Traded Tom Barrass & 2025 F4 (WCE) traded to Hawthorn for 2025 F1, F2 & F3 (all Haw)

[HeHateMe]

Trade period will probably play out like this:

• WC will ask for 11 + F1st for Barrass + F2nd
• Hawthorn will offer 27 + F2nd for Barrass + F3rd
• WC will say no and ask for a 1st Rd pick to be included.
• Hawthorn will offer either 11 or F1st.
• WC will ask for 27 or F2nd to be included as well.
• Hawthorn will offer 11 + F3rd.
• WC will counter 11 + F2nd.
• Hawthorn will put final offer 11 + F2nd for Barrass + F3rd.
• Will drag out till finals minutes of trade deadline with threats from both sides of walking away.
• minutes before trade deadline closes
• Hawthorn offer 11 + F2nd
• WC accept, paperwork lodged.

Also BTW we are now here

 

[bzparkes]

Eagles not going to give Barrass up without good compensation for a required , contracted player .

After trying to trade pick 4, F1st and Brockman for pick 1 last year, we can assume Hawthorn LM team are pretty clueless.

 

[hawkinoz]

Not enough from the Hawks.
Swans are offering 19+22 for 13, Hawks are also offering f1+f2 for 13
Hawks have one of the worst offers for 13, Swans one of the best

Hawks would have to give up at least f1+f2 for the 2 swans picks(maybe a touch more?)

I think the Eagles would take those 2 picks, and send one of them to Richmond for Baker.
Not really an ideal deal at all, I still want more than just the original pick 14 that the Hawks offered(which is their f1+f2)

19+22+another future 2nd or 3rd rounder for points

See as I said before.. Entitled..

Want Hawks to do the hustle and then pick up all the fruits.

We just walk away if that is the attitude.

 

[stallon]

See as I said before.. Entitled..

Want Hawks to do the hustle and then pick up all the fruits.

We just walk away if that is the attitude.

If youre not going to read what I wrote, or youre too stupid to understand it, please dont respond to me.

 

[hawksalltheway]

F1 and F2, eagles trying for more, but the deal will get done...more than fair

 

[hawkinoz]

If youre not going to read what I wrote, or youre too stupid to understand it, please dont respond to me.

Correct me if I am wrong...

You want 19+22+another future 2nd

We do the Hustle and you eat the fruits..

If that happens, you still get only 19+F2

Why strive to convert 13 to more if you are going to eat it all?

We just offer 13 for your 26+Barass and be done with it

 

[stallon]

Correct me if I am wrong...

You want 19+22+another future 2nd

We do the Hustle and you eat the fruits..

If that happens, you still get only 19+F2

Why strive to convert 13 to more if you are going to eat it all?

We just offer 13 for your 26+Barass and be done with it

I said your f1+f3 wont get 19+22, as 19+22 is ballpark value for pick 13, and 13 will cost you at least f1+f2, not f1+f3.

Youll have to pay a f1+f2 for 19+22(which is roughly equal to 13).

Then its back to normal programming wanting the early teens first rounder(which is equal to 19+22)+ a f2

 

[Citizen Erazed]

I like that our team have more of a backbone this year and not playing the nice guys as usual. Haven't gone full Mackie yet, but it's nice to see.

 

[JackOutback]

3rd rounder. Never been AA - backs cooked.

Can't believe you're throwing so much money and years at such a spud

He'll be among your top five players.

 

[hawkinoz]

I said your f1+f3 wont get 19+22, as 19+22 is ballpark value for pick 13, and 13 will cost you at least f1+f2, not f1+f3.

Youll have to pay a f1+f2 for 19+22(which is roughly equal to 13).

Then its back to normal programming wanting the early teens first rounder(which is equal to 19+22)+ a f2

Ok... Lets assume we have 19,22,33, one each of F1 and F2

What deal will get Barrass done with your picks as of now given what we know your list manger asked and what was offered.

Did they ask for 1st rounder and 2nd rounder or mid teens pick and 2nd rounder?

 

[stallon]

Ok... Lets assume we have 19,22,33, one each of F1 and F2

What deal will get Barrass done with your picks as of now given what we know your list manger asked and what was offered.

Did they ask for 1st rounder and 2nd rounder or mid teens pick and 2nd rounder?

Not all first rounders are equal, why do I even have to say this?
Youre being intentionally stupid now

 

[hawkinoz]

Not all first rounders are equal, why do I even have to say this?
Youre being intentionally stupid now

Answer teh question and quit weasling out

Exactly why list mangers ask for pick in single digits, Top 5, Top 10, early teens, mid teens or late teens.

