The Top 30 Performers of 07.

[Trump]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Daniel Kerr
3. Chad Cornes
4. Matthew Pavlich
5. Jonathon Brown
6. Brent Harvey
7. James Bartel
8. Joel Corey
9. Kane Cornes
10. Darren Glass
11. Dustin Fletcher
12. Nathan Foley
13. Sam Mitchell
14. Simon Black
15. Nick Reiwvoldt.
16. Dean Cox
17. Scott Lucas
18. Chris Judd
19. Kade Simpson
20. Matthew Scarlett
21. Sam Fisher
22. Adam Simpson
23. Hamish Mcintosh
24. Peter Burgoyne
25. Steve Johnson
26. Peter Bell
27. Jed Adcock
28. Brendon Lade
29. Luke Hodge
30. Buddy Franklin.

Discuss

 

[Shaymuhz]

reckon daniel kerr is a bit high at 2..

 

[hype]

Not too bad.. you might have missed a few from the other clubs.

 

[dodgyJim]

Surely you can find room for Priddis in there somewhere can't you. I think he has been an absolute gun this year for the Eagles.

 

[MaccaHawk]

Good effort.

Looking out for my own club's players, I reckon either Sam Mitchell or Luke Hodge should be in the top 10. Brad Sewell and Jordan Lewis also deserve a mention on this list. I'd have put them both in before Peter Bell or Steve Johnson.

 

[Bollox]

Glass at 10 and Scarlett at 20 ?

Might be an idea to reverse that so your bias doesnt ruin the thread

 

[Chewy]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Daniel Kerr
3. Chad Cornes
4. Matthew Pavlich
5. Jonathon Brown
6. Brent Harvey
7. James Bartel
8. Joel Corey
9. Kane Cornes
10. Darren Glass
11. Dustin Fletcher
12. Nathan Foley
13. Sam Mitchell
14. Simon Black
15. Nick Reiwvoldt.
16. Dean Cox
17. Scott Lucas
18. Chris Judd
19. Kade Simpson
20. Matthew Scarlett
21. Sam Fisher
22. Adam Simpson
23. Hamish Mcintosh
24. Peter Burgoyne
25. Steve Johnson
26. Peter Bell
27. Jed Adcock
28. Brendon Lade
29. Luke Hodge
30. Buddy Franklin.

Discuss

Luke Hodge has been far superior in 2007 to each of the following footballers:

10. Darren Glass
11. Dustin Fletcher
12. Nathan Foley
13. Sam Mitchell
14. Simon Black
16. Dean Cox
17. Scott Lucas
18. Chris Judd
19. Kade Simpson
20. Matthew Scarlett
21. Sam Fisher
22. Adam Simpson
23. Hamish Mcintosh
24. Peter Burgoyne
25. Steve Johnson
26. Peter Bell
27. Jed Adcock
28. Brendon Lade
30. Buddy Franklin.

I would have him in my Top 10, definitely in my top 15.
I think he is truly one of the elite players in the game, although no doubt, Bollox will call me biased.

I find it hilarious that some people only notice him when he cuts loose and dominates like last Sunday and kicks 6 goals.

He is EASILY Hawthorn's best footballer, for f**k's sake.

Oh, that's right!

We're hardly ever on free-to-air TV, so people don't really know.

 

[Big Nasty]

There is no way Glass is better than Scarlett.

 

[Dissident]

Good to know we can finish in the top half (hopefully) without one player in your top 30.

 

[scottydeewah]

Brad Sewell and Jordan Lewis also deserve a mention on this list. I'd have put them both in before Peter Bell or Steve Johnson

I think you underestimate how good a year this bloke is having.

 

[Budda 230]

Kade Simpson isn't top 30. Had a decent year but definitely not Top 30.

 

[noosa hawk mad]

With Brown & Pavlich 4 & 5 Surely Buddy should be in top 10

 

[FIGJAM]

Good to know we can finish in the top half (hopefully) without one player in your top 30.

Same. It's nice to have quiet achievers.

Tarkyn Lockyer has been fantastic for us, and Scotty Burns has been a super-hero (in terms of TOG, I reckon he'd be #1 for clearances in the comp).

 

[MarkT]

All in all not a bad effort and good on you for having a crack.

Since you asked to discuss, a couple of comments:

Fletcher at 11 is about 89 places too high. At the very least he has to be behind Scarlett but he is generally over rated anyway and this has been far from his best year. While I have never been a big Tarkyn Lockyer fan he has been Collingwood’s best performer this year and should be somewhere around top 20. He should be well ahead of Kade Simpson. I’d also have Scott Burns in there somewhere. His clearance work has been central to Collingwood being in the 8.

Edit: I see Figjam beat me to it re Lockyer and Burns. Great minds….

