- Sep 9, 2012
- 15,600
- 22,655
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- EAD Jiska
- Banned
- #326
Buddy, Bartel, Rockliff, Zorko, Robinson, Chapman, Cox, SJ, Thomas, Pavlich.
Round 3 trades
- Thread starter Jessbek
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Buddy, Bartel, Rockliff, Zorko, Robinson, Chapman, Cox, SJ, Thomas, Pavlich.
CACA_TAZZA
Senior List
Which FWD cash cow better to milk? Already have JJK, have to decide between
Buddy -> Westhoff OR
Varcoe -> Dwyer (presuming he is in)
Do I cop the price drop in Buddy, and go with Dwyer? I'm worried cos I have no real idea about Westhoff, not sure how well he'll go in the derby this week.
Varcoe I'm tempted to keep for this week, and trade in next week after payday.
Buddy -> Westhoff OR
Varcoe -> Dwyer (presuming he is in)
Do I cop the price drop in Buddy, and go with Dwyer? I'm worried cos I have no real idea about Westhoff, not sure how well he'll go in the derby this week.
Varcoe I'm tempted to keep for this week, and trade in next week after payday.
Ok so looking for opinions. Blokes on the chopping block are;
Watts
Rich
Karnezis and
Zac Smith
Im thinking Watts to Heppell and Rich to Pendlebury
Or
Watts to Birchall and Rich to Swallow.
Thinking of going with the former as Heppell should rise in value then could be swapped into the midfield and upgraded to a premo with cash cow profits in the future.
Smith for Luey is obvious but I think it will hurt less holding him another week than Watts/Rich.
No idea what to do with Karnezis as I already have the good forward rookies.
Watts
Rich
Karnezis and
Zac Smith
Im thinking Watts to Heppell and Rich to Pendlebury
Or
Watts to Birchall and Rich to Swallow.
Thinking of going with the former as Heppell should rise in value then could be swapped into the midfield and upgraded to a premo with cash cow profits in the future.
Smith for Luey is obvious but I think it will hurt less holding him another week than Watts/Rich.
No idea what to do with Karnezis as I already have the good forward rookies.
QS
Brownlow Medallist
Maric -> Kruezer
Karnezis -> Dwyer (if he plays)
Karnezis -> Dwyer (if he plays)
Tough one here.. last trade:
Hartlett -> Dixon/Hanley
or
Dusty (my most under-performing fwd) -> Westhoff
Now I'd probably bring whoever I trade out of those two back in, so this is purely just a cash grab move..
Really like the sound of almost straight swapping Westy to Buddy in a few weeks, but the only way I can do that is to give Dusty the chop.
For max points I should probably go Hartlett to Hanley, but I would hate to miss this Westhoff bandwagon that everyone is jumping on to!
Hartlett -> Dixon/Hanley
or
Dusty (my most under-performing fwd) -> Westhoff
Now I'd probably bring whoever I trade out of those two back in, so this is purely just a cash grab move..
Really like the sound of almost straight swapping Westy to Buddy in a few weeks, but the only way I can do that is to give Dusty the chop.
For max points I should probably go Hartlett to Hanley, but I would hate to miss this Westhoff bandwagon that everyone is jumping on to!
This is a piss take right? RIGHT!?
- Mar 24, 2012
- 2,308
- 1,372
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Arizona Cardinals
- Thread starter
- #333
Dusty > Westhoff.
Haha they are crazy sounding trades, but in this new "2 trades a week" world we live in I have to try keep up with the times and therefore generate cash to keep up with the pack.. the old school DTer in me would have love to just sit still and not trade until injury strikes. Heck I didnt use any trades last week and I feel like Im falling behind already!
Wombatcfc
Draftee
- Feb 11, 2013
- 5
- 0
- AFL Club
- Carlton
My DT scored 2045 in rnd 2,
DEF - Gibbs, goddard, b goodes, (Terlich, Docherty)
Stevenson, yarran, c Hampton
MID – Swallow, swan, cotchin, murphy,
fyfe, wines, omeara, whitfeild. (couch, kommer)
RUC – Cox, Cruiser. (rowe, Currie)
FWD – Kennedy, Walters, Martin
Franklin, Zorco, Varcoe (Maccafer, Lee)
Was thinking of trading, Franklin > Westhoff
Hampton(biggest crab in my team) > c heath.
This leaves me 350k on the bench to then upgrade yarran to birchall next week.
Anyone see more beneficial trades I can make, also do we get 2 more trades next week before price rise or does it come into effect strait after round 3, stupid question I know but 1st time dter here.
