Round 23 Trades

[SloppyJoe]

Excuse me, Did I ask for your opinion. And I'll thank him if I end up doing them options.

Move on....

It's a forum. Get used to people giving you a piece of their mind if your posts are thoughtless and ungrateful.

Moving on...

Current midfield of:

Jones tagged Hill to great effect last times the Saints played the Dockers, so I would expect Fyfe to cop a lesser tag, or none at all. Griff is playing Melb and trading Ablett is a gamble. Montagna was tagged by Crowley for a half last time after a big first half. If you are set on trading out a mid, I would say trade him or Redden. Masten is the best choice in that price range. Jack isn't too much more, but is in a bit of a DT form slump.

Josh Kennedy > Cloke / Pav
Cotchin Or Dangerfield > Watson / Sidebottom / Montagna

Cloke/Pav is a 50/50. Maybe Pav just shades Cloke on DT form and because he is up against the undersized St Kilda defence. Cotchin is all over the place and I would opt for consistency with that much cash on the line. Watson has been great since he came back and has shown that the off field dramas dont affect his DT form.

 

[Atley]

Josh Kennedy > Cloke / Pav
Cotchin Or Dangerfield > Watson / Sidebottom / Montagna

These are my weakest links bolded.

$1200 up for grabs, am I mad trading thinking of trading these guys out?

If so what do you lads reckon is the best choice?

Are you worried about Montagna copping the Crowley tag?

I know Cotchin has been poor lately but this week he wont be subbed so he will get to feat on the Essendon carcass. I also think Dangerfield will go alright.

 

[FromDaics2Dids]

Okay lads, here's the deal, going for b2b flags $1200 as I said on the line.

My team is:

BACKS: GODDARD, HANLEY, GIBBS, O'BRIEN, SCOTLAND, ELLIS ( Vlaustin / Blee )

MIDS: SWAN, PENDLES, BEAMS, GRIFFEN, ABLETT, COTCHIN, DANGERFIELD,

RUCKS: COX, ROUGHEAD ( Grundy / $89K Rookie )

FOWARDS: ROO, ROCKLIFF, MARTIN, BARTEL, JOHNSON, J.KENNEDY ( Staker, Daniher )

My opponents different players on the left vs mine

MALCESKI VS SCOTLAND
GRIMES VS ELLIS

DELEDIO VS BEAMS
MITCHEL VS COTCHIN
JP KENNEDY VS DANGERFIELD
WATSON VS SELWOOD

GOLDSTEIN VS ROUGHEAD

FRANKLIN VS KENNEDY

Okay if this was your team who would go out who would stay.

KENNEDY
COTCHIN
DANGERFIELD ( All potential outs to get an advantage )

Cash and pride here boys, been in this league for 8 years with the same blokes.

If this was you, what would you guys do here....

Cheers!

 

[C_Turn]

Okay lads, here's the deal, going for b2b flags $1200 as I said on the line.

My team is:

BACKS: GODDARD, HANLEY, GIBBS, O'BRIEN, SCOTLAND, ELLIS ( Vlaustin / Blee )

MIDS: SWAN, PENDLES, BEAMS, GRIFFEN, ABLETT, COTCHIN, DANGERFIELD,

RUCKS: COX, ROUGHEAD ( Grundy / $89K Rookie )

FOWARDS: ROO, ROCKLIFF, MARTIN, BARTEL, JOHNSON, J.KENNEDY ( Staker, Daniher )

My opponents different players on the left vs mine

MALCESKI VS SCOTLAND
GRIMES VS ELLIS

DELEDIO VS BEAMS
MITCHEL VS COTCHIN
JP KENNEDY VS DANGERFIELD
WATSON VS SELWOOD

GOLDSTEIN VS ROUGHEAD

FRANKLIN VS KENNEDY

Okay if this was your team who would go out who would stay.

KENNEDY
COTCHIN
DANGERFIELD ( All potential outs to get an advantage )

Cash and pride here boys, been in this league for 8 years with the same blokes.

If this was you, what would you guys do here....

Cheers!

In my opinion, you've got him covered in the backs and mids and your rucks and forwards are 50/50.

