The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[LemmingMaster]

Stanton v Cross?

Or basically any other player from around 380-420k Mark?

EDIT: I really want to pick Luke Hodge, do I take the one game with a gun on the bench or trade for him later?

 

[LemmingMaster]

fevola vs robert murphy ... that is seriously a flip of the coin ... any ideas on who will do better

Murphy, Fev is hit and miss.

 

[donbooger]

Stanton v Cross?

Or basically any other player from around 380-420k Mark?

EDIT: I really want to pick Luke Hodge, do I take the one game with a gun on the bench or trade for him later?

I took Hodge but i have a reserve centre who will be playing the first round so there is an adequate sub to for him.

Also i like cross he is ultra consistant and is on my team. Stanton is quality but essendon may have some emerging midfielders that could step up and take some of his load away.

 

[goal sneak]

Nicoski or Hurn?

 

[blue_boys]

i'd go with nicoski

Who is better from these options:

Lovett-Murray (does anyone know if he'll be playing loose man like a couple years ago) or Kennelly or Pettard

and

Hawkins or Richard Douglas

 

[samwise]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Yes it is really worth having C. Cornes.

Think you would be better off with H.Shaw/Milburn/etc and Brett Jones than Waters and Birchall. If cost allows for those changes.

problem with brett jones for waters or birchall is i believe waters is better than birchall and therefore i will be left with both west coast's flankers which is not good. had birchall last year just bad with so many hawthorn possesion getters it is hard for him to ever get more than 80-100. so the question now is

birchall + jones
or
waters + jones (both west coast)

guessin most will say waters, jones

- in the mean time i have traded waters for jones and traded birchall for bowden to have bowden + newman in the team. this is possibly worse than 2 west coasts. bowden is like sam fisher in that they have to have key defensive roles as well makin them risky.

dono what do you guys think?

waters/birchall/jones/bowden/birchall/newman

pick 3

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

i'd go with nicoski

Who is better from these options:

Lovett-Murray (does anyone know if he'll be playing loose man like a couple years ago) or Kennelly or Pettard

and

Hawkins or Richard Douglas

1st option

going for two different midfield set ups
which one?
Scotland, Cross, Stanton, houli, stevens, macnamara
or
Salopek, Cooney, Stanton, N Jones, stevens, houli
Not much variation I know
PS I 'm including stanton no matter what

 

[Dr diagnosis]

1st option



going for two different midfield set ups

which one?

Scotland, Cross, Stanton, houli, stevens, macnamara

or

Salopek, Cooney, Stanton, N Jones, stevens, houli

Not much variation I know

PS I 'm including stanton no matter what

definetly set up 2

can someone help me with some choices...

in the backline
waters or birchall?
Nicoski or barlow?

midfield
dyson or houli?

in the forward line
ROK or Cloke?

thanks for your help

 

[fjm9]

Porplysia and Morton
or
Vince and Houli

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

definetly set up 2

can someone help me with some choices...

in the backline
waters or birchall?
Nicoski or barlow?

midfield
dyson or houli?

in the forward line
ROK or Cloke?

thanks for your help

waters
barlow
houli
cloke

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

Porplysia and Morton
or
Vince and Houli

Don't like your player choices but
I'd have the 1st option because they are guaranteed games, while vince probably won't play half the time

 

[fjm9]

Don't like your player choices but
I'd have the 1st option because they are guaranteed games, while vince probably won't play have the time

Cheers although,they're actually not my players, just prices of players that surround the ones I actually have.

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

Cheers although,they're actually not my players, just prices of players that surround the ones I actually have.

what was the point of asking?

 

[pieman123]

Riewoldt or J brown and
Newman and Gilbee or Waters and Birchall??

 

[Hirdy!!]

Who would be the better option to start on field, Craig Bird or Cyril Rioli?

And i know they are in different possies..

 

[samwise]

for backline:

bowden + newman

or
waters + nicoski

 

[fjm9]

what was the point of asking?

For the setup of my team, do I go more evenly spread with a $170k and 190k or a 250k and 100k.

 

[Hirdy!!]

for backline:

bowden + newman

or
waters + nicoski

How does that work?
A 410k + 330k v a 340k + 210k?

 

[samwise]

How does that work?
A 410k + 330k v a 340k + 210k?

i got money

 

[Jimi]

Nash vs Jones

 

[BlahBlahBlah]

fevola vs robert murphy ... that is seriously a flip of the coin ... any ideas on who will do better

I'd go the Fev.
He's due for a biggie, and considering that he now has Judd & Stevo on top of Murphy, Scotland, Carrazzo, Simpson amongst other delivering it too him - he could be the one.

Plus, he's been up nice and close to Lara B

 

[blue_boys]

Brad Johnson and L.Hansen

or

Pavich and Scott D Thompson(north)

????

 

[rossi]

Waters or Newman?

 

[thewhippersnapper]

i got money

Bowden and Waters then...

 

[BlahBlahBlah]

Brad Johnson and L.Hansen

or

Pavich and Scott D Thompson(north)

????

Brown in Hansen and pocket the 30k.