Trades Round 21 Trades

[Maurice Mitchell]

I would have thought Houli, likes playing at the G
Williams might be affected by Jelly's return?

Averaging 114.1 at the MCG this season

 

[Maurice Mitchell]

Some talk of O'Brien being rested to get Jacobs to 200 games. A joke if that happens. Are they trying to win a premiership or bringing up individual milestones.
Would be a laughing stock. Again!



Wanted to bring in J Kelly but it sounds like he may take another week. At least this way I don't have to curse every Treloar possession.

If O'Brien is out this is what I am looking at:

 

[danster168]

I'm just glad I've gone the whole year , maintained a good ranking without picking up billings. geez his fantasy football is so much better than his actual affect on games

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

Definitely Gaff or Yeo at home v Crows this week who bleed points to mids. I got Yeo last week (already had Gaff) so that’s who I’d recommend. 8% ownership, in form with a huge ceiling.

Yep, I brought in Yeo last week and Gaff the week before.

 

[stevebbb]

Even though Witts has pulled up fine from his knee complain, thinking of trading him out regardless.

Witts to Gawn
rookie to rookie

I'll have cash in the bank to improve my side next week. Stewart, Salem, Neale, Danger and Heeney are on notice (lowest 3 rd avgs)

 

[kozi]

Yep, I brought in Yeo last week and Gaff the week before.

Yeo is a bloody animal. Gave Cripps a serious bath.

 

[Sixpence]

Even though Witts has pulled up fine from his knee complain

That's good news!

 

[TedDougChris]

Good news for my side, I received a notification that Mitch Hinge is injured.

I thought he’d been abducted by aliens, he just vanished off the face of the earth.....

 

[kozi]

Good news for my side, I received a notification that Mitch Hinge is injured.

I thought he’d been abducted by aliens, he just vanished off the face of the earth.....

Been stinking it up on my bench as well. Can confirm he was abducted and probed.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Considering bringing in Neale, Yeo, Williams, Crisp, Billings.

Telly out for Gawn (Marshall forward) might be a good play, but Gawn is against Grundy.

in 3 weeks? Must have some serious cash

 

[samFFC]

Some talk of O'Brien being rested to get Jacobs to 200 games. A joke if that happens. Are they trying to win a premiership or bringing up individual milestones.
Would be a laughing stock. Again!

View attachment 721894

Wanted to bring in J Kelly but it sounds like he may take another week. At least this way I don't have to curse every Treloar possession.

If O'Brien is out this is what I am looking at:

View attachment 721896

Yeah saw that. Weird given they are still thereabouts for the top8. Surely not.

 

[DustyTiggers]

Crisp or Williams?

 

[4tune8]

Both have good games coming up, Jelly might affect Zilliams but they have GC last round

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

in 3 weeks? Must have some serious cash

Sorry, I meant those are my trade targets (sidegrades) for my sloane, cripps, stewart, B Smith, Telly.

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Crisp or Williams?

I need an answer for this also.

If I say Williams, will you come back at me with who to trade out from Stewart or B Smith?

 

[kozi]

Crisp but might want to check the weather closer to Saturday.

 

[DustyTiggers]

I need an answer for this also.

If I say Williams, will you come back at me with who to trade out from Stewart or B Smith?

Purely going by the run home, Stewart out. Geelong apparently have a tough run home for backs. Crows have an awesome run home for backs. I rate Stewart higher as a player than smith though, but Smith hasn’t done anything to say he doesn’t deserve to stay. And the run home appears great for crows backs according to the traders. So I guess Stewart.

And EDIT as 4tune8 pointed out, Smith is through the middle. So the above analysis does not help. Though the outcome appears to be the same. So it does help. But doesnt. But does. Stewart out. Any other questions?

 

[Danger_zone]

Who would you chose out of the following:

1. Stewart and BSmith
2. H.Clarke and Crisp/Williams

Just need the highest scorers for next round. The safe option would be pick 1. But I think Clarke could match BSmith/Stewart in scoring (Freo gives lots of pts to def) and Crisp/Williams would do well against their respective opponents (Mel / Haw).

 

[4tune8]

Who would you chose out of the following:

1. Stewart and BSmith
2. H.Clarke and Crisp/Williams

Just need the highest scorers for next round. The safe option would be pick 1. But I think Clarke could match BSmith/Stewart in scoring (Freo gives lots of pts to def) and Crisp/Williams would do well against their respective opponents (Mel / Haw).

Haha, don't we all.

Smith is playing more mid/fwd, hence the higher scoring...so him 1st

Stewart was trialled on a more wing role last week, would expect him to go back to that release def role.

Clarke getting more mid time is worth a shot as a POD

Crisp has also being playing more of a mid role and with the Pies injuries looks set to stay there.

Williams role might change with Jelly back. ( if Jelly not back then he's a lock for the 3 with GC rnd 23)

Could you do Smith + Crisp?

 

[Danger_zone]

Haha, don't we all.

Smith is playing more mid/fwd, hence the higher scoring...so him 1st

Stewart was trialled on a more wing role last week, would expect him to go back to that release def role.

Clarke getting more mid time is worth a shot as a POD

Crisp has also being playing more of a mid role and with the Pies injuries looks set to stay there.

Williams role might change with Jelly back. ( if Jelly not back then he's a lock for the 3 with GC rnd 23)

Could you do Smith + Crisp?

I could do Crisp / Smith, but that would mean using my 2 trades. I was planning on using the other trade on ROB > Gawn /Greene (dpp), but will wait til Thursday teams. So it’s a toss up between who scores more between the two defender combos I’ve listed above.

Really good insight to all those players listed. But the weather is heavily playing into my reasoning, given the cold snap coming through (ie less marks, more stoppages). My thinking is the following:

Smith - Agree with that assessment, but just hesitant given we’re up against WCE. Believe they’ll destroy us in the centre.

Stewart - His high scores are dependent on getting 5/6+ marks. Given the weather, don’t see that happening this werkend. Further, he doesn’t seem to like a hug.

Clarke - quite consistent, disposal/mark wise. But with the rain, leads me to believe he’ll have a lots of hugs.

Crisp - Had same concerns as Stewart, but if Crisp is running through the centre as you say, he’ll do just fine in the wet. .

Williams - No rain forecast in Sydney. He average 100+ playing UNSW this year playing down back. So with Kelly coming back, won’t be as concerned, but would rate Crisp over Williams.

So in short: Crisp > Williams > BSmith > Clarke > Stewart.

 

[Maurice Mitchell]

Been stinking it up on my bench as well. Can confirm he was abducted and probed.

Like his owners. Seemed to perform ok

 

[Maurice Mitchell]

.....Williams - No rain forecast in Sydney. He average 100+ playing UNSW this year playing down back. So with Kelly coming back, won’t be as concerned, but would rate Crisp over Williams.

So in short: Crisp > Williams > BSmith > Clarke > Stewart.

Playing a night game in Canberra. Temp range 2 - 5 degrees. Light rain until evening

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Sorry, I meant those are my trade targets (sidegrades) for my sloane, cripps, stewart, B Smith, Telly.

Theyre all going to take $100k+ each trade you'd think

I'm seriously running dry on my bench

 

[Iceman!]

Changkuoth Jiath a chance to debut this week for the Hawks for anyone needing a 170k downgrade option on the bench that has a slick name.

 

[bl4ke]

Changkuoth Jiath a chance to debut this week for the Hawks for anyone needing a 170k downgrade option on the bench that has a slick name.

Debut confirmed