Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[Deliverance]

Heeney to Kelly (should have back my gut prior to Rd 1)

$283,600 in the bank.

Will probably just sit on the one trade this week, unless Atkins is a late out and i will turf him for UDL.

Will wait another week on Goldy to Gawn, should be 20-30K better off next week unless Maxxy goes mental (BE 198)

I'm most likely dumping Heeney as well. Look at it this way. He was injured in JLT2. He had two weeks to recover and didn't. So it must've been reasonably serious. Now here we are 5 weeks later and he's still carrying it. TBH I'd be more likely to hold him if he misses this week.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Heeney and Dunkley definitely gone now, not reversing trades.

Welcome KOTD seagull Lloyddddddd and T.Kelly to the team.

Looking forward to some KOTD seagull action this weekend.

3 trades down, I don't GAF!!!

There’s the JM we know and love, knew it wouldn’t be long until the trades are done. Warms my heart

 

[CurryMagic]

Held Heeney for one more round. TKelly next week if burned again.
Backline needs a lot of work but have enough cash production to improve quickly enough.
Anyone else see anything glaring?

Went Greene to Boak and Ridley (JS was great...) to Duursma (didn't want too many Port rookies initially and they proved they're all worth it.)

 

[toxic]

What's peoples thoughts on 380k being enough to do the following next week? I feel this will be very line ball...

Z. Williams > Seagull
Goldy > Gawn

No need to trade Zac imho

 

[Andrew Birch]

Held Heeney for one more round. TKelly next week if burned again.
Backline needs a lot of work but have enough cash production to improve quickly enough.
Anyone else see anything glaring?

Went Greene to Boak and Ridley (JS was great...) to Duursma (didn't want too many Port rookies initially and they proved they're all worth it.)

View attachment 647620

Nice team. I feel you need at least 1 Def SP. Witherden > Whitfield with that left over cash is what I'd do.

 

[KMitchell009]

Hello. Should I trade Michael Walters for Worpel this week? Apparently Walters has been poor first 2 games, however has blitzed against St Kilda previously? Also, is this the week before prices are adjusted?
Much thanks Kellie

 

[Andrew Birch]

Hello. Should I trade Michael Walters for Worpel this week? Apparently Walters has been poor first 2 games, however has blitzed against St Kilda previously? Also, is this the week before prices are adjusted?
Much thanks Kellie

Walters tonned up in Rd 1 though. Got to give a bloke the chance to redeem himself from 1 rubbish score. So No, No & Welcome.

 

[CurryMagic]

Hello. Should I trade Michael Walters for Worpel this week? Apparently Walters has been poor first 2 games, however has blitzed against St Kilda previously? Also, is this the week before prices are adjusted?
Much thanks Kellie

Walters to Worpel gives you cash now, and Worpel about to go up in price so win-win. I would hold Walters one more week however.
After three games prices are adjusted and every week after the players have played three games.

 

[CurryMagic]

Nice team. I feel you need at least 1 Def SP. Witherden > Whitfield with that left over cash is what I'd do.

Eyeing Lloyd if anyone. And aside from corrections will be the first premo back i trade in.

 

[Scythe94]

Really can’t believe I’m now considering trading Heeney for Boak, but surprisingly don’t really have any other issues to address at the moment (besides maybe trading Hore if he doesn’t get named).

Prepared for a jolly good rogering from Boak if I do bring him in. Nothing good ever comes from anyone named Travis.

 

[toxic]

Hello. Should I trade Michael Walters for Worpel this week? Apparently Walters has been poor first 2 games, however has blitzed against St Kilda previously? Also, is this the week before prices are adjusted?
Much thanks Kellie

No trade

Yes after this rd prices adjust

 

[Andrew Birch]

Heeney and Dunkley definitely gone now, not reversing trades.

Welcome KOTD seagull Lloyddddddd and T.Kelly to the team.

Looking forward to some KOTD seagull action this weekend.

3 trades down, I don't GAF!!!

