-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Tasmanian Football Thread
- Thread starter kempos_kingz_05
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Sportstalk or one of you umpires might be able to answer this one for me. How can a player who kinghits an opponent(badly enough to hospitalise him) and is then red-carded and reported allowed to accept a two match penalty?
who we talking about here
- May 3, 2007
- 3,132
- 293
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Coburg
Set penalty for striking is one match - so he's gone to the tribunal whoever he is - as that's what procedure dictates - red card, and off to the tribunal.
You'd have to ask Flipper as to why he's only given him 2 from there.
Deloraine v Rocherlea. Kent Tyson was the one hit.
crows26
Debutant
I was under the impression that a red card for striking was two weeks set penalty. But the umpire may deem the offence too serious and not offer the set penalty and refer straight to the tribunal.
Who was the Rocherlea player?
- May 3, 2007
- 3,132
- 293
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Coburg
No set penalty for a red card - it is procedure it must be taken straight to the tribunal.
A red card cannot be handed out for a striking charge - if it is said to warrant a red card a charge must be made under misconduct.
Matthew Head
Draftee
Geez and you only umpire Colts big fella - time for a call up by the sounds of things.
Honestly who cares the tribunal is weak as piss everywhere - so it matters not.
What was A. Gilmour's story on the news ? ? I missed it ! !
The tribunal rules vary from league to league. In NTFA football you can still be red carded and have a set penalty option (pending on which charge you've been reported on). The rules you've quoted are SFL, and I'm unsure about NTFL but I think it goes on SFL R's & R's
Mind you I did see a first last Saturday, an umpire reported a Old Scotch player and sent him and the St Pats player off on a GREEN CARD!
The St Pats player WAS NOT reported!
Procedure should have been yellow card and BOTH players reported!
Roorat - I've replied via P/M to your question...
- May 3, 2007
- 3,132
- 293
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Coburg
Did my second game at Premier Reserves level three weeks ago before taking the last 2 weeks off due to being interstate, and having exams.
Hope to get back up there in the next couple of weeks.
- May 3, 2007
- 3,132
- 293
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Coburg
Yep - that's the SFL's rules for all 3 leagues - O.S, Premier League, and Regional League.
Of course Old Scholars is the only league in which a green can be used at seniors level - but does not constitute a report - meerly a cool down period - it's used to keep control over the game - if someone does something stupid that isn't reportable but you think consitutes a spell then give him a green.
But you're right, in reporting someone, a yellow must be automatically shown, or a red if it is deemed to be misconduct.
An automatic report is made - and red card issued - if 2 green cards are given in one game - has only happened to me once.
I take it he will be promoted to the Reserves or back into the Senior team then this weekend ?? Not likely.
What does everyone think of North Hobart's apparent policy and Clarence's to some extent of leaving talented kids (who are clearly capable of playing at a higher standard) in the Under 19's.
Neither club play these type of kids (Darley (nth hob) Boon and H. Riewoldt (clar.)) in the reserves. If they are not picked in the Seniors (which is often) they go back to the Under 19's. It seems that H. Riewoldt has floundered in the Under 19's for about 3 years.
Glenorchy seem to have an entirely different policy. I believe they select their best side, then their second best side and so on regardless of age. Once a kid plays in the Seniors or Reserves they rarely seem to go back to the Unders.
I would have thought this is the way to go. Some of these young "stars" can develop bad habits and over-inflated ego's if left to dominate against their own age group. Wouldn't it be better to challenge them at the next level and see if they can cut the mustard against better oppostion?
whisper...
Senior List
- Mar 26, 2007
- 185
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Each to their own i say.
some teams may believe the best way for young kids to develop is by playing against kids their own age, other teams may be/are different.
Why play a 16/17 year old in the twos, if the twos player cant play underage... therefore a player comes up from 17s and so on while a older player wont get a game??
some teams may believe the best way for young kids to develop is by playing against kids their own age, other teams may be/are different.
Why play a 16/17 year old in the twos, if the twos player cant play underage... therefore a player comes up from 17s and so on while a older player wont get a game??
This weeks morbid thoughts from yours truly:
SFL Premier League Round 16
Clarence v Kingborough at Bellerive (Clarence by 135): Should be far too good for the Tigers, who can't even manage a score of any description
New Norfolk v Brighton at Boyer (New Norfolk by 92): Eagles are better than their opponents...
Glenorchy v North Hobart at KGV (Glenorchy by 3): Cracking contest expected, might be a shoot that could just favour the Pies
Hobart v Lauderdale at TCA (Lauderdale by 19): Whoever wins will almost be into week 2 of the finals, that's about it.
