Injury The OFFICIAL Injury Updates thread - 2 weeks

[The Nostradamus]

Perez being back isn't positive he's terrible

Disagree, he can play

Goes hard at it and has class, just needs continuity in the ones to help him adjust to the pace

 

[Rod Stroker]

No punishment for Boak causing concussion?

 

[Lomas]

No punishment for Boak causing concussion?

Nah, must have happened roughing up JHF.

 

[RossHenshaw]

at least zurhaar, perez and tucker all back next week

I’d only pick the Bull out of those 3

 

[RossHenshaw]

Perez being back isn't positive he's terrible

Back to soccer for our Spanish Bull Perez

 

[RossHenshaw]

At training ? Turner tackle ?

Nah , opening his locker . Hit his head

 

[RossHenshaw]

So Cam officially dented his cheekbone bumping heads with Horne-Francis. Lovely touch to round out the good news.

Isn’t this ironic…
All the build up…
All the Bull vs Judas crap leading up …
All the Bull is going to knock Judas out …
And
The Bull Ends up with a broken cheek bone & weeks out
We just can’t buy a trick ….
NMFC ….

 

[Passmore]

So Cam officially dented his cheekbone bumping heads with Horne-Francis. Lovely touch to round out the good news.

I think we consign this game to history and never speak of it again.

 

[ferball]

So Cam officially dented his cheekbone bumping heads with Horne-Francis. Lovely touch to round out the good news.

Well at least he got fined for it.

 

[shimaburnsgrieg]

Perez being back isn't positive he's terrible

Perez is squarely in the Bonar/Turner camp - just not at AFL standard.

The sooner we pull the trigger with Perez the better for him and us. He will find a club at VFL level and we just have to stop stockpiling the list with these c graders.

 

[Rod Stroker]

 

[hellas_johnny]

Perez is squarely in the Bonar/Turner camp - just not at AFL standard.

The sooner we pull the trigger with Perez the better for him and us. He will find a club at VFL level and we just have to stop stockpiling the list with these c graders.

Agreed its genuinely scarey how many of these types we have on our list.. gonna take 2 years to clear the list out.

 

[shintemaster]

Disagree, he can play

Goes hard at it and has class, just needs continuity in the ones to help him adjust to the pace

He's not top of my list for cuts - although contract expiry is never ideal for a fringe, mid sized player.

 

[muttley45]

I see Xerri is listed as 3-5 weeks, has he rejoined training yet ? up until he got injured, i thought he was showing good progress, maybe available after the bye, i haven't given up on him yet.

 

[The Y Factor]

I see Xerri is listed as 3-5 weeks, has he rejoined training yet ? up until he got injured, i thought he was showing good progress, maybe available after the bye, i haven't given up on him yet.

He’s considered our number one ruckman moving forward so you shouldn’t give up on him

 

[LuvtheKangas]

I see Xerri is listed as 3-5 weeks, has he rejoined training yet ? up until he got injured, i thought he was showing good progress, maybe available after the bye, i haven't given up on him yet.

I saw him at Salamanca Market a few hours before the game on Saturday. He was moving freely and as he was wearing thongs (not recommended in Tassie) we could see that there is no longer any strapping on the ankle. Looks like it's now all about regaining conditioning.

 

[giantroo]

Dynamic forward cleared ahead of Sunday

North Melbourne is likely to regain Cam Zurhaar for its clash with Collingwood, while a handful of other Kangaroos are also eyeing comebacks

www.nmfc.com.au

PLAYER	INJURY	ESTIMATED RETURN
Aiden Bonar	Knee	Test
Charlie Comben	Ankle	8 weeks
Luke Davies-Uniacke	Hamstring	2 weeks
Blake Drury	Hip	Test
Brayden George	Knee	Season
Josh Goater	Knee	2 weeks
Jack Mahony	Shoulder	Season
Liam Shiels	Concussion	1 week
Darcy Tucker	Hamstring	Test
Tristan Xerri	Ankle	3 weeks
Updated: Tuesday, May 23

 

[Devington]

Zurharr cleared, Shiels surprise concussion, Drury and Bonar are tests after some knocks, LDU and Goater just a fortnight away maybe possibly pleasegodplease, Young and Perez out of concussion protocols and cleared, Tucker a test, Archer back to the VFL.

Spoiler alert but we have a few sore boys

 

[hsquid]

So we lost because we replaced Shiels when he went to the bench concussed.

 

[Devington]

So we lost because we replaced Shiels when he went to the bench concussed.

Injury report makes it sound like the concussion wasn't found until later that night, no mention of him coming off for an assessment or anything.

 

[hsquid]

Injury report makes it sound like the concussion wasn't found until later that night, no mention of him coming off for an assessment or anything.

Yeah, I know. But you could see he was distressed when he came off, so out of it that he thought the concussion was in his calf.

 

[giantroo]

Looks like this is the moment, seems to cop some sort of knock.

View attachment 348839106_7047470841936929_6226579097508458435_n.mp4

 

[tazaa]

So Bonar will play VFL and Young and Archer will return. Thats good for the VFL defence.

Tucker should return to the seniors and Id drop Dury to the VFL or give him a week off.

So basically we have:

Shiels - Concussion 1 week
LDU - Hamstring 2 weeks
Goater - Knee 2 weeks
Xerri - Ankle 3 weeks
Comben - Ankle 8 weeks
Brayden George - Knee Season
Mahony - Shoulder Season


LDU aside we have a best 22 to pick from this week.

 

[Lomas]

So Bonar will play VFL and Young and Archer will return. Thats good for the VFL defence.

Tucker should return to the seniors and Id drop Dury to the VFL or give him a week off.

So basically we have:

Shiels - Concussion 1 week
LDU - Hamstring 2 weeks
Goater - Knee 2 weeks
Xerri - Ankle 3 weeks
Comben - Ankle 8 weeks
Brayden George - Knee Season
Mahony - Shoulder Season


LDU aside we have a best 22 to pick from this week.

Will Xerri need a few in the seconds?

 

[tazaa]

Will Xerri need a few in the seconds?

100%
If so, on current form cant see him displacing Todd or CCJ.