Trades Round 7 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Who to trade out of Constable and Dahlhaus, and why? Pros and cons for both, and now I'm stuck haha (they're both from my own team and I'm still lost)
Constable. I reckon Dahl will be much better this week. Constable omitted after already getting a rest is alarming, he has to go I think. So much for all the plans of holding Constable until the byes and beyond...
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Constable. I reckon Dahl will be much better this week. Constable omitted after already getting a rest is alarming, he has to go I think. So much for all the plans of holding Constable until the byes and beyond...

His BE is still so low though...and Dahl is averaging 65 in his last 3...haha

Ugh. I do agree though, but I just don't know if I can take Dahl dishing up another 50 and then him losing another 40K. So annoying
 
If you have cover do Dahl and if Chook ain't back next week do him then

Yeah that's kinda what I'm leaning towards...just playing the BE game. Constable scores so well, that it would seem a waste if he's back in 1 or 2 weeks...
 
His BE is still so low though...and Dahl is averaging 65 in his last 3...haha

Ugh. I do agree though, but I just don't know if I can take Dahl dishing up another 50 and then him losing another 40K. So annoying
Depends on your cover for dahl and constable I guess. Just think this week is carnage and it's good to keep someone who can get 90+ on field. I don't think Constable is going to come back soon tbh, Guthrie coming back in and playing well has put a tight squeeze on spots.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

JS of Answerth? I reckon moderate at best.

These are the weeks that really seperate the men from the boys.

Can't be great can it? Lions probably have 3 that come in next week as well. Thinking of going for Larkey ahead of him just because I know he'll be playing for awhile even if he doesn't make cash as quickly.
 
Have 650k.. somebody talk me out of Rozee to J.Cameron
Cameron’s a KPF that loves a suspension.
I must admit I did have a fleeting look at J.Cameron. Started the year very strongly (goals-wise), and some high possession games. In good form and GWS have a dream run coming up where he should score well...

Did I talk you out of it or into it??


What if you are in a completely separate category ???
TDC - always good for a laugh. I lol'd.


Going Ed Curnow over Heeney as a fwd upgrade.
Will either work, or bomb my season even further.
Hoping I traded in the 2018 version of Ed.
I traded in Ed Curnow about this time last season. He totally bombed. But fingers crossed you'll fare better this season.


People trading scrimshaw because he's having a week off? There's no loyalty anymore
Yes good call. Though those with Whitfield are just unlucky this week.
Scrim has been getting better each week, and could do a Bailey Fritsch. I'm holding.
 
Depends on your cover for dahl and constable I guess. Just think this week is carnage and it's good to keep someone who can get 90+ on field. I don't think Constable is going to come back soon tbh, Guthrie coming back in and playing well has put a tight squeeze on spots.

I've found a way to keep both, so I think that's what I'm gonna do for the meantime. Can trade both next week or the week after, if it doesn't work out. Means my trades stay the same as well. Clark stays on the bench for one more week, but at least he'll play

Drew > Larkey (via Atkins DPP)
Scrimshaw > T Kelly (via Duursma DPP)

13K remaining

Dahl could go badly, but I'd rather just not make the decision this week, if I don't have to, haha

Means my team looks like this after trades:

Screen Shot 2019-05-02 at 8.25.06 pm.png Screen Shot 2019-05-02 at 8.29.20 pm.png
 
Last edited:
Holding Scrim (also holding Constable but that’s more of a forced thing than a choice). Means I’m fielding Answerth, Hore and Stack in defence which makes me feel a little unwell but at least I’ve still got 22 playing and bench cover on all lines barring the ruck. More than some can say this round
 
So I've got 3 options with my trades. Scrimshaw and Constable will go.

Option 1 -

Scrimshaw -> Answerth
Constable -> Adams
93k left.

Option 2 -

Constable -> Answerth
Scrimshaw -> Sicily
83k left.

Option 3 -

Constable -> Ross
Scrimshaw -> Answerth
425k left.

--------------------------------------

I'm leaning towards 2. Think Sicily will be a Top 6 defender whilst Adams won't be a Top 8 mid. Looking to get the guys to suit my bye structure. Option 1 means that Stack/Answerth on the field. Option 2 means Hayes on the field. Option 2 also gives me an easier out to trade Collins to a forward or mid next week.

Head scratcher though, I'm torn.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Trades Round 7 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top