Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[blackshadow]

Haven't watched the game yet, did LDU actually look alright?
Scott was talking in his presser about you guys not winning out of the centre, so he may then change that line up that includes LDU??
Ando and Ahern to come back in???

Can you talk me into picking him up?

I haven't rewatched the game (I don't think I can put myself through it) but LDU was very classy especially in the first half. He's definitely on my watch list.

 

[Axly]

Hanley > Worpel

Worth it?

 

[SterlingArcher]

We know how this turned out for Billings owners last year don't we.....

Hold? Pfft!

They shouldn't even be in the same conversation.

 

[Moustachio]

Telly I want but I'm not going for any of those mid pricers. Still uncertainty about them and feel they will end up underwhelming their owners soon enough. Rocky probably the best option but probably also the riskiest with Wines coming back, as well as being the ultimate burn man of the past. Might pick him up at round 6 or 7 when he is $500-600k if he is averaging 120+ and doesn't look like slowing down.

There is no nice way to say this... if you pay $600k for Rocky at some point this season, I believe that is known as going "full ******" at SC.

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

They shouldn't even be in the same conversation.

As far as player to player I agree with you, however it is still a valid point that holding just because they are deemed premo selections is sometimes the wrong path

 

[blackshadow]

Dusty and Heeney giving me angst at the moment. Goldie to a lesser extent.

I'm seriously considering trading both down and banking the cash to bring in Fyfe/Neale and/or Grundy in weeks to come.

Dusty to LDU

Heeney to Daniel/Worpel

Thoughts on either of these trades or both?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Not sexy enough?

Here2tellyouwhy

Look Hurns a spud and my team's so shit he's my D1

 

[SterlingArcher]

As far as player to player I agree with you, however it is still a valid point that holding just because they are deemed premo selections is sometimes the wrong path

Billings wasn't a true premo. He had 1 season that barely scraped in to a top 10 position.

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

Dusty and Heeney giving me angst at the moment. Goldie to a lesser extent.

I'm seriously considering trading both down and banking the cash to bring in Fyfe/Neale and/or Grundy in weeks to come.

Dusty to LDU

Heeney to Daniel/Worpel

Thoughts on either of these trades or both?

Like Dusty to LDU definitely can roll with that trade

Heeney I agree can go as well, not completely sold on Daniel or Worpel reaching the top group of forwards but if you feel both can, I personally feel Daniel might be the more consistent of the two...

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

Billings wasn't a true premo. He had 1 season that barely scraped in to a top 10 position.

He was at a premo price and was purchased as such, I agree he wasn't the obvious choice but people were buying him to be a premo so fits the bill.

 

[turtles]

So last week everyone wanted to trade out Grundy and Oliver, this week it's Heeney?
He only has to average 99.7 from now to match his 97.5 average from last year.
Like oliver and Grundy, I'll keep Heeney and the trade thanks.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Heeney managed to average 98 with an 18 and 4 scores under 80. He averaged 107 prebye so he is capable of rescuing his slow start. In 2017 he had 10 scores from 18 games under 100, and 4 under 80 (again averaging 98).

I`m confident that if he can get fit by round 5-6 he`ll end up a genuine keeper by rescuing his season.

 

[dmc333]

If this was just a poor form I'd agree, but he's not fit and he can't run through the guts consistently to pick up extra points.

Me saying this should guarantee him 100 from a FP this week though.

 

[pincrusher]

Won't surprise me if Heeney misses this week after listening to Horse's presser. He didn't give any inclination that he would be out, but said he did it in the JLT and has tweaked it in each of the first two games. Only positive is an 8 day break to the blues match.

 

[faible]

1) do you think Lycett will have a top 6 forward average once you remove his 167?
It doesn't matter if he does overall if you didn't have him for it.

2) career high disposals on the weekend (record by a whole 5 touches). Is he the next Grundy or was it just a spike game? Pretty confident it's the latter but your team.

Hard to say, I think 160 is clearly one out of the box, but in the role he’s playing can he get to that 95ish region you need for a top 6 FWD is what I’m unsure about.

Represents some value if he can, useless if he can’t.

 

[dylan93]

Have a feeling I'll hold Heeney and turn Dusty into a super premo of either Fyfe/J. Lloyd/Neale? Thoughts?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Have a feeling I'll hold Heeney and turn Dusty into a super premo of either Fyfe/J. Lloyd/Neale? Thoughts?

Get Fyfe.

 

[dmc333]

Have a feeling I'll hold Heeney and turn Dusty into a super premo of either Fyfe/J. Lloyd/Neale? Thoughts?

I can't see you going wrong there. Dusty doesn't look like being a top 10 mid.

 

[dylan93]

Get Fyfe.

Injury prone af though aye?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Injury prone af though aye?

Worth the risk and gives you another Captain option. 135.5 ave, what's not to like.

 

[dylan93]

Worth the risk and gives you another Captain option. 135.5 ave, what's not to like.

Plus those scores were against rubbish teams haha.

 

[braddalzielleoursaviour]

Thinking of going Walters>Newnes and Goldy>Grundy?

 

[Test Tickle]

Jamie Elliott > LDU (via Drew)
Dusty > Neale

wot use fink bout dat bro?

 

[JRyan23]

Keep Walters
or
Trade to Boak/Worpel
or
Trade to Moore and Butters/Walsh to Rocky/Sheed

 

[Marlowe]

Heeney scoring like shit because he's injured says hold to me. More worried about Dunkley's role which won't just correct itself.

Also, how injured could Heeney really be considering that mark he took last week. Doesn't seem like his foot is going to fall off any time soon.