Injury The OFFICIAL Injury Updates thread - 2 weeks

[zoomba23]

So Bonar will play VFL and Young and Archer will return. Thats good for the VFL defence.

Tucker should return to the seniors and Id drop Dury to the VFL or give him a week off.

So basically we have:

Shiels - Concussion 1 week
LDU - Hamstring 2 weeks
Goater - Knee 2 weeks
Xerri - Ankle 3 weeks
Comben - Ankle 8 weeks
Brayden George - Knee Season
Mahony - Shoulder Season


LDU aside we have a best 22 to pick from this week.

Urm, why should Tucker return to the seniors? What's he done to warrant that exactly

 

[Farthers]

Have we moved Mahony to the LTI list yet?

 

[tazaa]

Urm, why should Tucker return to the seniors? What's he done to warrant that exactly

It’s a vibe lol
Club surely seems to think so

 

[zoomba23]

It’s a vibe lol
Club surely seems to think so

I'm not sure what the social media team have been watching. Ford and Scott had more influential games off the wing than Tucker's managed all year

 

[The Nostradamus]

It’s a vibe lol
Club surely seems to think so

rate tucker so happy for him to come in (all of hall,spicer, drury should be replaced along with shiels), are you now someone with an inner scrote source

 

[the big lebowski]

It’s a vibe lol
Club surely seems to think so

No mention of Thomas seems telling

 

[Mav]

Looks like this is the moment, seems to cop some sort of knock.

View attachment 1694898

How good are those repeat efforts. You can see how knackered he is but he's just willing himself to the next contest. Caused the turnover that could have won us the game.

 

[tazaa]

I'm not sure what the social media team have been watching. Ford and Scott had more influential games off the wing than Tucker's managed all year

I agree. With Shiels out we may just want another experienced runner against the Pies

rate tucker so happy for him to come in (all of hall,spicer, drury should be replaced along with shiels), are you now someone with an inner scrote source

Tucker in was just my opinion TN

No mention of Thomas seems telling

Maybe club doesn’t want to be seen as promoting his return. Tough one to manage I guess. Whether TT returns this week or next it’s gonna be against sell out crowds against Pies and *
End of the day he warrants a recall and idiots are gonna heckle him regardless

Play the man

 

[tazaa]

As of Monday

Bonar - Knee 1 week
Free - Shoulder TBC
Shiels - Concussion Test
LDU - Hamstring 1 week
Goater - Knee 1 week
Xerri - Ankle 2 weeks
Comben - Ankle 7 weeks
Brayden George - Knee Season
Mahony - Shoulder Season

 

[hellas_johnny]

With any luck vs gws we get ldu back ready to go and goater ready for vfl also. Getting ldu into the midfield along with Thomas to go with simpkin wardlaw sheezel Phillips and Powell is scary to think about.

 

[Horizons_00]

Depressing…

 

[roos_fanatic08]

View attachment 1700145

Depressing…

I thought we only had 9 or so?

 

[giantroo]

 

[giantroo]

PLAYER	INJURY	ESTIMATED RETURN
Aiden Bonar	Knee	TBC
Charlie Comben	Ankle	6 weeks
Luke Davies-Uniacke	Hamstring	2 weeks
Brayden George	Knee	Season
Josh Goater	Knee	3 weeks
Jack Mahony	Shoulder	Season
Curtis Taylor	Foot	Test
Tristan Xerri	Ankle	3 weeks
Updated: Tuesday, May 30

 

[Farthers]

PLAYER	INJURY	ESTIMATED RETURN
Aiden Bonar	Knee	TBC
Charlie Comben	Ankle	6 weeks
Luke Davies-Uniacke	Hamstring	2 weeks
Brayden George	Knee	Season
Josh Goater	Knee	3 weeks
Jack Mahony	Shoulder	Season
Curtis Taylor	Foot	Test
Tristan Xerri	Ankle	3 weeks
Updated: Tuesday, May 30

Hamish Free?

 

[Sphynx]

We are absolutely bonkers if we consider bringing Shiels back onto a wing with what Ford has shown the last 2 weeks there.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

PLAYER	INJURY	ESTIMATED RETURN
Aiden Bonar	Knee	TBC
Charlie Comben	Ankle	6 weeks
Luke Davies-Uniacke	Hamstring	2 weeks
Brayden George	Knee	Season
Josh Goater	Knee	3 weeks
Jack Mahony	Shoulder	Season
Curtis Taylor	Foot	Test
Tristan Xerri	Ankle	3 weeks
Updated: Tuesday, May 30

LDU - 2 Weeks.

 

[The Nostradamus]

PLAYER	INJURY	ESTIMATED RETURN
Aiden Bonar	Knee	TBC
Charlie Comben	Ankle	6 weeks
Luke Davies-Uniacke	Hamstring	2 weeks
Brayden George	Knee	Season
Josh Goater	Knee	3 weeks
Jack Mahony	Shoulder	Season
Curtis Taylor	Foot	Test
Tristan Xerri	Ankle	3 weeks
Updated: Tuesday, May 30

wheres hamish free
thought he was out for the year with the shoulder also

 

[tazaa]

LDU - 2 Weeks.

He was 2 weeks last week.
It begins

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

He’s back for one round before our bye (if fit)

You simply don’t play him until after the bye.

Surely.

 

[tazaa]

He’s back for one round before our bye (if fit)

You simply don’t play him until after the bye.

Surely.

Agreed. There’s no point. Why risk him back down in Hobart to do it again?

Give him the bye, really hammer his training loads and see you in 4 weeks.

He’s the only best 22 player on that list.

Plus more exposure to Wardlaw and Phillips in the middle.

 

[Its a Process]

We are absolutely bonkers if we consider bringing Shiels back onto a wing with what Ford has shown the last 2 weeks there.

He would replace Howe - you generally need 3 players to go through the wing rotation.

I am very happy for him to come in for Howe.

 

[giantroo]

 

[giantroo]

 

[Ligma]

Slay xerri