Injury The Injury/Suspension List – 2024

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Who to? I would if I was him

He said at his exit interview that if he wasn't best 22 anymore he'd like to be traded.

 

[schmuttt]

The Spargo thing is insane. Rushed back for opening round, gets hurt and isn’t sighted again, yet they don’t make the surgery call until now?

 

[Topkent]

He said at his exit interview that if he wasn't best 22 anymore he'd like to be traded.

Another damned goody lie!
There's no way he's best 22 next year, Tholstrup emerging, Chandler locked in and Koz dominating I don't see where he plays. Id play McAdam before him aswell

 

[Toump Ass]

I'd have Spargo in over Chandler.

 

[Bluelegs]

Chandler has more upside but Spargo handles our dumb gameplan better.

 

[Bluelegs]

The Spargo thing is insane. Rushed back for opening round, gets hurt and isn’t sighted again, yet they don’t make the surgery call until now?

If we had done surgery immediately would he have been able to come back this year?

 

[Topkent]

Chandler has more upside but Spargo handles our dumb gameplan better.

In what way?

 

[Bluelegs]

In what way?

Spargo has generally been one of the only players that can find a target in our forward 50 when there are 67,000 people in there.

 

[Topkent]

Spargo has generally been one of the only players that can find a target in our forward 50 when there are 67,000 people in there.

I thought the same, Spargo has 3 more goal assists in his last 39 games than Chandler, Chandler has 16 more goals in the same time.

 

[Toump Ass]

Chandler had that wonderful run of form at the start of last year I think? Since then been more-or-less invisible when I saw him.

Ball-in-hand much prefer Spargo.
Spargo averaged .8 goals a game last year, same as Chandler currently. Spargo's stats include one as sub and 2 games he was injured (and subbed off) in. Was trash for a while after that concussion too.

Not much separating either but Spargo played nice and hungry in the finals last year and I don't even remember anything Chandler did and that's pretty much all I care about to be honest, not going out on the field and playing like a bloody fairy.

 

[stEdy]

Think Spargo wanted to go to North? If he's smart he should probably do it. Get a good pay day. He has other interests outside of footy and I reckon he'd be pretty happy there. Maybe his dad or grandfather played there too.

There's a lack of smart, hard working smalls across the league. He's not a star but he's a perfect workhorse half forward for the modern game where you just have to do a shit load of running up and back and still have to hit a target when you're gassed (which he can do because his kicking action is so compact and simple).

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Chandler had that wonderful run of form at the start of last year I think? Since then been more-or-less invisible when I saw him.

Ball-in-hand much prefer Spargo.
Spargo averaged .8 goals a game last year, same as Chandler currently. Spargo's stats include one as sub and 2 games he was injured (and subbed off) in. Was trash for a while after that concussion too.

Not much separating either but Spargo played nice and hungry in the finals last year and I don't even remember anything Chandler did and that's pretty much all I care about to be honest, not going out on the field and playing like a bloody fairy.

Chandler always plays well in games where we play up tempo and goes missing when we do the contested bombs away slow ball movement shite. Hes a good user and link up player who relishes space. Put him on a normal team and im convinced he would be considered a very good player. We just find a way to ruin every forward we have pretty much.

 

[stEdy]

I really like Chandler, even when he doesn't get a stack of the ball he's always tackling and doing the dirty work.

Good overhead and importantly he's a lovely set shot who can kick 50m.

 

[Topkent]

Chandler always plays well in games where we play up tempo and goes missing when we do the contested bombs away slow ball movement shite. Put him on a normal team and im convinced he would be considered a very good player. We just ruin every forward we have pretty much.

Yeah outside of some neat kicks not sure what Spargo brings that Chandler doesn't. Chandler's much more dangerous around goal, Spargo is a crapper version of ANB

 

[Toump Ass]

I'd take any version of ANB over most of the flogs in our side tbh.

 

[Toump Ass]

What would I know though, I've barely watched us this year lmao

 

[Topkent]

I'd take any version of ANB over most of the flogs in our side tbh.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I dont think Spargo does a single thing better than Chandler honestly, maybe a 20m kick, but its not like its that big a difference. Chandler better at everything else: gut running/endurance, pace, tackling, marking, set shot, kicking over a distance.

 

[Topkent]

I dont think Spargo does a single thing better than Chandler honestly, maybe a 20m kick, but its not like its that big a difference. Chandler better at everything else: gut running/endurance, pace, tackling, marking, set shot, kicking over a distance.

Also don't want a guy in the forward line who can't snap it and make the distance from 30m out.

 

[PerfectFooty]

See you next week

 

[Daemon]

See you next week

Expect him to line up in round 22 with Trac with the season on the line.


(We will be 12 points out of the 8 but Goody still thinks we are a chance).

 

[Scythe94]

The fact that they still won't list Petracca as out for the season Can't wait for them to rush Windsor back for a meaningless Round 24 game, either.

 

[Dory_77]

Lucky Max doesn't have an issue with his ankle anymore (slide 4)

 

[jhong]

Lucky Max doesn't have an issue with his ankle anymore (slide 4)

.

 

[MarcMaverick]

Regardless of our injury list, we need to put our boys in for surgery and prep them for 2025.