DEF - Gibbs, goddard, b goodes, (Terlich, Docherty)
Stevenson, yarran, c Hampton
MID – Swallow, swan, cotchin, murphy,
fyfe, wines, omeara, whitfeild. (couch, kommer)
RUC – Cox, Cruiser. (rowe, Currie)
FWD – Kennedy, Walters, Martin
Franklin, Zorco, Varcoe (Maccafer, Lee)
Was thinking of trading, Franklin > Westhoff
Hampton(biggest crab in my team) > c heath.
This leaves me 350k on the bench to then upgrade yarran to birchall next week.
Anyone see more beneficial trades I can make, also do we get 2 more trades next week before price rise or does it come into effect strait after round 3, stupid question I know but 1st time dter here.
Nice team.
I would be trading out Zorko instead of Franklin. Zorko is likely to drop more in $.
Hampton to Heath is good. Pittard is another good rookie defender.
- Mar 24, 2012
- 2,308
- 1,372
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Arizona Cardinals
- Thread starter
- #338
He isn't playing terrible, he just isn't a DT relevant player haha
Price changes right after the 3rd game. For some players round 3 is only their second game (e.g. Crouch)
Come on. He was ok in his 1st yearHe isn't playing terrible, he just isn't a DT relevant player haha
Damn nab cup
Hartlett to pittard
crouch to moloney
next week, i will go
kommer to crouch
daw to Rowe
just my thinking so far
also thinking of
Cox to fwds
and zorko to kreuzer
hartlett to pittard
crouch to moloney
next week, i will go
kommer to crouch
daw to Rowe
just my thinking so far
also thinking of
Cox to fwds
and zorko to kreuzer
hartlett to pittard
Zorko>JJK is locked in
Lycett>Westhoff bandwagon
Or
Turn K.Mitchell into a gun Mid?
S.Mitchell?? Pendles??
Already have GAJ,Swan,Watson and Lids.
Lycett>Westhoff bandwagon
Or
Turn K.Mitchell into a gun Mid?
S.Mitchell?? Pendles??
Already have GAJ,Swan,Watson and Lids.
West Coast Weasel
Club Legend
Watts, just get rid of the guy. I downgraded to Stevenson and banked the cash after a dreadful first round.
Rich can't seem to break tags (I'm having the same issue with Shuey in my team...) and Karnezis wore the dreaded vest last time round. Haven't really followed Smiths progress
West Coast Weasel
Club Legend
My trades:
Danger for Swan. Didn't pick him initially. Premos really should be avg 100s
Karnezis for JJK. Like everyone else on BF
Danger for Swan. Didn't pick him initially. Premos really should be avg 100s
Karnezis for JJK. Like everyone else on BF
Worth trading Murphy to Ebert?
City Search
All Australian
Do people think JJK to Buddy will be a sideways trade in a few weeks?
- Apr 20, 2001
- 27,605
- 10,692
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Utd,Liverpool, WWT Eagles.
Will be close but you will need some uplift cash.
btemplar88
Blues4Flag2020
- Banned
- #348
thinking about keeping karnezis now beams is out. plus BL plays GC and Melbourne in the coming weeks. Roughie could be a better downgrade to luey and maybe j kennedy (swans) out for watson or stanton) i already got all the good rookies
Pick any rookie getting a price rise this week. Even if they only get this one price rise it will be more money to spend than if you didn't have them.
Neade looks like he is in the team long term at Port and his minnow opponents have made his scores ripe for a price rise. Heath is also going to cop a healthy price rise. Already having Terlich means he wont rise in price but I don't suggest you trade him out..... Docherty and Lee might be good downgrade targets later... Vlastuin too....
It shows the importance of getting playing rookies right round 1 and 2. If you leave Docherty and Lee on your bench you are down 60-100K just from this round. With Terlich and Rowe price rising next round that is another 60 to 100K that you miss out on.... and holding Mitchell means you are possibly 10-30K down. This means worst case scenario next round you are upto 230K behind on the cash generation just from one round.
Was considering Zorko - > Kreuzer but you lose the DPP of Rowe/Cox forever which does not seem like a good idea.
Dangerfield -> Pendlebury (other mids Swan,Gaz,JK,Moloney) can't see any other mids worth getting this round and i love pendles.
I think Zorko -> Westhoff is actually safer then this complex 3ruck trade but i feel i have too much $$ in the bank not being utilised
Worth noting Kreuzer should do well against Geelongs undermanned ruck department you'd think
