Opinion My top 10- Positions-2024

Remove this Banner Ad

Lingsface

Lingsface

Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
May 9, 2005
5,412
3,609
perth
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
geelong
My top 10 in positions this year.

Small Forwards
1- Dylan Moore
2- Tyson Stengle
3- Toby Greene
4- Izak Rankine
5- Kysiah Pickett
6- Charlie Cameron
7- Brett Daniels
8- Jack Ginnivan
9- Ben Long
10- Jack Higgins

Tall Forwards
1- Jesse Hogan
2- Jeremy Cameron
3- Joe Daniher
4- Charlie Curnow
5- Jake Waterman
6- Harry Mckay
7- Ben King
8- J Ugle Hagan
9- Josh Treacy
10- Sam Darcy

Midfielders
1-Isacc Heeney
2- Marcus Bontempelli
3- Lachie Neale
4- Patrick Cripps
5- Nick Daicos
6- Caleb Serong
7- Zach Merrett
8- Errol Gulden
9- Zac Butters
10- Tom Green

Small/Medium Backmen-
1- Nick Blakey
2- Dane Zorko
3- Max Holmes
4- Luke Ryan
5- Andrew Mcgrath
6- Dan Houston
7- Zach Guthrie
8- Nick Vlaustin
9- Jack Sinclair
10- Blake Hardwick

Tall Defenders
1- Harris Andrews
2- Jacob Weitering
3- James Sicily
4- Jeremy Mcgovern
5- Tom Stewart
6- Liam Jones
7- Sam Taylor
8- Sam Collins
9- Alex Pearce
10-Callum Wilkie

Ruckmen
1- Max Gawn
2- Tristan Xerri
3- Rohan Marshall
4- Darcy Cameron
5- Luke Jackson
6- Tim English
7- Oscar Mcinerney
8- Tom De Koning
9- Jarrod Witts
10- Sean Darcy
 
How is Keays not on the small/medium forward list and Ben Long is
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Lingsface said:
My top 10 in positions this year.

Small Forwards
1- Dylan Moore
2- Tyson Stengle
3- Toby Greene
4- Izak Rankine
5- Kysiah Pickett
6- Charlie Cameron
7- Brett Daniels
8- Jack Ginnivan
9- Ben Long
10- Jack Higgins

Tall Forwards
1- Jesse Hogan
2- Jeremy Cameron
3- Joe Daniher
4- Charlie Curnow
5- Jake Waterman
6- Harry Mckay
7- Ben King
8- J Ugle Hagan
9- Josh Treacy
10- Sam Darcy

Midfielders
1-Isacc Heeney
2- Marcus Bontempelli
3- Lachie Neale
4- Patrick Cripps
5- Nick Daicos
6- Caleb Serong
7- Zach Merrett
8- Errol Gulden
9- Zac Butters
10- Tom Green

Small/Medium Backmen-
1- Nick Blakey
2- Dane Zorko
3- Max Holmes
4- Luke Ryan
5- Andrew Mcgrath
6- Dan Houston
7- Zach Guthrie
8- Nick Vlaustin
9- Jack Sinclair
10- Blake Hardwick

Tall Defenders
1- Harris Andrews
2- Jacob Weitering
3- James Sicily
4- Jeremy Mcgovern
5- Tom Stewart
6- Liam Jones
7- Sam Taylor
8- Sam Collins
9- Alex Pearce
10-Callum Wilkie

Ruckmen
1- Max Gawn
2- Tristan Xerri
3- Rohan Marshall
4- Darcy Cameron
5- Luke Jackson
6- Tim English
7- Oscar Mcinerney
8- Tom De Koning
9- Jarrod Witts
10- Sean Darcy
Click to expand...
Cripps + Daicos above Neale on the mids and id sneak in Nic Newman to the small defenders list. Treloar >Tom Green too.
 
Lingsface said:
My top 10 in positions this year.

