Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
If Hawks miss finals then their first plus somethingWhat do you think goes close.
I think the start is
1st and pies 2nd
Then probably moves to 1st , f1 and 2nd then swap of picks
Hawks 1st a 4th and DGB for Barrass AND a 2nd rounder? No wayHawks 1st and one of their 4th rounders and DGB for WCE's 2nd would be WIN/WIN for both teams IMO
DGB gets to go home to try to resurrect his career and Barass gets to go to a team ready to be contenders
I recon due to the quality in this draft, WC is taking Hawks 1st & DGB for Barrass. Unless Hawks start winning finals, 2-3 spots won't matter. Pick 10 is pretty spot on.Hawks 1st a 4th and DGB for Barrass AND a 2nd rounder? No way
All those for Barrass alone maybe, at a stretch. Should be something a little better than that added to the first rounder
DGB is worth next to nothing right now
Eagles have to factor in Gov finishing up soon. It's a dangerous spot to be having no AFL standard KPDs.I recon due to the quality in this draft, WC is taking Hawks 1st & DGB for Barrass. Unless Hawks start winning finals, 2-3 spots won't matter. Pick 10 is pretty spot on.
While he's no Barrass or Gov, Edwards is AFL standard. But you're right in that we don't have depth in the positionEagles have to factor in Gov finishing up soon. It's a dangerous spot to be having no AFL standard KPDs.
The concern is he's not proven as a no1 KPD standard player. He looks good with quality support but it's a risk relying on him to be the guy with no form there.While he's no Barrass or Gov, Edwards is AFL standard. But you're right in that we don't have depth in the position
They are rebuilding from a bad position, they are going to have to take some risks for once with trading out.The concern is he's not proven as a no1 KPD standard player. He looks good with quality support but it's a risk relying on him to be the guy with no form there.
I think the key is whether there is any fringe experienced KPD they can bring in on the cheap. Honestly, if Hawks are getting Barrass AND Battle, WC could do worse than demand Frosty get chucked in as steaknives...Eagles have to factor in Gov finishing up soon. It's a dangerous spot to be having no AFL standard KPDs.
Eagles should ask for first round picks this year and next and find out how hungry the Hawks are for the player.
He's 31 next month. Could go out the same time as Gov.I think the key is whether there is any fringe experienced KPD they can bring in on the cheap. Honestly, if Hawks are getting Barrass AND Battle, WC could do worse than demand Frosty get chucked in as steaknives...
He's been really good this year. A very good stop gap for a couple of years until your developing talls come through isn't a bad deal TBH. Whether Frosty would want to move is another thing. He's pretty popular amongst the playing group.I think the key is whether there is any fringe experienced KPD they can bring in on the cheap. Honestly, if Hawks are getting Barrass AND Battle, WC could do worse than demand Frosty get chucked in as steaknives...
They can ask but there's no chance Hawthorn will trade 2 firsts for Barrass.
Collingwoods 2nd and a future first or our current first and future 2nd is the best offer they'll get.
Can only speak from experience but when we offloaded Mitchell and O'Meara and then bundled the picks we got for them to trade up for an extra 1st and landed Weddle. We also opened up the midfield for the next generation to find their way and develop.
I believe WC could see a similar benefit from moving on Barrass for a first. Your argument is they would benefit more from keeping him and paying the extra 250k. Hard to say which one if is right without knowing their complete strategy for the rebuild.
They do still have Mcgovern as the experienced defender that will help mentor the young defenders.
Nah, if Barrass was uncontracted id take the Hawks 1st and DGB(who again, is worth nothing).I recon due to the quality in this draft, WC is taking Hawks 1st & DGB for Barrass. Unless Hawks start winning finals, 2-3 spots won't matter. Pick 10 is pretty spot on.
Out future 1st won’t be in any part of the trade.Nah, if Barrass was uncontracted id take the Hawks 1st and DGB(who again, is worth nothing).
Hes got 3 years so the offer has to be better than that.
Hawks 1st + pies 2nd, or Hawks 1st+F1 for Barrass and a 2nd rounder
I think that’s a fair trade for all.Imagine it will be
Hawks 1st rounder + future 2nd + 27 + 71 for Barass + 23 + 59
Eagles drop down the order a tiny bit in both rounds. Pick 59 for us means nothing cos our last pick will hopefully be used for Malaki Champion anyway so thats a no loss situation for us
Lock her in Eddie