If Matty Clarke asked for 1st rounder and 2nd rounder, go have a chat with him on basic trade jargon.

Again answer the question and prove to us you and other Eagles fans are not entitled.

 

[THE_GUN]

Has it been clarified exact what the offer was from Hawks prior to them swapping the pick #14 with Carlton
Keep hearing #14+F2 with Barrass + F3 coming back

If this was the offer i think the eagles missed a great opportunity and doubt they get a better result

 

[stallon]

Answer teh question and quit weasling out

Exactly why list mangers ask for pick in single digits, Top 5, Top 10, early teens, mid teens or late teens.

If Matty Clarke asked for 1st rounder and 2nd rounder, go have a chat with him on basic trade jargon.

Again answer the question and prove to us you and other Eagles fans are not entitled.

List managers do specify what they want, but not to the general public. They prefer to keep negotiations behind closed doors

Are you actually for real?

 

[triple treat]

Can't believe you're throwing so much money and years at such a spud

He'll be among your top five players.

Cause he'll be among them all 23 players are among them on game day. i dare say they get among them out of footy as well!

 

[stallon]

Has it been clarified exact what the offer was from Hawks prior to them swapping the pick #14 with Carlton
Keep hearing #14+F2 with Barrass + F3 coming back

If this was the offer i think the eagles missed a great opportunity and doubt they get a better result

Would've been just 14.
F1+f2 for Barrass+f3 theyre offering now is a worse offer than 14+f2 for Barrass+f3 that was originally reported. They surely wouldnt have done that trade unless they thought the f1+f2 would be more attractive than pick 14 alone.

 

[Come back Cyril]

Can't believe you're throwing so much money and years at such a spud

He'll be among your top five players.

My comment was a joke, a 3rd rounder is even more absurd than the ridiculoue 2 1st's hes a generational full back comments.

Top five players is also way off (and for what it's worth I think Barrass is very good at what he does and will be an excellent addition).

 

[kerrazy]

Roos absolutely torched the Hawks for their shambolic way in which they have negotiated for Barrass services.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Also BTW we are now here

Very impressive call

 

[THE_GUN]

Would've been just 14.
F1+f2 for Barrass+f3 theyre offering now is a worse offer than 14+f2 for Barrass+f3 that was originally reported. They surely wouldnt have done that trade unless they thought the f1+f2 would be more attractive than pick 14 alone.

So have the eagles now given up on 2 x F2 picks

 

[stallon]

My comment was a joke, a 3rd rounder is even more absurd than the ridiculoue 2 1st's hes a generational full back comments.

Top five players is also way off (and for what it's worth I think Barrass is very good at what he does and will be an excellent addition).

Barrass would be in or around the top 5 players at all clubs tbh

 

[stallon]

So have the eagles now given up on 2 x F2 picks

idk whats going on tbh

 

[Sirlemsip]

I like that our team have more of a backbone this year and not playing the nice guys as usual. Haven't gone full Mackie yet, but it's nice to see.

You realise that Hawks supporters are saying exactly the same thing regarding the Barrass situation.

 

[Sirlemsip]

Barrass would be in or around the top 5 players at all clubs tbh

Not at most clubs, and certainly not at ours.

Would definitely be behind: Day, Newcombe, Sicily, Moore, Scrimshaw, D'Ambrosio, and Lewis (when fit).
Would also be behind: Worpel, Impey, McDonald, Amon, Meek, Battle and Hardwick.
Would be on par with up and comers like: Weddle, Ward, Mackenzie.

At the end of the day, he isn't an essential need for us with Battle coming across, Frosty's form and Blanck likely ready to go from Round 1.

We don't need to offer overs, and whilst we would like him at the club we aren't going to bend over and overpay.

 

[stallon]

Not at most clubs, and certainly not at ours.

Would definitely be behind: Day, Newcombe, Sicily, Moore, Scrimshaw, D'Ambrosio, and Lewis (when fit).
Would also be behind: Worpel, Impey, McDonald, Amon, Meek, and Hardwick.
Would be on par with up and comers like: Weddle, Ward, Mackenzie.

At the end of the day, he isn't an essential need for us with Frosty's form and Blanck likely ready to go from Round 1.

We don't need to offer overs, and whilst we would like him at the club we aren't going to bend over and overpay.

Nice jokes mate.
Sicily, maybe Day and Duke, thats it.