Round 20 Trades

[tarky]

To get rid of Ibbo or... Knowing my luck he'll start smashing 140s again.

 

[LanLion]

Trade out Hannebery or JOM? Gonna get Attack Dogs Griff.
I reckon JOM will get a low ton against Melb, whereas Hannebery could get anywhere from 60-130 against Pies. Historically hasn't done well against them.

 

[Jessbek]

Read on a Facebook page that Clarkson has stated Buddy won't play this week.

 

[CrowAboutIt]

Jack or scooter?

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Buddy out after bringing him in a week ago.. tossing up between J Lewis, T Cloke or JP Kennedy?, prob leaning towards Lewis.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

I assume you mean JJ Kennedy

I dont rate lewis - too inconsistent

I assume you already have
Bartel, SJ, Dusty, Rocky


JJK has been good
Cloke too
Stokes been playing poorly but scored 94 last week
NRoo is cooked I think
Henderson better placed in backline
Roughy not good enough to be a permanent top six forward
Lewis scores too many 60's

I'd go one of the big full forwards, check their match ups coming up over finals and toss up

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

I assume you mean JJ Kennedy

I dont rate lewis - too inconsistent

I assume you already have
Bartel, SJ, Dusty, Rocky


JJK has been good
Cloke too
Stokes been playing poorly but scored 94 last week
NRoo is cooked I think
Henderson better placed in backline
Roughy not good enough to be a permanent top six forward
Lewis scores too many 60's

I'd go one of the big full forwards, check their match ups coming up over finals and toss up

Yes so JJ Kennedy.

My current fwd line is Martin, N Riewolt, S Johnson, Rockcliffe, B Harvey, Buddy - Staker & Menzel.. So I don't have Bartel, but I think he has been too inconsistent and I also cant get out of my head the amount of times Cloke burnt me last season.

If Ibbotson doesn't play I will only have enough $ to upgrade one of him and Buddy, so was thinking I might be better off downgrading Buddy, playing Staker and then upgrading Ibbotson to either H Shaw or Hanley.

 

[meesy]

Nicholls --> Grundy

Not sure on 2nd trade

Hunter/Carter --> Griffen/Barlow

Griffen vs Barlow?

Griffen plays Carlton, Adelaide, Brisbane & Melbourne
Barlow plays GWS, Melbourne, Port, Saints

both! but get barlow first ... GWS man

 

[Fitzey]

Am so far behind don't know what to do! Ranked about 21k though. Need to win this week very tough game! Please help!
DEF: Godd, Hepp, Gibbs, Ellis, Terlich, Wilson (Staker, Thurlow)
MID: Swan, Ablett, Pendles, Jack, O'Keefe, J.Selwood, Reddan, Murphy (Rampe, Kommer)
RUK: Cox, Krooze (Nichols, Currie)
Fwd: Martin, Lewis, Cloke, Bartel, Roughead, Johnson (Stokes, Caff)
$6,100 in bank.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Am so far behind don't know what to do! Ranked about 21k though. Need to win this week very tough game! Please help!
DEF: Godd, Hepp, Gibbs, Ellis, Terlich, Wilson (Staker, Thurlow)
MID: Swan, Ablett, Pendles, Jack, O'Keefe, J.Selwood, Reddan, Murphy (Rampe, Kommer)
RUK: Cox, Krooze (Nichols, Currie)
Fwd: Martin, Lewis, Cloke, Bartel, Roughead, Johnson (Stokes, Caff)
$6,100 in bank.

You're a premium surplus in the FWD line but two short in the backline.

I would downgrade you most profitable but least useful bench (Kommer, Maccaffer?) Trade one of Stokes or Roughead to Enright by swinging Staker onto your forward bench.

Next week downgrade the other of Kommer and Maccaffer and upgrade Terlich to a premium defender or Murphy to Beams

 

[Fitzey]

You're a premium surplus in the FWD line but two short in the backline.

I would downgrade you most profitable but least useful bench (Kommer, Maccaffer?) Trade one of Stokes or Roughead to Enright by swinging Staker onto your forward bench.

Next week downgrade the other of Kommer and Maccaffer and upgrade Terlich to a premium defender or Murphy to Beams

who should i start? Terlich or Wilson?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

who should i start? Terlich or Wilson?

Terlich

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Kreuzer out, luckily I have roughead on the pine

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Kreuzer out, ughhhhhhhhhhhh

Mitchell > Beams
Kreuzer > Minson

Minno should be able to monster Carlton in the ruck this week

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Come on dooooooooooown Brodie Grundy

 

[FrankenLynch]

Kreuzer out, ughhhhhhhhhhhh

Tell me about it! The absolute worst out of any player for me. Just got him in last week but still have Nicholls on the bench so either I play Rowe or I upgrade Nicholls and then have 3 premo rucks next week!

 

[Mateyman]

Should I just play Grundy with Kreuzer out?
Will hopefully manage a 60 vs Sydney, and it means I can get JPK/Mitchell out of my starting side for Beams.

 

[CrowAboutIt]

Was hoping to trade goldy > Cox this week however with kreuz out I'm not sure what to do..

Should I:

Trade goldy anyway and play cox and Grundy

Trade kreuz and play cox and goldy

Haven't been happy with goldy and have been trying to get rid of him all season.. Is it worth the risk trading him and playing Grundy for a week but then hopefully having cox and kruez next week? Any suggestions guys..

 

[Hate]

**** you Franklin! Always find a way to **** UP my team. Now I need to rearrange my trades. Taking a huge punt on this.

Franklin > J. Riewoldt/Tippet
T. Mitchell > Watson

 

[Comettski_1]

Trades I made:
Priddis for ROK
Franklin for Mayne

Now with Kreuzer out should I go:
Kreuzer to Minson
Franklin for Mayne
(Keep Priddis)

Or take the punt on Grundy?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Should I just play Grundy with Kreuzer out?
Will hopefully manage a 60 vs Sydney, and it means I can get JPK/Mitchell out of my starting side for Beams.

Thats what I am doing

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Thoughts on bringing in Pavlich??

 

[TedDougChris]

Might need to check my opponents this week to see if they are Kruezer affected as well. Undecided how to approach this:

Out: T Mitchell, S Mayes.
In: ??? , ???

Now, the issue is, that I don't have enough money to get my two preferred options. I have 1.012M to play with.

If I get D Beams, I don't have enough to get Boomer Harvey. I could get Bartel, but he's not scoring well and has a massive BE this week (I think). Getting Beams would leave me 430K for a forward.

I could get Harvey, but then I only have 552K available for a mid. Cotchin appeals, I suspect both Scooter and Cornes will get tagging roles over the coming weeks, I suspect ROK will get a rest before the finals (as may Cotchin actually).

Beams would obviously be a midfield starter, Cotchin I think will outscore J Selwood, who would move to the bench.
Harvey would replace NRoo as a starting forward, NRoo would become an emergency.

Thoughts people ?? I'm relying on Grundy to cover for a week.

 

[Bluey_McKenna]

Stanton to Beams.

Kreuzer to ????

Minson better placed for the remainder of the season, but Roughy could go huge against the Saints...

 

[kaisasosai]

Stanton to Beams.

Kreuzer to ????

Minson better placed for the remainder of the season, but Roughy could go huge against the Saints...

Or Roughy could get double teamed because they don't have Franklin to worry about.