Top 10 worst Top 10 picks since '97 - '03

[DJ Dupree]

I guess that means Goddard is St Kilda's version of Jessie Smith and he's a hack.

Goddard was on track for a good season before he did his knee and looked sharp when he played up the ground against Melbourne in round one.

Goddard isn't as talented as Norf's Gibson, Swallow, Firrito, Pratt and Swallow.

Heh you said 'Swallow' twice.

A bit silleh of ya!

 

[Squizz]

Yeah - he likes "the swallow".

Very harsh on Goddard. I had been critical, but the year and a bit before the knee were very good.

The saints have contributed a couple of others - Raph Clarke and Cayden Beetham.

But there's a whole bunch of Top 10's who haven't really played any footy - no comparison to a Goddard. There's a number in 2002 who have hardly set the world on fire.

 

[Bollox]

Maybe not the worst and this one is injury related but sometimes things just dont work out...pretty sure Collingwood traded and switched pick 3 (Pavlich) for pick 6 or7 ish (Danny Roach) in 1999. Roach played one game.

 

[lids2004roar]

Stop arguing about Cooney and Goddard... FFS they are possibly the worst 2 number one picks since Josh Fraser.

 

[Bourky23]

Stop arguing about Cooney and Goddard... FFS you should be grateful because my sh*t rabble of a club drafted the worst number 1 pick of all time in Brett "I'm a Hack" Deledio.

edited for accuracy