 

[Waverley73]

It's good to see a non-Geelong supporter acknowledge the season Steve Johnson is having. His stats are comparable with Riewoldt this year:


...............Riewoldt....S Johnson
Games........19................16
Av Disp........18................18.3
Av Marks......9.7...............7.2
Av Tack........1...................2.1
Tot Goals.....39..................38
Av Goals......2.1.................2.4

 

[Asgardian]

Okay, this is my list

1/- Daniel Kerr
2/- Chad Cornes
3/- Gary Ablett Jr.
4/- Matthew Pavlich
5/- James Bartel
6/- Jonathon Brown
7/- Luke Hodge
8/- Nick Riewoldt
9/- Scott West
10/- Kane Cornes
11/- Sam Mitchell
12/- Andrew McLeod
13/- Dean Cox
14/- Joel Corey
15/- Darren Glass
16/- Josh Carr
17/- Lance Franklin
18/- Matthew Scarlett
19/- Hamish McIntosh
20/- Simon Black
21/- Chris Judd
22/- Ben Rutten
23/- Brendon Lade
24/- Nathan Foley
25/- Brett Harvey
26/- Shaun Burgoyne
27/- Marc Murphy
28/- Brett Kirk
29/- Heath Shaw
30/- Scott Lucas

 

[trueblue_91]

Kade Simpson isn't top 30. Had a decent year but definitely not Top 30.

Simpson not top 30.

Would only be carrazo for us he has had dominated for us this year

 

[trueblue_91]

Okay, this is my list

1/- Daniel Kerr
2/- Chad Cornes
3/- Gary Ablett Jr.
4/- Matthew Pavlich
5/- James Bartel
6/- Jonathon Brown
7/- Luke Hodge
8/- Nick Riewoldt
9/- Scott West
10/- Kane Cornes
11/- Sam Mitchell
12/- Andrew McLeod
13/- Dean Cox
14/- Joel Corey
15/- Darren Glass
16/- Josh Carr
17/- Lance Franklin
18/- Matthew Scarlett
19/- Hamish McIntosh
20/- Simon Black
21/- Chris Judd
22/- Ben Rutten
23/- Brendon Lade
24/- Nathan Foley
25/- Brett Harvey
26/- Shaun Burgoyne
27/- Marc Murphy
28/- Brett Kirk
29/- Rhyce Shaw
30/- Scott Lucas

Rhyce Shaw

 

[Big Nasty]

Okay, this is my list

1/- Daniel Kerr
2/- Chad Cornes
3/- Gary Ablett Jr.
4/- Matthew Pavlich
5/- James Bartel
6/- Jonathon Brown
7/- Luke Hodge
8/- Nick Riewoldt
9/- Scott West
10/- Kane Cornes
11/- Sam Mitchell
12/- Andrew McLeod
13/- Dean Cox
14/- Joel Corey
15/- Darren Glass
16/- Josh Carr
17/- Lance Franklin
18/- Matthew Scarlett
19/- Hamish McIntosh
20/- Simon Black
21/- Chris Judd
22/- Ben Rutten
23/- Brendon Lade
24/- Nathan Foley
25/- Brett Harvey
26/- Shaun Burgoyne
27/- Marc Murphy
28/- Brett Kirk
29/- Rhyce Shaw
30/- Scott Lucas

Scarlett below Glass
Also Abletts been the best performed player this season.

 

[MarkT]

Okay, this is my list

29/- Rhyce Shaw

Did you mean Heath?

 

[TheBigUnit]

Luke Hodge has been far superior in 2007 to each of the following footballers:

10. Darren Glass
11. Dustin Fletcher
12. Nathan Foley
13. Sam Mitchell
14. Simon Black
16. Dean Cox
17. Scott Lucas
18. Chris Judd
19. Kade Simpson
20. Matthew Scarlett
21. Sam Fisher
22. Adam Simpson
23. Hamish Mcintosh
24. Peter Burgoyne
25. Steve Johnson
26. Peter Bell
27. Jed Adcock
28. Brendon Lade
30. Buddy Franklin.

I would have him in my Top 10, definitely in my top 15.
I think he is truly one of the elite players in the game, although no doubt, Bollox will call me biased.

I find it hilarious that some people only notice him when he cuts loose and dominates like last Sunday and kicks 6 goals.

He is EASILY Hawthorn's best footballer, for f**k's sake.

Oh, that's right!

We're hardly ever on free-to-air TV, so people don't really know.

You're overrating his season IMO (I'd only have him DEFINITELY ahead of the bolded names). I don't think anyone's disputing that he's a very good player. While he has had some incredible games in the 2nd half of the season, his early season form was average and throughout the season he has lacked consistency to be a top 10. I would also have Mitchell and Buddy ahead of him from a Hawthorn perspective this year.

 

[Asgardian]

Did you mean Heath?

Yes, sorry, my mistake

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Did you mean Heath?

He damn well better have, because Rhyce won't finish in the Top 10 in our B&F this year.

Meanwhile, Tarkyn Lockyer is going to walk in to the Copeland trophy this year, yet he can't get any recognition.

 

[CAUSE FOR CONCERN]

glass 07 >>>>>>>> scarlett 07

 

[Nightwolf]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Daniel Kerr
3. Jonathan Brown
4. Chad Cornes (god that hurt)
5. Matthew Pavlich
6. Jimmy Bartel
7. Luke Hodge
8. Nick Reiwoldt
9. Joel Corey
10. Dean Cox
11. Brent Harvey
12. Lance Franklin
13. Andrew McLeod
14. Matthew Scarlett
15. Sam Mitchell
16. Nathan Foley
17. Kane Cornes
18. Hamish McIntosh
19. Jed Adcock
20. Brett Kirk
21. Andrew Carrazzo
22. Heath Shaw
23. Steve Johnson
24. Sam Fisher
25. Brad Ottens
26. Matthew Richardson
27. Drew Petrie
28. Scott Lucas
29. Chris Judd
30. Campbell Brown