Trades Round 4 trades

[PAFC27]

Surprising that the bulldogs are giving up the most points to midfielders so far this year. More than Adelaide.

 

[Danger_zone]

Thoughts on why Doedee is good value:

• My general rule is that poor teams will see more action in the backline. Given how the Crows are going, Doedee is going to be seeing plenty of the ball.
• His debut year (2 years ago), he averaged 72.5. With natural develop/progression, this will likely increase.
• If he averages 70-75 (BCV 87.5-93.5) here on out, thats more than enough for D6.

Given then above, I think Doedee will come up with the goods (or a good stepping stone). Keep in mind that I did back in Brodie Smith to be a top scoring Defender....

 

[TheRednWhite]

Naismith E tonight so if he scores well, I have to loop D.Cameron into R2. That means no room for Worldwide
Actually hoping for a 50 from Naismith to keep the cash gen rolling but not a real big score. That means I can justify getting Pittonet to R2.

To actually get Worldwide, I'm considering downgrading Ceglar. He has been ok and will be a good enough fwd but I think he has almost peaked and has Goldy this week. That said, he will probably still be better than Brayshaw as a fwd.

If Naismith gets a 50 tonight:

Ceglar/Brayshaw to Worldwide via Ceglar to fwd
Whit to Simpkin
Pickett to Ridley/Doedee via Starce to mid

Would you go Ridley or Doedee + 100k?

 

[Cotchy9]

Exactly right. There's too much value and poor players/non-playing rooks to fix this week.

I've been watching Dangerfield very closely so far, he's playing 20% more midfield time this year compared to last year (source - fantasy freako). He's also had the most CBA's every week for Geelong which is a great sign. With the Deboer tag out of the way he really could start to go bang. Also have my eyes on Whitfield and Macrae as great value targets in the coming weeks. Will be interesting to see how Macrae goes tonight

Understand no one is in a position to upgrade in the mids, and everyone chasing the likes of Simpkin, Pittonet, Bailey Smith etc

I’ve got Dunkley to trade out, so looking hard at Danger and think I’ll go through with it. Great value and could still be top 8 imo

 

[mezaire]

Naismith E tonight so if he scores well, I have to loop D.Cameron into R2. That means no room for Worldwide
Actually hoping for a 50 from Naismith to keep the cash gen rolling but not a real big score. That means I can justify getting Pittonet to R2.

To actually get Worldwide, I'm considering downgrading Ceglar. He has been ok and will be a good enough fwd but I think he has almost peaked and has Goldy this week. That said, he will probably still be better than Brayshaw as a fwd.

If Naismith gets a 50 tonight:

Ceglar/Brayshaw to Worldwide via Ceglar to fwd
Whit to Simpkin
Pickett to Ridley/Doedee via Starce to mid

Would you go Ridley or Doedee + 100k?

My personal opinion is that they will both avg around 70-75 but I think Ridley might be more consistant.

I went Ridley last week and may go Doedee next week

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Thoughts on why Doedee is good value:

• My general rule is that poor teams will see more action in the backline. Given how the Crows are going, Doedee is going to be seeing plenty of the ball.
• His debut year (2 years ago), he averaged 72.5. With natural develop/progression, this will likely increase.
• If he averages 70-75 (BCV 87.5-93.5) here on out, thats more than enough for D6.

Given then above, I think Doedee will come up with the goods (or a good stepping stone). Keep in mind that I did back in Brodie Smith to be a top scoring Defender....

Though I agree and I had Doedee in my side earlier this week.... something about seeing him in my backline doesnt fill me with confidence!

If he fires out another 70 this week then I reckon I'll be on board as a stepping stone.

 

[happy_eagle]

Pickett seems unlikely to keep his spot you'd think. Tyler Brown probably capable of a higher score anyway (unless Treloar is back this week?)

 

[PAFC27]

My personal opinion is that they will both avg around 70-75 but I think Ridley might be more consistant.

I went Ridley last week and may go Doedee next week

Naismith averaging that would be nuts given his scoring history

 

[TheRednWhite]

Naismith averaging that would be nuts given his scoring history

I think he meant Doedee and Ridley averaging 70-75. That is also overs I think, for both. Might just grab Ridley as I can afford to and he will make cash quickly so I can get up to Lloyd in a few weeks.

 

[davosowl]

Trades this week, looking at some bench corrections:

Dunkley - McGrath
Green - Bennell
Sturt - M King
($139k bank)

Would love to jump aboard the worldwide express, but I'm $5k short of Sturt to Pittonet.

Currently got the Grundanui ruck line, with Naismith on bench.

If Pickett gets dropped, thinking of trading him to Pitt instead of King. But will that be a wasted trade if Pickett gets his spot back soon?

 

[DaTBird187]

Houston, Cumming & The Bont gone. Welcome Macrae, Weller and Lil' Louis Butler.

 

[PAFC27]

I think he meant Doedee and Ridley averaging 70-75. That is also overs I think, for both. Might just grab Ridley as I can afford to and he will make cash quickly so I can get up to Lloyd in a few weeks.

Thoughts on Florent mate?

 

[Dupogi]

These GWS Spuds have screwed me over for the last time

THEY'RE ALL GONE!

View attachment 899315

I actually think Cogs goes big this week

 

[TheRednWhite]

Thoughts on Florent mate?

yeah great role, assuming you already have Simpkin, he is the next best around that price. He is MID only though but will be a decent stepping stone. I would be jumping on but I already have Ward, who fulfils the same purpose for me.

thoughts on Houston effect with Duurs out? Does he float out onto a wing and play more midfield?

 

[PAFC27]

yeah great role, assuming you already have Simpkin, he is the next best around that price. He is MID only though but will be a decent stepping stone. I would be jumping on but I already have Ward, who fulfils the same purpose for me.

thoughts on Houston effect with Duurs out? Does he float out onto a wing and play more midfield?

Not interested in Simpkin I'll take the comp on with that one and happy to put my hand up if it's the wrong love. If there's no rookies carnage for me I'll hop on Florent though.

I don't think so, reckon Sam Mayes comes in to fill the role but if a like for like isn't named its worth considering. Personally the eye test told me Houston is firmly back on that half back line

 

[Eskimo_Fennel]

These GWS Spuds have screwed me over for the last time

THEY'RE ALL GONE!

View attachment 899315

GWS "spuds" out.. North Melbourne players in.. What a time to be alive

 

[PAFC27]

Voss: A few guys to consider

Senior assistant coach Michael Voss says Port Adelaide is fortunate to have plenty of options to replace the injured Xavier Duursma.

www.portadelaidefc.com.au

TheRednWhite

 

[TheRednWhite]

Who do I field out of bennell or rivers? It’s impossible for me to pick the right one. One will score 30 more than the other.
Also I will finally have Budarick on field after his back to back 60s on my bench, he is back to 30s this week

 

[Benjo_]

Who do I field out of bennell or rivers? It’s impossible for me to pick the right one. One will score 30 more than the other.
Also I will finally have Budarick on field after his back to back 60s on my bench, he is back to 30s this week

Rivers a safer bet given Bennell will only play 50% of the game

 

[PAFC27]

5 minutes until team sheets

 

[Iceman!]

Serong in for the Dockers

Jacobs out for the Giants

Pickett out

 

[Iceman!]

Harley named last week... Doesn't play and is now omitted... Makes sense

 

[PAFC27]

Houston named first midfielder.

Brodie Smith named on the wing.

Ffs what do

 

[Crashy]

Carnage!

 

[Gold_Cat]

Harley Bennell has been dropped god damn!