Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[blackshadow]

If your club doesn’t pump games into kids like this in the position you’re in then there’s something wrong

No disagreement here or from most North supporters but it's not up to us...

 

[Girthquake]

im more than happy to burn a trade on heeney if hes out but boy oh boy do i hate looking at 2 players from the same club side by side in my team (Danger & Kelly )

 

[Hawkforce]

Dusty owners flicking him: You reason?
Heeney owners flicking him: Your reason?

Gone Dusty to Rocky and Heeney to Boak.

Reasons? Don't think Dusty will be Top 10. And Heeney looks like a slow start. The trades net me over $200 Grand.

Sideways af - but it looks good on Monday...

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I don't think I did the Roughy out Roughy in move but are considering doing it with Lcyett. Probably won't. It feels wrong doing it. Is like admitting you have made a mistake.and I don't like doing that.

Have got a few more days to try a couple hundred different trades. Might even just go for a cash grab as have a few under performing promos.

 

[enobrien]

No disagreement here or from most North supporters but it's not up to us...

Really? I thought you had some pull down at Arden St

 

[Gigantic]

Any chance punchable comes back next week..?

Honestly no idea what's wrong with his calf

Could be back next week or out 4 weeks with a mysterious calf injury

 

[stevebbb]

Currently doing:

Valente to Butters
Mills to Worpel (Moore to Def)

$40k in the bank

Keeping Heeney unless he's out injured

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Really? I thought you had some pull down at Arden St

No you miss heard him, he got a pull at Arden St back in the day.

 

[Riviat]

Heeney -

Darling - I thought i promised myself no more KPP last year....... can turn him into Boak

 

[XPISTO]

Interested to see not much talk about Lincoln McCarthy... Not saying he is a must have, at least not this week necessarily, but he is a tasty price and to me is just as attractive as Darcy Moore (for both SC and irl).

 

[freddy mercury]

Why not hold Balta & go
Heeney > Parker
Dusty > MID/FWD of choice

Then next week if Balta is still out next week trade him for any one of the others.

that works out well, could go Dusty to Kelly, leaving me with 450k left. Happy days.

 

[Asho81]

At this stage, likely the following will happen;
Heeney --> Moore.
Atkins --> RockPig.

Heeney under an injury cloud, along with shitty role to start the year.... Moore and Rocky both Playing very well and will shoot up in $$ over the next few weeks.

 

[Bollox]

Holding Heeney coz its sounding like 1 week off...and the fwd rooks are going alright to cover 1 week.
He's starting ok but fading fast on it, looking like a classic niggle that hasnt quite healed and would bet on being out this week or next.

There are a cpl of guys in fwds that will be cheaper in 2 weeks time and IFFF out this week Heeney's price doesnt change so happy to trade him the following week.
The fwd guys doing well Rnd 1 and 2 dont inspire me much as top 5 fwds for the season so happy to wait a week or two. Not burning 2 trades on him out then back in coz i have no doubt he'll be a top 5 fwd and essential 2nd half of season.

 

[go you pups]

What's your reasoning for ditching Dunkley mate being a Doggies supporter and all?

You would know best about Dunkley...

He's only about a 17-23 possession type at the moment

Marks and tackles have helped his scoring a little, but he's just not accumulating enough currently because Wallis and Libba are in the guts more than him

Look at his DT scores this year and that is a fair reflection of where he's at

That 98 against Sydney for example was only a 79 in DT

If he were finding it 25+ a week I'd have no problems and would hold him, but at the moment he's only a 80-85avg type in this current role

3 out of his 4 games so far this year (1JLT + 2HnA) just has not hit the stat lines needed

 

[ubeaut]

im more than happy to burn a trade on heeney if hes out but boy oh boy do i hate looking at 2 players from the same club side by side in my team (Danger & Kelly )

Who cares if they're from same team if they're both likely to be top 6 fwds? Especially when Heeney has the same bye anyway?

 

[Moustachio]

Dusty owners flicking him: You reason?
Heeney owners flicking him: Your reason?
Mills owners: Anyone holding? If so, basis?

Dusty: no tackles 2 games in a row, first time ever including his rookie year... stats back up the speculation that he's not mentally there.
Heeney: ridiculous to trade, holding
Mills: ridiculous to hold, flicked him last week... Horse full of shit... at least with Heeney we've actually seen he gets good mid time when fit

 

[Father Jack]

Even though it's tempting to trade Heeney out, the timing isn't quite right yet. Death or glory

 

[Hava Alle]

Dusty: no tackles 2 games in a row, first time ever including his rookie year... stats back up the speculation that he's not mentally there.
Heeney: ridiculous to trade, holding
Mills: ridiculous to hold, flicked him last week... Horse full of shit... at least with Heeney we've actually seen he gets good mid time when fit

Dont think it's ridiculous to hold Heeney. Ankle issue's and it looks as though Papley has taken all the mid minutes. 60-40 fwd-mid. Imo.

 

[Girthquake]

Who cares if they're from same team if they're both likely to be top 6 fwds? Especially when Heeney has the same bye anyway?

Was just saying i dont like the look of 2 players from same club next to eachother cheif, not that im not picking him

 

[Bollox]

At this stage, likely the following will happen;
Heeney --> Moore.
Atkins --> RockPig.

Heeney under an injury cloud, along with shitty role to start the year.... Moore and Rocky both Playing very well and will shoot up in $$ over the next few weeks.

Ignore that part becoz it is ancillary fluff. Reduce the decision down to simply an injury cloud, which is real. Its that injury causing the shitty role. Zero chance he wouldnt have been playing major midfield minutes if he was 100%.

The decision to trade Heeney is the same as any other time of yr when a guy might be out one week maybe 2...do u have solid coverage to hold, or do you think he will be a drag for the long haul.

The difference right now is everyone is desperately reaching for anyone that scored points in the first 2 rnds. Everyone luvs to think they're buying a bargain.

 

[Raveneyes]

Have $300k to play with. Ranked 15k so want to make some moves.

Thinking....

Heeney > Worpel
- Heeney is playing injured, and there's no telling when he'll recover, or if he will get those promised midfield minutes.
- Worpel has the Titch role, and is a top 10 contender. Is priced to clear. Grande Sale! Grande Sale! Grande Sale! Where? In Hawthorn and Dingley!

Hore > Crisp
- Need the cash from the Worpel trade. Instant points boost, and get a solid keeper for the season.

Have all the must have rookies, Gibbons the only one I don't have but I don't mind.

Waiting until selection before I end up with a crazy knee jerk trade to derail my season.

 

[Marlowe]

im more than happy to burn a trade on heeney if hes out but boy oh boy do i hate looking at 2 players from the same club side by side in my team (Danger & Kelly )

A dangerous bias to have sometimes (especially for a team like Geelong).

 

[Marlowe]

Got 30 trades:

Dusty>Neale
Heeney>Boak

Yay or nay?

Nay. **** off, Neale is mine.

 

[atlas1]

Death or glory

Just another story

 

[Bollox]

If you dont have Brouch is he a must have at this point ?
Started Rocky instead of Brouch and didnt want to have 3 midpricers in mids. Now tempted.

Brouch looked damn good against my mob. Right from the start.