Ladder: Glenorchy 54, North Hobart 48, Clarence 40, Hobart 36, Lauderdale 30, New Norfolk 20, Kingborough 8, Brighton 4
SFL Regional League Round 17
Claremont v Huonville at Abbotsfield Park (Claremont by 33): Will only pull away towards the end of the day to sure up their finals spot
Kermandie v Lindisfarne at Geeveston (Lindisfarne by 27): Lindisfarne to make it 17 straight, not before a good hard fought match at the Nest.
Central Hawks v Cygnet at Oatlands (Hawks by 43): They might finally win a game!
Sorell v Channel at Pembroke Park (Sorell by 150): Do I really need to explain?
Triabunna v Dodges Ferry at The Bunna (Dodges by 115): Road trip distance wise is a long one, but there'll be no problems here!
Ladder: Lindisfarne 64, Dodges Ferry 44 (171), Huonville 44 (144), Kermandie 42, Claremont 40, Sorell 38, Central Hawks 20, Triabunna 16, Cygnet 12, Channel 0
NTFL Round 18
Devonport v Penguin at Devonport (D'Port by 175): Only because Penguin are so ordinary!
Launceston v South L'ton at Windsor Park (Launceston by 55): They'll be keen to redeem themselves on their home patch
Wynyard v East Devonport at Austin Street (Easts by 48): Whoever wins won't get the spoon.
Ulverstone v Latrobe at Victoria Street (Ulverstone by 9): A lot tighter than expected, especially when Latrobe are playing for so much
North L'ton v Smithton at Aurora Stadium (North by 67): A Smithton loss will end their finals hopes, A win will keep the dream alive, just!
Ladder: Launceston 56 (263), Burnie 56 (193), Ulverstone 40 (161), North L'ton 40 (116), South L'ton 36 (116), Latrobe 36 (107), Smithton 28, Devonport 24, Penguin 8, East Devonport 4, Wynyard 4
NTFA Division One Round 16
Deloraine v George Town at The Racecourse (G Town by 60): George Town are warming up for another big flag tilt.
Hillwood v Bridgenorth at Hillwood (Bridgenorth by 85): Hillwood well and truly out of sorts.
Longford v Bracknell at Longford (Longford by 33): No Adams = No Bracknell. Will be only half fit even if he plays this one.
Scottsdale v Rocherlea at Pie Park (Scottsdale by 41): Rocherlea will find out why Scottsdale is a tough place to play at!
Ladder: George Town 52, Longford 44, Scottsdale 36 (129), Bracknell 36 (109), Rocherlea 32, Deloraine 20, Bridgenorth 20, Hillwood 0
NTFA Division Two Final Round
Perth v Fingal at Perth (Fingal by 29): Although under the pump injury-wise, Perth should fight this one out with the Blues. A Fingal loss and they'll lose top spot in the Seniors. The Reserves is an Elimination Final almost, with the winner to get 3rd spot.
Tamar Cats v OL's at Beauty Point (Tamar Cats by 300): This will be ugly, I mean really ugly!
Evandale v Old Scotch at Morven Park (Scotch by 150): Scotch look to have Evandale covered. Evandale need to win the Reserves and hope OL's lose to Tamar Cats to pull off a 5th Place miracle!
Uni-Mowbray v St Pats at The Campus (St Pats by 25): A dead rubber, with nothing but pride to play for.
Seniors Ladder: Fingal 48 (179), Tamar Cats 44 (174), Old Scotch 44 (156), Perth 40 (173), St Pats 32, Evandale 16, Uni-Mowbray 12, OL's 0
Reserves Ladder: Old Scotch 50, St Pats 48, Fingal 40, Perth 40, OL's 24 (100), Evandale 24 (96), Tamar Cats 14, Uni-Mowbray 0
SFL Premier League Round 16
Clarence v Kingborough at Bellerive (Clarence by 135): Should be far too good for the Tigers, who can't even manage a score of any description
New Norfolk v Brighton at Boyer (New Norfolk by 92): Eagles are better than their opponents...
Glenorchy v North Hobart at KGV (Glenorchy by 3): Cracking contest expected, might be a shoot that could just favour the Pies
Hobart v Lauderdale at TCA (Lauderdale by 19): Whoever wins will almost be into week 2 of the finals, that's about it.
Ladder: Glenorchy 54, North Hobart 48, Clarence 40, Hobart 36, Lauderdale 30, New Norfolk 20, Kingborough 8, Brighton 4
SFL Regional League Round 17
Claremont v Huonville at Abbotsfield Park (Claremont by 33): Will only pull away towards the end of the day to sure up their finals spot
Kermandie v Lindisfarne at Geeveston (Lindisfarne by 27): Lindisfarne to make it 17 straight, not before a good hard fought match at the Nest.