Small Forwards
1- Dylan Moore
2- Tyson Stengle
3- Toby Greene
4- Izak Rankine
5- Kysiah Pickett
6- Charlie Cameron
7- Brett Daniels
8- Jack Ginnivan
9- Ben Long
10- Jack Higgins

Tall Forwards
1- Jesse Hogan
2- Jeremy Cameron
3- Joe Daniher
4- Charlie Curnow
5- Jake Waterman
6- Harry Mckay
7- Ben King
8- J Ugle Hagan
9- Josh Treacy
10- Sam Darcy

Midfielders
1-Isacc Heeney
2- Marcus Bontempelli
3- Lachie Neale
4- Patrick Cripps
5- Nick Daicos
6- Caleb Serong
7- Zach Merrett
8- Errol Gulden
9- Zac Butters
10- Tom Green

Small/Medium Backmen-
1- Nick Blakey
2- Dane Zorko
3- Max Holmes
4- Luke Ryan
5- Andrew Mcgrath
6- Dan Houston
7- Zach Guthrie
8- Nick Vlaustin
9- Jack Sinclair
10- Blake Hardwick

Tall Defenders
1- Harris Andrews
2- Jacob Weitering
3- James Sicily
4- Jeremy Mcgovern
5- Tom Stewart
6- Liam Jones
7- Sam Taylor
8- Sam Collins
9- Alex Pearce
10-Callum Wilkie

Ruckmen
1- Max Gawn
2- Tristan Xerri
3- Rohan Marshall
4- Darcy Cameron
5- Luke Jackson
6- Tim English
7- Oscar Mcinerney
8- Tom De Koning
9- Jarrod Witts
10- Sean Darcy
Click to expand...
Bailey Dale? Probably the most damaging hbf in the league should be #1
 
195cm Nick Blakey as a Small/Medium Backman, yet 189cm Sicily is a Tall Backman. Hmm.
 
Sixpence said:
That's irrelevant, they're mids.
Click to expand...
It is relevant in saying different heights still play different roles, Sicily is the second biggest Backman in his side so he has to play on big players more often. Swans have more options to take the big players and he plays a small role more than a big role.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Lingsface said:
It is relevant in saying different heights still play different roles, Sicily is the second biggest Backman in his side so he has to play on big players more often. Swans have more options to take the big players and he plays a small role more than a big role.
Click to expand...
The height of mids is irrelevant in a discussion about Defenders. And Sicily is the third biggest defender behind Frost and Scrimshaw (who have been our FB and CHB all year).

Blakey is a running half back, not specifically a "small" role.
 
Sixpence said:
The height of mids is irrelevant in a discussion about Defenders. And Sicily is the third biggest defender behind Frost and Scrimshaw (who have been our FB and CHB all year).

Blakey is a running half back, not specifically a "small" role.
Click to expand...
And KPP players who have played this role are?
 
Lingsface said:
My top 10 in positions this year.

Small Forwards
1- Dylan Moore
2- Tyson Stengle
3- Toby Greene
4- Izak Rankine
5- Kysiah Pickett
6- Charlie Cameron
7- Brett Daniels
8- Jack Ginnivan
9- Ben Long
10- Jack Higgins

Tall Forwards
1- Jesse Hogan
2- Jeremy Cameron
3- Joe Daniher
4- Charlie Curnow
5- Jake Waterman
6- Harry Mckay
7- Ben King
8- J Ugle Hagan
9- Josh Treacy
10- Sam Darcy

Midfielders
1-Isacc Heeney
2- Marcus Bontempelli
3- Lachie Neale
4- Patrick Cripps
5- Nick Daicos
6- Caleb Serong
7- Zach Merrett
8- Errol Gulden
9- Zac Butters
10- Tom Green

Small/Medium Backmen-
1- Nick Blakey
2- Dane Zorko
3- Max Holmes
4- Luke Ryan
5- Andrew Mcgrath
6- Dan Houston
7- Zach Guthrie
8- Nick Vlaustin
9- Jack Sinclair
10- Blake Hardwick

Tall Defenders
1- Harris Andrews
2- Jacob Weitering
3- James Sicily
4- Jeremy Mcgovern
5- Tom Stewart
6- Liam Jones
7- Sam Taylor
8- Sam Collins
9- Alex Pearce
10-Callum Wilkie

Ruckmen
1- Max Gawn
2- Tristan Xerri
3- Rohan Marshall
4- Darcy Cameron
5- Luke Jackson
6- Tim English
7- Oscar Mcinerney
8- Tom De Koning
9- Jarrod Witts
10- Sean Darcy
Click to expand...

