The Top 10 Thread

[gandaal]

This is a thread for all the various lists people come up with about footy (best coaches, best players, best divers, worst umpires, ect). It can be in response to lists by others or you can post your own on a completely different topic, and it doesn't even have to be a top 10. It could be a top 56 if that's what you want.

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order):

Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
Rhys Palmer (Fre)
Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
David Myers (Ess)
Andrejs Everitt (WB)
Tom Hawkins (Gee)
Cale Morton (Melb)
Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
Christopher Mayne (Fre)
Cyril Rioli (Haw)
Brad Ebert (WC)
Chris Masten (WC)
Trent Cotchin (Rich)
Kyle Reimers (Ess)
Jarryd Morton (Haw)
Lachlan Hansen (NM)
Nathan Brown (Coll)
Travis Boak (Port)
Craig Bird (Syd)
Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)

 

[MF]

This is a thread for all the various lists people come up with about footy (best coaches, best players, best divers, worst umpires, ect). It can be in response to lists by others or you can post your own on a completely different topic, and it doesn't even have to be a top 10. It could be a top 56 if that's what you want.

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order):

Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
Rhys Palmer (Fre)
Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
David Myers (Ess)
Andrejs Everitt (WB)
Tom Hawkins (Gee)
Cale Morton (Melb)
Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
Christopher Mayne (Fre)
Cyril Rioli (Haw)
Brad Ebert (WC)
Chris Masten (WC)
Trent Cotchin (Rich)
Kyle Reimers (Ess)
Jarryd Morton (Haw)
Lachlan Hansen (NM)
Nathan Brown (Coll)
Travis Boak (Port)
Craig Bird (Syd)
Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)

I would have thought Cotchin and Rioli would be a bit higher than that? It looks like you've just thrown Gibbs at 1, Kreuzer at 3 and then raffled the rest.

Top 5 AFL Venues:

1. MCG
2. Telstra Dome
3. SCG
4. Subiaco
5. ANZ Stadium

 

[Big Bryza]

This is a thread for all the various lists people come up with about footy (best coaches, best players, best divers, worst umpires, ect). It can be in response to lists by others or you can post your own on a completely different topic, and it doesn't even have to be a top 10. It could be a top 56 if that's what you want.

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order):

Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
Rhys Palmer (Fre)
Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
David Myers (Ess)
Andrejs Everitt (WB)
Tom Hawkins (Gee)
Cale Morton (Melb)
Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
Christopher Mayne (Fre)
Cyril Rioli (Haw)
Brad Ebert (WC)
Chris Masten (WC)
Trent Cotchin (Rich)
Kyle Reimers (Ess)
Jarryd Morton (Haw)
Lachlan Hansen (NM)
Nathan Brown (Coll)
Travis Boak (Port)
Craig Bird (Syd)
Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)

Nowhere near the top 20atm

 

[Captain_Judd]

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order):

Do you 2 guys have problems reading of something?

 

[The Dustbin]

I would have thought Cotchin and Rioli would be a bit higher than that? It looks like you've just thrown Gibbs at 1, Kreuzer at 3 and then raffled the rest.

Read the thread correctly.

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order).

 

[Pivo]

This is a thread for all the various lists people come up with about footy (best coaches, best players, best divers, worst umpires, ect). It can be in response to lists by others or you can post your own on a completely different topic, and it doesn't even have to be a top 10. It could be a top 56 if that's what you want.

Here's my top 20 teenages playing AFL footy at the minute (in no particular order):

Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
Rhys Palmer (Fre)
Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
David Myers (Ess)
Andrejs Everitt (WB)
Tom Hawkins (Gee)
Cale Morton (Melb)
Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
Christopher Mayne (Fre)
Cyril Rioli (Haw)
Brad Ebert (WC)
Chris Masten (WC)
Trent Cotchin (Rich)
Kyle Reimers (Ess)
Jarryd Morton (Haw)
Lachlan Hansen (NM)
Nathan Brown (Coll)
Travis Boak (Port)
Craig Bird (Syd)
Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)

I realise this is personal opinion and I read this a couple of times looking for a catch.

I'm staggered Joel Selwood isn't in this list.

 

[pinkus maximus]

I realise this is personal opinion and I read this a couple of times looking for a catch.

I'm staggered Joel Selwood isn't in this list.

selwood is not a teenager anymore?

ps. this thread's going well

 

[gandaal]

I didn't want to do a top 20 in order because I didn't want to claim that I had expert knowledge of every player in the AFL but I'll give it a go if that's what some people want

Top 20 (not based on potential)

1. Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
2. Trent Cotchin (Rich)
3. Rhys Palmer (Fre)
4. Cyril Rioli (Haw)
5. Travis Boak (Port)
6. Nathan Brown (Coll)
7. Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
8. Brad Ebert (WC)
9. Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)
10. Cale Morton (Melb)
11. Jarryd Morton (Haw)
12. Tom Hawkins (Gee)
13. Kyle Reimers (Ess)
14. Andrejs Everitt (WB)
15. David Myers (Ess)
16. Craig Bird (Syd)
17. Christopher Mayne (Fre)
18. Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
19. Chris Masten (WC)
20. Lachlan Hansen (NM)

Selwood is 20 years old.

 

[Pivo]

selwood is not a teenager anymore?

ps. this thread's going well

Fair call - missed it by that much Sure I heard he was still 19 but clearly not.

I need to check my facts before typing.