Central Hawks v Cygnet at Oatlands (Hawks by 43): They might finally win a game!
Sorell v Channel at Pembroke Park (Sorell by 150): Do I really need to explain?
Triabunna v Dodges Ferry at The Bunna (Dodges by 115): Road trip distance wise is a long one, but there'll be no problems here!
Ladder: Lindisfarne 64, Dodges Ferry 44 (171), Huonville 44 (144), Kermandie 42, Claremont 40, Sorell 38, Central Hawks 20, Triabunna 16, Cygnet 12, Channel 0
NTFL Round 18
Devonport v Penguin at Devonport (D'Port by 175): Only because Penguin are so ordinary!
Launceston v South L'ton at Windsor Park (Launceston by 55): They'll be keen to redeem themselves on their home patch
Wynyard v East Devonport at Austin Street (Easts by 48): Whoever wins won't get the spoon.
Ulverstone v Latrobe at Victoria Street (Ulverstone by 9): A lot tighter than expected, especially when Latrobe are playing for so much
North L'ton v Smithton at Aurora Stadium (North by 67): A Smithton loss will end their finals hopes, A win will keep the dream alive, just!
Ladder: Launceston 56 (263), Burnie 56 (193), Ulverstone 40 (161), North L'ton 40 (116), South L'ton 36 (116), Latrobe 36 (107), Smithton 28, Devonport 24, Penguin 8, East Devonport 4, Wynyard 4
NTFA Division One Round 16
Deloraine v George Town at The Racecourse (G Town by 60): George Town are warming up for another big flag tilt.
Hillwood v Bridgenorth at Hillwood (Bridgenorth by 85): Hillwood well and truly out of sorts.
Longford v Bracknell at Longford (Longford by 33): No Adams = No Bracknell. Will be only half fit even if he plays this one.
Scottsdale v Rocherlea at Pie Park (Scottsdale by 41): Rocherlea will find out why Scottsdale is a tough place to play at!
Ladder: George Town 52, Longford 44, Scottsdale 36 (129), Bracknell 36 (109), Rocherlea 32, Deloraine 20, Bridgenorth 20, Hillwood 0
NTFA Division Two Final Round
Perth v Fingal at Perth (Fingal by 29): Although under the pump injury-wise, Perth should fight this one out with the Blues. A Fingal loss and they'll lose top spot in the Seniors. The Reserves is an Elimination Final almost, with the winner to get 3rd spot.
Tamar Cats v OL's at Beauty Point (Tamar Cats by 300): This will be ugly, I mean really ugly!
Evandale v Old Scotch at Morven Park (Scotch by 150): Scotch look to have Evandale covered. Evandale need to win the Reserves and hope OL's lose to Tamar Cats to pull off a 5th Place miracle!
Uni-Mowbray v St Pats at The Campus (St Pats by 25): A dead rubber, with nothing but pride to play for.
Seniors Ladder: Fingal 48 (179), Tamar Cats 44 (174), Old Scotch 44 (156), Perth 40 (173), St Pats 32, Evandale 16, Uni-Mowbray 12, OL's 0
Reserves Ladder: Old Scotch 50, St Pats 48, Fingal 40, Perth 40, OL's 24 (100), Evandale 24 (96), Tamar Cats 14, Uni-Mowbray 0
what about your darwin footy tips sportstalk lol
They play their footy in our summer time buddy...
I think he means Darwin FA (located in the Burnie Area), with Queenstown, Ridgley, Somerset, Yeoman, etc.
Somerset boy, I don't know enough of the DFA, so spill your guts and give us your thoughts on DFA action..
- Banned
- #7,093
I think he means Darwin FA (located in the Burnie Area), with Queenstown, Ridgley, Somerset, Yeoman, etc.
Somerset boy, I don't know enough of the DFA, so spill your guts and give us your thoughts on DFA action..
Settle down on Bink Bink mate, he's a half back flanker.
ok here we go round 13I think he means Darwin FA (located in the Burnie Area), with Queenstown, Ridgley, Somerset, Yeoman, etc.
Somerset boy, I don't know enough of the DFA, so spill your guts and give us your thoughts on DFA action..
somerset vs cuprona at somerset (somerset by 60) to many options up forward
ridgely vs natone at natone (ridgely by 20) to classy 4 natone
south vs yoaman at yoaman (south by 40) yoaman suck bad
yolla vs queeny at queeny (queeny by 100) no one beats the crows on the gravel
Sporty, I hope you're right but I have a bad feeling you won't be. Strong looking Lions line up in the paper and a very much weakened Claremont side, even at home. We'll know in 9 hours I guess.
