big one for you.
For me, aslong as Peterson is named, I'm doing the Wright to Peterson trade.
Doesn't matter, even if he keeps scoring at his current average, he wont drop by more than 10k over the course of the year. Source: Too Serious.
BlazingDon#9
Debutant
- Thread starter
- #438
Had it with Gray not going to play this week, and who knows If they are going to risk him against Geelong the next week a game which they know the result will most likely be a loss.
Gray -> Ballantyne
Gray -> Franklin
Crunch time decision.
Gray -> Ballantyne
Gray -> Franklin
Crunch time decision.
CuriousObsession
Senior List
Yeah, but if he keeps scoring at his current average you have a player priced at 190, averaging 40, who you will have to double trade up to a fallen gun, plus you are losing points keeping him on the field. However, if he can somehow start scoring 60s, he will increase in price greatly, but I don't see him doing that on current form.
Ball to McKenzie is looking good. Also tempted to trade Clark to Sandi, but will prob save the trade and upgrade Hille to Sandi later in the year. Sandi will eventually go down in price.
The Spornstar
Premiership Player
Am thinking:
In: McKenzie, Brown
Out: Masten, Tippett
Thoughts?
In: McKenzie, Brown
Out: Masten, Tippett
Thoughts?
Ones a keeper ones a midpricer, always pick the keeper.
Well I've moved Pods onto the field to cover for him so hopefully the ts midfield can hit him on the tit a few times. If he kicks 3 goals then he should be good for a score of 60 at least which would do me nicely. But we've already had this discussion
Very interested to see if and when Howlett gets back into the Bombers side. Would it be asking too much for him to spend 3 weeks out?
hawks4life
Debutant
lecras has been named which is good for my team but do i get rid of him to get peterson (whos has been scoring around lecras's 09 average) in his two games so far and price will rise by about 200 k. but also hoping lecras plays midfield which would pick up his scores
Murphy is very injury prone. However if he can keep it together and spend a whole season in the side without getting injured then he is easily good enough to be considered a forward premium.
Harry Freis Tash
Debutant
Hey guys ... like everyone with Clark I'm looking at a sideways early trade to Sandi before the price change ...
But my other big worry is dud Matthew Bate ... was thinking of an early bail out on him ... downgrade to Duncan or Petersen ... keep the profit in the bank and use the rookie as a quick return cash cow to then trade up to a season long premium keeper in a few weeks time
Would appreciate any advice on what people think about that
But my other big worry is dud Matthew Bate ... was thinking of an early bail out on him ... downgrade to Duncan or Petersen ... keep the profit in the bank and use the rookie as a quick return cash cow to then trade up to a season long premium keeper in a few weeks time
Would appreciate any advice on what people think about that
I've decided against trading as even though Medhurst has been a huge dissapointment thus far its ridiculous to judge a player on just 2 weeks and I have no other pressing issues so why trade for the sake of trading?