I would bring in a midfielder for dangers/cotchin and a forward for JJK.

Maybe look at Boyd/Jordan Lewis but yea depends on your cash situation etc . Hope that helps

 

[Small Moves]

Okay lads, here's the deal, going for b2b flags $1200 as I said on the line.

My team is:

BACKS: GODDARD, HANLEY, GIBBS, O'BRIEN, SCOTLAND, ELLIS ( Vlaustin / Blee )

MIDS: SWAN, PENDLES, BEAMS, GRIFFEN, ABLETT, COTCHIN, DANGERFIELD,

RUCKS: COX, ROUGHEAD ( Grundy / $89K Rookie )

FOWARDS: ROO, ROCKLIFF, MARTIN, BARTEL, JOHNSON, J.KENNEDY ( Staker, Daniher )

My opponents different players on the left vs mine

MALCESKI VS SCOTLAND
GRIMES VS ELLIS

DELEDIO VS BEAMS
MITCHEL VS COTCHIN
JP KENNEDY VS DANGERFIELD
WATSON VS SELWOOD

GOLDSTEIN VS ROUGHEAD

FRANKLIN VS KENNEDY

Okay if this was your team who would go out who would stay.

KENNEDY
COTCHIN
DANGERFIELD ( All potential outs to get an advantage )

Cash and pride here boys, been in this league for 8 years with the same blokes.

If this was you, what would you guys do here....

Cheers!

How much do you have left in your salary cap?

The match ups look pretty good as they are.

 

[FromDaics2Dids]

How much do you have left in your salary cap?

The match ups look pretty good as they are.

$213,000

 

[Crawb]

Everything really hinges on Beams I guess.

 

[C_Turn]

Everything really hinges on Beams I guess.

Yea, I havn't had him yet this season, not sure wether to get him (obviously if named) to try and nullify opponents or get boyd or someone else to try and gain an advantage.

 

[Small Moves]

Everything really hinges on Beams I guess.

From what I've heard in the media he'll be back this week. Pretty important game leading into the finals.

 

[JMc#5]

Okay lads, here's the deal, going for b2b flags $1200 as I said on the line.

My team is:

BACKS: GODDARD, HANLEY, GIBBS, O'BRIEN, SCOTLAND, ELLIS ( Vlaustin / Blee )

MIDS: SWAN, PENDLES, BEAMS, GRIFFEN, ABLETT, COTCHIN, DANGERFIELD,

RUCKS: COX, ROUGHEAD ( Grundy / $89K Rookie )

FOWARDS: ROO, ROCKLIFF, MARTIN, BARTEL, JOHNSON, J.KENNEDY ( Staker, Daniher )

My opponents different players on the left vs mine

MALCESKI VS SCOTLAND
GRIMES VS ELLIS

DELEDIO VS BEAMS
MITCHEL VS COTCHIN
JP KENNEDY VS DANGERFIELD
WATSON VS SELWOOD

GOLDSTEIN VS ROUGHEAD

FRANKLIN VS KENNEDY

Okay if this was your team who would go out who would stay.

KENNEDY
COTCHIN
DANGERFIELD ( All potential outs to get an advantage )

Cash and pride here boys, been in this league for 8 years with the same blokes.

If this was you, what would you guys do here....

Cheers!

I'd be worried about Roughead (surely will play deep forward and the Swans will look to lock down) & Kennedy (out of form).

The most in form guys you're missing are Stokes, Enright, Selwood.J

Maybe Danger --> Jelwood & Kennedy --> Stokes (not sure if cash permits)


Similarly i have a big match up... my team as follows:

B: Goddard; Gibbs; Hanley; Enright; O'Brien; R.Murphy (Ibbotson;Clisby)
M: Swan; Ablett; Pendlebury; Jelwood; Griffen; Priddis; Cotchin; Barlow (Crouch; Menzel)
R: Cox; Leuenberger (Grundy; Rowe)
F: Johnson; Bartel; Stokes; N.Riewoldt; Martin; Rockliff (Staker; Daniher)

Our different players as follows (opponent on left, me on right)

Backs:
Hibberd v R.Murphy

Mids:
Watson v Priddis
Beams v Cotchin

Rucks:
Goldstein v Leuenberger

Forwards:
J.Kennedy v Stokes

I think he'll change Kennedy to Stokes which would mirror our forward lines. He's got no bench depth so may strengthen that with his second trade...