As for OL's, what's happened to them? Our very own Cadoras played in a few flags up there years ago and it seems since he's departed the wheels have fallen off!
Only went for the home side more on that Huonville are 5-3 on the road, but have only beaten 1 real opponent (Kermandie Round 1).
Whoever wins will seal their place in the finals pretty much, and we'll know at about 5ish.
As for OL's well, they last made the Seniors finals in 2006 (sneaked in on the Cats by about 2%), but simply are undermanned on and off the field in 08. Playing at Invermay Park behind Aurora Stadium doesn't help them either as they share the venue with about 5-6 other groups for training etc, and they only had 6 turn up to training on Tuesday night!
They've lost 2 coaches (Lorne Goninon in Round 2, now as Asst Coach at Uni; and Brett Laskey just last week through personal reasons). Nick Morrison will play as acting coach, and today against a Tamar Cats outfit that will have the Barron's and all just cueing up for some personal boost to their stats, plus if they could flog St Pats by 180 at St Pats, it will be horrendous what they'll do at Beauty Point. The only positive from the season is that they should hang on in the reserves for 5th spot.
The usual heavy heartedness in posting this...
Tasmania 7-7(49)
Williamstown 31-14(200)
For those of you with Austar replays available on the Comedy Channel, certainly gave me a good chuckle.
Phoenix_13
Rookie
I'm sympathetic to the players in that team that actually want to make something of their football and enjoy playing at the highest possible level they can, but have their plight overshadowed by the politics of WadeFL Tas..
The usual heavy heartedness in posting this...
Tasmania 7-7(49)
Williamstown 31-14(200)
For those of you with Austar replays available on the Comedy Channel, certainly gave me a good chuckle.
I feel your pain there, I really do...
OK, wrapping up proceedings today
SFL Premier League and Glenorchy got up in the game of the day against North Hobart by just 1 point at KGV, Hobart with a six goal to nil third term cast off Lauderdale by 24 points while in the other two games New Norfolk did enough to beat Brighton by 39 and Clarence defeated Kingborough by 67
Ladder: Glenorchy 58, North Hobart 48, Clarence 44, Hobart 40, Lauderdale 30, New Norfolk 24, Kingborough 8, Brighton 4
SFL Regional League and Lindisfarne just snuck through against Kermandie by 3 goals, Huonville with a strong second half outlasted Claremont by 49, Dodges beat Triabunna by 47 in a high scoring shootout, Central Hawks beat Cygnet by 92 and Sorell blasted Channel by 146.
Ladder: Lindisfarne 68, Dodges 48 (169), Huonville 48 (144), Sorell 42 (126), Kermandie 42 (119), Claremont 40, Cent Hawks 24, Triabunna 16, Cygnet 12, Channel 0
NTFL saw Launceston return to the winners list with a 123 point spanking of South L'ton, Devonport beat Penguin by 50, East Devonport pipped Wynyard by 6 in a thriller at Austin Street, as Ulverstone scraped a win against Latrobe by 13 while Smithton broke their Aurora Stadium hoodoo to win by 20 points and keep their finals chances in tact.
Ladder: Launceston 60, Burnie 56, Ulverstone 48, North L'ton 40, South L'ton 36, Latrobe 36, Smithton 32, Devonport 28, Penguin 8, Easts 8, Wynyard 4
NTFA Division One and George Town controlled the second half to overrun Deloraine by 38, Bridgenorth while inaccurate did account for Hillwood by 40, Bracknell upset Longford by 13 and Scottsdale were easy 63 point winners against Rocherlea.
Ladder: George Town 56, Longford 44, Scottsdale 40 (133), Bracknell 40 (110), Rocherlea 32, Bridgenorth 24, Deloraine 20, Hillwood 0
NTFA Division Two Final Round saw Uni-Mowbray thrash St Pats by 88 points, Tamar Cats pound OL's by 196, Old Scotch 144 point win over Evandale and in the upset of the season an undermanned Perth outclassed Fingal to win by 15
Final Seniors Ladder (Provisional): Tamar Cats 48 (189), Fingal 48 (171), Old Scotch 48 (167), Perth 44, St Pats 32, Uni-Mowbray 16, Evandale 16, OL's 4
Final Reserves Ladder (Provisional): Old Scotch 54, St Pats 52, Fingal 44, Perth 40, OL's 28, Evandale 24, Tamar Cats 14, Uni-Mowbray 0
Next week Finals week 1 (Played on Sunday 10 August)
Qualifying Final: Fingal v Old Scotch, Elimination Final: Perth v St Pats
Reserves QF: St Pats v Fingal, Reserves EF: Perth v OL's
Qualifying Finals at The Valley, Elimination finals at Evandale
- Status
