Round 5 Trades

[BigVic]

Thank goodness that Ablett is fine. Very happy with Mummy to Sandi at the last minute.

Carrots > Waters or Carrots > Gravy.

C. Smith > Treloar for FWD/MID DPP options.

What do you think of the above?

 

[arch11]

I am forced to trade this week as have both Caraz and Harbrow so need to find replacements

 

[kaiserchief13]

I am forced to trade this week as have both Caraz and Harbrow so need to find replacements

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Carrazzo -50k are you serious. ****ing longergan sniper.

Does Carrazzo almost deserve his own thread? I am struggling to find someone to trade him in with.

Here are the options unless you want to make a serious downgrade

For others since the players I have aren't here there are Lids, Goddard, Waters (if you don't have him then get him) and Marty Clarke isn't a bad one.

I am liking Suckling since I have the extra cash.
Johnson also looks interesting and I am certainly considering that.

Thoughts???

 

[policegetthatman]

^ Ya Suckers.

 

[lion4life]

Dickson > Treloar is the only trade I will probably be making. Dickson doesnt look like getting a game anytime soon, and Treloar will make some quick cash next week

 

[yogibbear]

What would you do with my team:

I'm thinking Porpoise -> Treloar. But $225k cash left over is a bit much, though want to wait another week before upgrading anyone... hmmmmm.... anyone got any advice? All appreciated!

 

[yogibbear]

Carrazzo -50k are you serious. ****ing longergan sniper.

Does Carrazzo almost deserve his own thread? I am struggling to find someone to trade him in with.

Here are the options unless you want to make a serious downgrade

For others since the players I have aren't here there are Lids, Goddard, Waters (if you don't have him then get him) and Marty Clarke isn't a bad one.

I am liking Suckling since I have the extra cash.
Johnson also looks interesting and I am certainly considering that.

Thoughts???

Probably:Scotland >>> Duffield > Heppell > Conca > Hargrave

 

[Alexwce]

Carazzo - JMac
Saad - Treloar

will leave me with with 373k which I can hold on until one of the rookies max out, oh and it means I keep Fyfe, not certain that's the best idea but it'll do

 

[swanton]

What would you do with my team:

I'm thinking Porpoise -> Treloar. But $225k cash left over is a bit much, though want to wait another week before upgrading anyone... hmmmmm.... anyone got any advice? All appreciated!

Dont really need to trade, only one would be kennedy to trelaor, the rest of your rookies still have some money to make for you

 

[yogibbear]

Dont really need to trade, only one would be kennedy to trelaor, the rest of your rookies still have some money to make for you

Thanks mate, yeah you're probably right, I think both Porpoise and Kennedy have the same B/E next week so Porpoise probably higher ceiling.

 

[Unrivaled Mach]

Kennedy > Treloar (The other rookies have more to make than him so hes the only option)
Carrazzo > Deledio

 

[Ziebellion]

Probably the best starting side i have seen Yogi. For me Cox, Porpz, danger and Martin are your worst picks but still going alright.

What have your trades been so far?

 

[Mattrox]

I had Wingard and I think his price won't rise very quickly anymore so I traded JMac into the team.

I don't think Paine's bubble is too big so I am trading in Treloar.

Then sit and hold until I can get premiums into the side.

 

[yogibbear]

Probably the best starting side i have seen Yogi. For me Cox, Porpz, danger and Martin are your worst picks but still going alright.

The three trades I've used for 2 rookie fixes (Dickson and Coniglio OUT for Milera and Greene) and Fyfe -> Robinson.

Looks silly cause now I have cash in hand which could have been used to upgrade Porps to a Jordan Lewis type before round 1 started... I regret nothing!

 

[CrozaN]

Thanks mate, yeah you're probably right, I think both Porpoise and Kennedy have the same B/E next week so Porpoise probably higher ceiling.

Correct, Porps has a BE of 19 and Kennedy a BE of 16, so basically the same. Given Porps is vsing Port, i think he should have a alright game, so i would trade Kennedy to Treloar.

I am tossing up as to whether or not i trade Dickson to Treloar (but gain no cash, short term wise), or go Kennedy to Treloar, which will give me $112k in the kitty, meaning i can do one of Magner/Porps to Pfieffer the following week and then upgrade someone to a premium.

Hmmmmm....

 

[NinjaBear]

thoughts on parker?seems to be a great pickup.

 

[beez]

Carrazzo > Waters
Dickson > Treloar

 

[swanton]

thoughts on parker?seems to be a great pickup.

More of a SC player, the last couple of games he has had 30 possies and only scored like 88 and 104, plus he is not going to be a keeper so seem like a waste of a trade

 

[amazingjoshy]

Very keen to bring in Barlow this week, lowest he'll be all year IMO (B/E of 57). Looks back to full fitness, and just looked really good the last 2 games to me.

Thinking on a McCarthy to Barlow trade, have the cash to do it this week...just that McCarthy looks like having a permanent mid role at Port and still has a bit of of cash to make (B/E of 35-40).

Pull the trigger this week or is there any reason to wait on this one that I'm missing?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Correct, Porps has a BE of 19 and Kennedy a BE of 16, so basically the same. Given Porps is vsing Port, i think he should have a alright game, so i would trade Kennedy to Treloar.

I am tossing up as to whether or not i trade Dickson to Treloar (but gain no cash, short term wise), or go Kennedy to Treloar, which will give me $112k in the kitty, meaning i can do one of Magner/Porps to Pfieffer the following week and then upgrade someone to a premium.

Hmmmmm....

the cows haven't MOOED yet!

 

[Ziebellion]

Porpz BE 36 and Kennedy 31 acc to fanfooty. Will wait for ffgenie but it seems breakevens are higher for rookies then expected and lower for premium/expensive players then expected.

 

[Lashie]

Could get Treloar and then upgrade Dangerfield to Robinson or something.
Not sure how wise that would be yet, might be easier to hang onto a bit of cash.

 

[Big Cox 88]

problem with trading cows early, say anyone around a 30 b/e is if they go on to score a 90 or 100 this week, they still have another 3 weeks of mooing and can make you around another 80k. So unless you have identified a fallen premium who has picked up form (which is hard to judge after 4 rounds) or have identified a midpricer who is getting keeper numbers at the moment it might be best to sit tight for another week or two.

 

[James]

If Couch is not selected AGAIN I may concede and go Couch>Treloar. I'm not missing out on a 70k price increase if the MFC won't concede that their team would be better with Couch in it. Although this would leave me with no cash for upgrades.

Or maybe Kennedy>Treloar (certain trade if Kennedy is dropped) which would leave me 115k for an upgrade the week after.