Round 9 trades (if no Gawn yet, quit)

[Phoenix_9]

Considering keeping D. Smith. Tell me I’m crazy.

 

[Hawkers Hero]

are you sure Watson gets another game? you'll have to make that trade long before Freo's team is announced...could end up covering a donut with a donut

I'm hoping they have bigger issue to worry about with their injury list than dropping a guy after he has a decent game.

Its really him or ling as the options I think - unless I ignore Baz, hold the trades and shoot for Whitfield instead.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

i was led to believe that all teams are announced 24 hours in advance. if so then we won't know about Ling till Friday night.

Ahh right well there you go. I thought they would have announced all teams Thursday this week and that would apply for the week after?

 

[GoDees234]

I know both players have the upcoming bye, but I really like the following trades, but leaves with with only 1K.



Alternatively, if Doedee misses then I will trade him to Stewart and then trade Taylor > Close and King > Duncan via DPP

Any feedback or suggestions would be much appreciated.

Cheers guys.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Think I’ve settled on:
Brander to Close.
King to B. Smith.

Will leave the 3rd trade to cover Doedee.
Doedee to Stewart or S. Hill to Ling (maybe). Need 1 of Doedee or Hill to play.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Yeo cleared to play changes all my plans
This game is so frustrating

 

[SC fish]

Does Saturday games get announced Thursday as usual or Friday? We would wait for Close to be selected before doing the trade

Saturdays teams are announced Friday evening

 

[Bollox]

This Close fella just doesnt look the part to me. Who am i to get in the way of a good frenzy though.
Go crazy and load up.

U Cheap bastards

 

[Benchpress]

Now that Yeo is safe:

Hill > McKay
King > Close
Dev Smith > Petracca
$35,400

Or

King > Georgiades
Dev Smith > Close
Hill > Seagull
$34,000

I'm assuming option 1 makes more sense because of byes..... 2 just looks sexier to me for some reason tho

 

[Glorin]

Brodie Smith or Laird? Anyone got a view?

Neither.

 

[stevebbb]

Saturdays teams are announced Friday evening

Really? WTF that makes no sense

 

[DT_35]

Taylor > Close VIA Walters
Devon > B.Smith
Pickett > Zerrett

Taylor > Close
Devon > B.Smith
Noble > Ridley (Or Hurn/Stewart)

Taylor > Close
Devon > B.Smith
Buda/Bennell > Hurn/Stewart

Only if Walters out:
Walters > Neale
Devon > B.Smith
Taylor > Close

Thoughts?

 

[pulpdriver]

Neither.

Can't believe I started Laird over Sicily. That was one of the toss up decisions I struggled with and in the end went Laird for more dollars because he was more dependable

 

[toxic]

Consistent

 

[SC fish]

Considering keeping D. Smith. Tell me I’m crazy.

Not crazy at all - he's going to do a Viney this weekend after everyone else trades him OUT

 

[Gene Simmons]

How do these 2 trades sound?

D.Smith -> Close
S.Hill -> Daniel

 

[Gresham2King]

Thinking Smith > Close, Williamson > Ridley, King > Draper via DPP.

Strengthens my backline which is where I trust my rookies the least.

 

[pulpdriver]

Consistent

View attachment 921758

Would be ballsy. Cunnington probably not coming back any time soon either. Better value around the same price though imo.

 

[stevebbb]

Consistent

View attachment 921758

Surely guys with higher averages and better history around the same price appeal more. Zerrett, Parket, Gaff, even Cogs, Duncan

 

[Phoenix_9]

Not crazy at all - he's going to do a Viney this weekend after everyone else trades him OUT

That’s what I’m hoping. But his form is putrid. He can turn it around, he needs to clean up his disposal and get more of it... he is capable... I’m probably kidding myself.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Can't believe I started Laird over Sicily. That was one of the toss up decisions I struggled with and in the end went Laird for more dollars because he was more dependable

Same, said it all preseason. I struggled with F2/3 and D2/3
Punchy and Peeney > Chewy and Greenwood 110kish

Laird > Sissy 20k
110k +
20k

=130k > The Gull

 

[markm106]

At least smith will be a warm body to field with no bye.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Considering keeping D. Smith. Tell me I’m crazy.

No, I will not.

Keeping him myself. Got too many other problems to **** around trading someone who is a lock as B22 with an average of 76.

 

[Bollox]

Same, said it all preseason. I struggled with F2/3 and D2/3
Punchy and Peeney > Chewy and Greenwood 110kish

Laird > Sissy 20k
110k +
20k

=130k > The Gull

Go on, have a good sook . Tell us all how it feels dirty and you wish you had a choice.
Mighty Gull dont care.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Consistent

View attachment 921758

Going by Dumont's SC scoring history, he's already had his three 100+ scores for the year.