I for one am looking forward to witnessing the first ever in-out-in-double-trade manoeuvre in BF history in Rd14 when you trade both Dunkley & Heeney back into your team during the same Rd!

 

[ROOINYOU]

Witherden to Neman or HOLD

Hold mate.

 

[Haychh]

Only Premo I would consider trading out if I had him would be Dusty, there is definitely something there we haven't been told about yet.

Other than that hold unless you've missed out on any of the must have rookies.

Heeney will get better as the year goes on and will still end up a top 6 forward, apart from Danger and Kelly all other forwards have their issues.

People saying I don't want another Billings this year... please.... Heeney and Billings are not on the same planet

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Only Premo I would consider trading out if I had him would be Dusty, there is definitely something there we haven't been told about yet.

Other than that hold unless you've missed out on any of the must have rookies.

Heeney will get better as the year goes on and will still end up a top 6 forward, apart from Danger and Kelly all other forwards have their issues.

People saying I don't want another Billings this year... please.... Heeney and Billings are not on the same planet

I agree. Billings is scoring waaay more!

 

[Deliverance]

Only Premo I would consider trading out if I had him would be Dusty, there is definitely something there we haven't been told about yet.

Other than that hold unless you've missed out on any of the must have rookies.

Heeney will get better as the year goes on and will still end up a top 6 forward, apart from Danger and Kelly all other forwards have their issues.

People saying I don't want another Billings this year... please.... Heeney and Billings are not on the same planet

Issue with Heeney is that he is injured and we don't know how bad. We know Horse will play them injured ala buddy and Hanners, with bad outcomes for SCers

 

[ROOINYOU]

After too much thinking and a few naps ive come up with 2 trade options..

1) Ridley > Newman + Greene > Kelly

2) Ridley > Milera + Greene > Dollhouse

Thoughts?

Newts and Kelly by 30 points a week

 

[Gene Simmons]

Is it crazy to go Goldy -> Lycett and pocket the $100k?

 

[PoopingHindi]

so tempted to go Walters to Daniel.
how the hell did Walters only get 8 possessions with 89% ToG? even if he was stuck in a forward pocket the entire game that's still pretty ****ing bad.
Daniel seems to have the seagull role at the Bulldogs so he's going to see plenty of the football.

i could always leave it for another week but that could end up costing me $50k+ and points if Walters produces another turd.
if this was round 6 i wouldn't trade but its not. it's round 3 and the last chance i get to make corrections.

 

[Old Stuckup]

Any advice for this team? Could possibly go Heeney to Kelly but not sure what else stands out significantly.

 

[GT619]

Is hore to scrimshaw a must have side trade

 

[Northernsoul74]

Is hore to scrimshaw a must have side trade

If Hores not named yes, even if he is named I’m probably still doing that trade.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Is hore to scrimshaw a must have side trade

only if Hore not named this week..

 

[Bollox]

Bloody hell you've been given all the info what you want a crystal ball you know what don't pick him suits me and all the other smart one's that have him all ready

geeeeeez
i'm copping a spray from a 200 post Brissy fan noone has ever seen before
2 in a row and they come from everywhere
go easy, i;m a sensitive type.

 

[ubeaut]

Only Premo I would consider trading out if I had him would be Dusty, there is definitely something there we haven't been told about yet.

Other than that hold unless you've missed out on any of the must have rookies.

Heeney will get better as the year goes on and will still end up a top 6 forward, apart from Danger and Kelly all other forwards have their issues.

People saying I don't want another Billings this year... please.... Heeney and Billings are not on the same planet

No-one is saying they are in the same conversation as players in real life. But for SC purposes if Heeney continues to play injured/mostly fwd the result will be the same as Billings. That is he'll frustrate every week, and you tell yourself "never trade a premo, he'll come good". And he will come good, but when? After 7?8? 9?rounds,by which time it's too late, you've lost massive points, Heeney loses massive cash and you're season is over.
Yep sounds like Billings and Hibberd to me.
He gets 1 more chance against Carlton for me. I need to see 100+, more midfield time and no ankle issues. Otherwise GTFO of my team.