 

[Masten2McKinley]

your missing Joel Selwood

Joel Selwood >>>>>>>>>>>>> any teenager

 

[WOTTAMACHINE]

your missing Joel Selwood

Joel Selwood >>>>>>>>>>>>> any teenager

Read above^^^^^

 

[Silvagnis]

your missing Joel Selwood

Joel Selwood >>>>>>>>>>>>> any teenager

Can't you read and spell?

Selwood is 20 years old.

 

[MF]

Read the thread correctly.

Never!

It gets difficult trying to alt tab between BF and my work without getting busted. Rookie mistake.

 

[11sjw]

Do you 2 guys have problems reading of something?

Not as much as you do with spelling..."teenagers" is the word you were after.

 

[MF]

Do you 2 guys have problems reading of something?

I do now.

 

[Neville Bartos]

Top 10 Playing Surfaces (and I know this because I'm a 342 game veteran who's played them all

1. Aurora Stadium
2. MCG
3. AAMI Stadium
4. Telstra Dome
5. Skilled Stadium
6. Carrara
7. Manuka
8. Subiaco
9. SCG
10. Gabba


Doesn't rate a mention: ANZ Stadium

 

[Neville Bartos]

Top 10 worst hair styles of 2008:

1. Nathan Carroll (The tuft)
2. Chance Bateman (Predator)
3. Shaun McManus (Shitty Surfie Boof)
4. Chris Mayne (Copycat surfy boof)
5. Cameron Ling (Red mane)
6. Jarrod Harbrow (rats tail)
7. Matt Priddis (Surf boof III)
8. Matthew Lloyd (same haircut for 18 years)
9. Gary Ablett (he has to be shit at something)
10. Dale Thomas (14 year old female hair)

 

[gandaal]

Top 10 Playing Surfaces (and I know this because I'm a 342 game veteran who's played them all

1. Aurora Stadium
2. MCG
3. AAMI Stadium
4. Telstra Dome
5. Skilled Stadium
6. Carrara
7. Manuka
8. Subiaco
9. SCG
10. Gabba


Doesn't rate a mention: ANZ Stadium

If Telstra Dome is 4th that's says plenty about some of the other grounds footy is played on

 

[fish_bowl]

top beers... tiger, VB, tsing toa, valour, blue ice

top 10 to never win a B&F

(no particular order)

darren bewick
tyson edwards
ryan okeefe
nick winmar
sean wellman
fev
mark mercuri
akermanis
cox
rodan


very unrearshed... sure i missed some biggies

 

[The Passenger]

top 10 to never win a B&F

that's a good one and i'd have to look into later.

always see topics such as best players to never win a brownlow but it usually just contains the best players of all time less a handful that won them. only 8 of the 21 in the AFL's official team of the century won a brownlow (not that the team is undisputedly the 21 best players in league history).

Even the players that missed out on that team who numerous people claim should've or could've been in the team never won a brownlow - Wayne Carey, Dermott Brereton, Peter Hudson, Gordon Coventry, Peter Daicos, Barry Davis, David Dench, Robert Flower, Darrel Baldock, Malcolm Blight, Geoff Southby, Jack Regan, Simon Madden (and several others).... all players who could slot into that team quite comfortably but never won a brownlow.

 

[AG]

Top 10 players I have seen (since 1996):
1. James Hird
2. Wayne Carey
3. Simon Black - very underated IMO.
4. Ben Cousins
5. Michael Voss
6. Chris Judd
7. Tony Lockett
8. Nathan Buckley
9. Andrew McLeod
10. Paul Kelly

Didn't see much of Gary Ablett or Greg Williams.

 

[AG]

Top 10 Swans players I've seen:
1. Tony Lockett
2. Paul Kelly
3. Michael O'Loughlin
4. Tadgh Kennelly
5. Adam Goodes
6. Stuart Maxfield
7. Barry Hall
8. Brett Kirk
9. Daryn Cresswell
10. Ryan O'Keefe

 

[TassieSaint]

top beers... tiger, VB, tsing toa, valour, blue ice

top 10 to never win a B&F

nick winmar

Nicky Winmar was a dual best and fairest winner (winning from the likes of Lockett, Harvey and Burke no less). You're probably thinking of Michael Long

 

[gandaal]

Top 10 Carlton Players I have seen
1. Greg Williams
2. Stephen Silvagni
3. Stephen Kernahan
4. Craig Bradley
5. Anthony Koutoufidies
6. Brendan Fevola
7. Brett Ratten
8. Peter Dean
9. Andrew McKay
10. Michael Sexton

 

[SaintsPremiers08]

I didn't want to do a top 20 in order because I didn't want to claim that I had expert knowledge of every player in the AFL but I'll give it a go if that's what some people want

Top 20 (not based on potential)

1. Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
2. Trent Cotchin (Rich)
3. Rhys Palmer (Fre)
4. Cyril Rioli (Haw)
5. Travis Boak (Port)
6. Nathan Brown (Coll)
7. Matthew Kruezer (Carl)
8. Brad Ebert (WC)
9. Jack Reiwoldt (Rich)
10. Cale Morton (Melb)
11. Jarryd Morton (Haw)
12. Tom Hawkins (Gee)
13. Kyle Reimers (Ess)
14. Andrejs Everitt (WB)
15. David Myers (Ess)
16. Craig Bird (Syd)
17. Christopher Mayne (Fre)
18. Austin Wonaeamirri (Melb)
19. Chris Masten (WC)
20. Lachlan Hansen (NM)

Selwood is 20 years old.

Cmon.....Armitage >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hansen