The evidence is beyond doubt. Just because you don't understand it does not weaken it.
Last edited:
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rules Score Review (ARC) Thread - Lions v Tigers Elimination
- Thread starter NonPhixion
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No one understands it, including the afl legend who coached the lions to 3 flags.
‘It’s disturbing’: Lions great baffled by review as fresh claim made amid backlash
‘It’s disturbing’: Lions great baffled by review as fresh claim made amid backlash
www.foxsports.com.au
You don't have to understand basic maths to be good at football.No one understands it, including the afl legend who coached the lions to 3 flags.
‘It’s disturbing’: Lions great baffled by review as fresh claim made amid backlash
‘It’s disturbing’: Lions great baffled by review as fresh claim made amid backlash
Last edited:
What they need to do is come up with a graphic like Hawkeye that animates the ball hitting the post. Doesn't matter if it uses the same mathematic principles, people would feel better if there was an animated graphic with it hitting the post.
- Aug 18, 2022
- 392
- 992
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Gee I don't know, maybe the person employed to do it as a profession?
Ghost Patrol
Incognito Moderatore
- Sep 17, 2019
- 24,288
- 37,838
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #458
Yeah, what did the goal umpire say again?
Pretty sure he said “can we please check whether it hit the post?”
- Apr 24, 2022
- 3,583
- 9,688
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
"everyone" must have a different definition over in tigerland
- Apr 24, 2022
- 3,583
- 9,688
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
i listened to triple j on my way to work yesterday but i dont know why youre asking me about this?
FourthTimeAround
Cancelled
- Jun 6, 2022
- 2,173
- 2,640
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Section 5
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 26, 2018
- 6,956
- 10,902
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Below chart is the Goal Umpire process on Score Reviews. Not the field umpire. Different chart for that one
The AFL has reviewed the call and stated a behind was the correct result
The AFL could have elaborated a bit more, but probably don't want to go down that path as it will never end
The ARC person considered it was conclusive (a behind) so the goal umpires thoughts are not considered
Maybe in future the Goal umpires should have a third option not just 2
Then fans/media would then not place to much weight on what the goal umpire thinks.
1:- I think it is a goal, but want to check on .............?
2:- I think it was a behind, but want to check on ......?
3:- I just don't know because..................................? I was knocked over, Ball into lights, Ball to high to judge etc.
The AFL has reviewed the call and stated a behind was the correct result
The AFL could have elaborated a bit more, but probably don't want to go down that path as it will never end
The ARC person considered it was conclusive (a behind) so the goal umpires thoughts are not considered
Maybe in future the Goal umpires should have a third option not just 2
Then fans/media would then not place to much weight on what the goal umpire thinks.
1:- I think it is a goal, but want to check on .............?
2:- I think it was a behind, but want to check on ......?
3:- I just don't know because..................................? I was knocked over, Ball into lights, Ball to high to judge etc.
Last edited:
Pies Johnson goal-
Lynch 15m out, Johnson 35m out similar angle. johnsons shot looks probably a point from the angle. goal umpire in perfect position to line up the flight calls it a goal. reckon the arc bullied goalie/rushed the decision in the lynch fiasco.
Bont2Bruce
At the Destination Club
- Mar 15, 2012
- 11,176
- 26,163
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray, Melbourne City
Read the thread, I know you haven't. Your post is just as ignorant as many others. Multiple images from different angles showing the same thing (ball over the post) is mathematically certain, it isn't a subjective call such as deciding if a ball has touched a player's fingers at low resolution.
- Jun 22, 2011
- 4,035
- 5,106
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Man City, Cleveland Browns
There are no certainties in maths, not the way the Tigers do it.
tiger supporters looked happy, umpire said goal but check.... not point but check, looked like andrews rushed at lynch before play on call.... and no i haven't had time to read the whole thread, i was busy reading the matchday thread freo v dogs
- Aug 18, 2022
- 392
- 992
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Tigers supporters happiness doesn't matter (though plenty in the 'fan angle' footage were not cheering like he'd just won the game), umpire called for it to be checked, that's all that is required, and Andrews doesn't take a step before play on is called, he moves concurrent with the call. As all the Tigers supporters heard after Daniher kicked the winner 'Let it go!'tiger supporters looked happy, umpire said goal but check.... not point but check, looked like andrews rushed at lynch before play on call.... and no i haven't had time to read the whole thread, i was busy reading the matchday thread freo v dogs
Besides, you've only got a few more days until we likely get rolled by Melbourne then you can jump on the 'that wouldn't have happened to us' bandwagon
TheOptimum18
Club Legend
- Apr 18, 2022
- 1,226
- 2,603
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I understand the whole point about triangulation and all other mathematical theory mentioned in the thread. I would draw out my own depiction of what I feel like can be summarised from the 3 camera angles, but this tweet does it better than I could.
But at the end of the day, I don't believe all 3 angles are perfectly in sync. You can claim any 2 of the 3 are in sync with each other, but I find it hard to see how all 3 can be in sync with the diagram in the tweet.
But at the end of the day, I don't believe all 3 angles are perfectly in sync. You can claim any 2 of the 3 are in sync with each other, but I find it hard to see how all 3 can be in sync with the diagram in the tweet.
smasha
It's Time!
Asterisk flag now.
No replay of the incident and rushing the decision out in 5 seconds.
Never listen to oppos opinion on BF,full of poo.
No replay of the incident and rushing the decision out in 5 seconds.
Never listen to oppos opinion on BF,full of poo.
Similar threads