I've got a mountain of cash so no drams there.

Questions:
1) Bring in Watson/Beams/Scooter (and for who)?
2) Should i bring in Goldstein and make it a midfield battle?
3) Should i strengthen bench and pray for carnage?
4) Any suggestions???

He looks to have me on paper, but 2 big trades could get it done for me...

 

[Recon_29]

Any suggestions guys?

Thinking of downgrading Daniher to a rookie for some extra cash and upgrading carter to a extra mid, either Beams/Griffen/Montagna.

 

[Atley]

To be honest I would get Griffen and Beams by ditching Fyfe/Mitchell

 

[Recon_29]

To be honest I would get Griffen and Beams by ditching Fyfe/Mitchell

thats a good option but i am worried about midfield cover.

 

[SureBuddy]

View attachment 28269


Any suggestions guys?

Thinking of downgrading Daniher to a rookie for some extra cash and upgrading carter to a extra mid, either Beams/Griffen/Montagna.

Your Midfield is really weak and I don't like Franklin/Bartel in the forwards either, both so unreliable. 1 You can deal with and hope they do okay, but with both you take the risk of both them spudding and you losing 100 points to your opponent right there.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

thats a good option but i am worried about midfield cover.

Graham is a ball magnet and i don't think he'll be sub again

 

[Crawb]

View attachment 28269


Any suggestions guys?

Thinking of downgrading Daniher to a rookie for some extra cash and upgrading carter to a extra mid, either Beams/Griffen/Montagna.

Why do you have 6 trades left?

 

[Recon_29]

Your Midfield is really weak and I don't like Franklin/Bartel in the forwards either, both so unreliable. 1 You can deal with and hope they do okay, but with both you take the risk of both them spudding and you losing 100 points to your opponent right there.

Franklin to NRoo is an option but I'm not confident he will have a huge game against fremantle. The other options are cloke and perhaps stokes? Agreed about my mid, i want at least one of fyfe and mitchell gone.

Graham is a ball magnet and i don't think he'll be sub again

If he plays

 

[C_Turn]

Is anyone seriously considering Boyd against Melbourne for some GF POD?

He doesn't seem to have the best record against Melbourne but he always has the potential to go huge

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Franklin to NRoo is an option but I'm not confident he will have a huge game against fremantle. The other options are cloke and perhaps stokes? Agreed about my mid, i want at least one of fyfe and mitchell gone.







If he plays

Can't see him not playing, there are a lot of spuds

Duigan, Joseph etc to drop before Graham.

 

[kierez4ever]

no surprise to see Lyon dog us in the last round. thankfully barlow is playing

In: A.Sandilands, G.Ibbotson, P.Faulks, A.Silvagni, C.Pearce, J.Crichton, J.Mellington, A.Forster, H.Crozier, M.Taberner
Out: M.Johnson (rested), D.Mundy (rested), L.Spurr (rested), Z.Dawson (rested), H.Ballantyne (rested), N.Suban (hamstring), S.Hill (hamstring), M.Walters (knee), Z.Clarke (rested), N.Fyfe (rested)

 

[VSTone]

Johnson to Houli
Wellingham to Martin

 

[Tippaz]

Heppell -> Ibbotson
K.Jack -> S.Selwood

 

[yellowandblack21]

I really never thought I'd ever be so desperate as to trade IN Harry O, but this is the day.
Malceski -> Harry
KJack -> SSelwood

Just need to decide on a captain now, Jelwood or Swannie

 

[kierez4ever]

thinking Heppell-> Duffield (for money as i only 6k and back up) and then Cotchin-> Libba
thoughts?!??!?

 

[kierez4ever]

View attachment 28301
thinking Heppell-> Duffield (for money as i only 6k and back up) and then Cotchin-> Libba
thoughts?!??!?

re-thinking might go Heppell-> Mckenzie and ROK-> Libba