Cripps and Daicos have to be one and two for mids. One of them will win the Coaches award and both are Brownlow favourites. They have been better than Neale and Bont this year.
 
South of the Yarra said:
Cripps and Daicos have to be one and two for mids. One of them will win the Coaches award and both are Brownlow favourites. They have been better than Neale and Bont this year.
Click to expand...
I don’t think so, I think Neale and Bont have been more damaging and Heeney was miles ahead in the first half of the year and has strung together a few bog games to go with that at the end of the season. Neale has won so much critical ball and his kicking has gone to another level this year.
 
Lingsface said:
I don’t think so, I think Neale and Bont have been more damaging and Heeney was miles ahead in the first half of the year and has strung together a few bog games to go with that at the end of the season. Neale has won so much critical ball and his kicking has gone to another level this year.
Click to expand...

Nick Daicos has just won ABC Footballer of the Year. Daicos and Cripps have just tied for SEN player of the year. It will most likely be Daicos and Cripps who fight out the coaches award and the Brownlow. Daicos has averaged more goals than Neale, more disposals, more tackles, more score involvements more clearances, significantly more metres gained, more contested possession, more inside 50s and so on but apparently Neale has been nore damaging. Daicos has dragged the Pies back into games on his own back and dragged us over the line on so many times. To say Neale has been more damaging than Cripps and Daicos is laughable.
 
I just love that small defender Nick Blakey towers over tall defender James Sicily
 
Lingsface said:
Please read previous posts.
Click to expand...
The one where you forget that Josh Weddle and Jack Scrimshaw exist by telling people Sicily is the "second biggest backman" in the side (presumably after Frost)?
Anyways, good effort
 
South of the Yarra said:
Nick Daicos has just won ABC Footballer of the Year. Daicos and Cripps have just tied for SEN player of the year. It will most likely be Daicos and Cripps who fight out the coaches award and the Brownlow. Daicos has averaged more goals than Neale, more disposals, more tackles, more score involvements more clearances, significantly more metres gained, more contested possession, more inside 50s and so on but apparently Neale has been nore damaging. Daicos has dragged the Pies back into games on his own back and dragged us over the line on so many times. To say Neale has been more damaging than Cripps and Daicos is laughable.
Click to expand...
Just the way I have seen it, would be open to reading others.
Daicos leads Neale by 1 possesion in averages and 1.5 in clangers per game, so not the best bragging point.
Neale leads him on clearances, Neale 75 percent disposal efficiency to Daicos 67 percent. Im sure I could go on there is so many points both ways in the end its just the way I see it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion My top 10- Positions-2024

Similar threads

Lunchtime
Top 10 Players Since 2000
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
239
Views
7K
kreuze_missile
kreuze_missile
Zevon
Opinion AFL 2024 Round 10 - Weekend Wrap & Liked, Learnt, Hated
Replies
23
Views
2K
HairyO
HairyO
Lingsface
Top 5 Midfields 2024
21 22 23 24 25
Replies
601
Views
35K
FlowersByIrene
FlowersByIrene
Lingsface
Top 10 Key Position Forwards
2 3
Replies
64
Views
3K
Art Vandelay_
Art Vandelay_
PowerfulPies2023
Top 10 coaches in the history of the game?
2 3
Replies
58
Views
3K
Happy Mastenator
Happy Mastenator
Lingsface
  • Article
Brownlow Top 10
Replies
6
Views
662
adammania9
adammania9
Cleric
  • Poll
Prediction Who will be the best key position tall forward in the game?
2 3 4
Replies
80
Views
3K
Strapping Young Lad
Strapping Young Lad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top