Schulz or J.Riewoldt

[Engimal]

Was he a team man the night he got shitfaced and got caught speeding 40km/hr over the speed limit, causing Richmond to lose a $750,000 a year sponsor that had been part of the club for 16 years?

No, he was just a funny man. Classic prank on your team.

 

[eth-dog]

I'd take either, but I don't like sooks, so Schulz

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Looking at the careers of both - JR8

 

[Coxy_]

Was he a team man the night he got shitfaced and got caught speeding 40km/hr over the speed limit, causing Richmond to lose a $750,000 a year sponsor that had been part of the club for 16 years?

You are an absolute tosser. He was 19 and never stopped copping shit from people at the club until he finally moved on. Shitfaced as well was he? He blew .065...

It netted us a better sponsor in the end anyway, did us a massive favour.

 

[Hate]

What's all this nonsense about Schulz not being a sook? I watched a 5 minute period of Ports game yesterday and in the 5 minute period I could have sworn I saw Schulz throw his hands up in the air and sook because he didn't get the obvious free kick??

As for right this moment though, I'd take Schulz. Jack isn't performing all that well but his career like said by a bunch of people in here craps all over Schulz

 

[forwardflanker]

Not enough credence has been given to how their respective teams are going. How many more goals do people think Riewoldt would have kicked if he had Port's midfield kicking to him instead of Richmond. Likewise, if this thread were made two seasons ago when Port were garbage it would been locked as a troll attempt.

 

[windyhill]

Was he a team man the night he got shitfaced and got caught speeding 40km/hr over the speed limit, causing Richmond to lose a $750,000 a year sponsor that had been part of the club for 16 years?

Would a team man sook it up and refuse to talk to the media like a spoilt brat, annoying sponsors that had been a part of the club for 16 years ?

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Would a team man sook it up and refuse to talk to the media like a spoilt brat, annoying sponsors that had been a part of the club for 16 years ?

Appears on the footy show and talks to the media = All about Jack, putting himself before the team
Doesn't appear on footy show or talk to the media = All about Jack, putting himself before the team


Let's face it, the only reason Jack doesn't get the recognition he deserves is because people don't like him and will come up with any ridiculous criticism to discredit him.

 

[windyhill]

Appears on footy show at 3k a pop. Is the gag off ?

 

[Monkey King]

Short memories. Jack has 2 Colemans a b&f an AA, has consistently kicked more goals and has more X Factor.

This. It's got to be Riewoldt unless your retention of football performance has a Memento-like limitation.

 

[juss]

This. It's got to be Riewoldt unless your retention of football performance has a Memento-like limitation.

Agreed. Although Schulz is having the better season thus far, Jack's career even though younger has him covered.

 

[Jakko]

Both would be nice.

 

[juss]

Both would be nice.

In a way they are similar style of players. Both good contested marks and good kicks. Both can kick 5 goals from 10 possession games and both are more suited within 60 meters of goal than leading up the wing and getting 20 possession and 10 mark games.

 

[Roachy8]

LOL - it's all about Port Adelaide at the moment - fair enough, playing ripping footy which has allowed their forwards plenty of opportunities after swift ball movement.
Sarge is a quality player and a great team man... good on him.

But seriously, anyone not picking Jack is a Port supporter or taking the piss.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Not enough credence has been given to how their respective teams are going. How many more goals do people think Riewoldt would have kicked if he had Port's midfield kicking to him instead of Richmond. Likewise, if this thread were made two seasons ago when Port were garbage it would been locked as a troll attempt.

Yea thats a pretty sensible comment but if jack was at the PAFC he would have to go through de-sooking sessions

 

[Engimal]

et's face it, the only reason Jack doesn't get the recognition he deserves is because people don't like him and will come up with any ridiculous criticism to discredit him.

Either that or he's not that good this year.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Either that or he's not that good this year.

That comment was in reference to him being called a sook. Nothing to do with his form.

 

[Engimal]

That comment was in reference to him being called a sook. Nothing to do with his form.

What recognition were you talking about then? His recognition as a good person?

 

[Big Sauce 21]

put a poll up

 

[Dan]

Why are Richmond posters getting upset? Let the people have their opinion.

 

[Bardo State]

Schulz has now played 1 third of one very good season in his career and has a few years on Riewoldt. Right now, Jack easily.

 

[TheFVK]

Was he a team man the night he got shitfaced and got caught speeding 40km/hr over the speed limit, causing Richmond to lose a $750,000 a year sponsor that had been part of the club for 16 years?

Lad

 

[Chaisa]

Why are Richmond posters getting upset? Let the people have their opinion.

Except it isn't a smart opinion. Where does Schulz have Riewoldt beat in terms of their careers?

 

[Robbo92]

Jack is never going to win any of these polls simply because people don't like him. In terms of footballing talent it's genuinely not even close. Jack by an absolute mile.

 

[Dan]

Lets start a poll with J.Riewoldt Vs a shit but likeable AFL player then :/