Top 5 Midfields 2024

[Cleansweep17]

I don't often find myself backing up Collingwood, but you clearly haven't watched N.Daicos play this year if you still think he is a HBF.

He is 2nd in the competition for Centre Clearances per game (behind Cripps) and averages the same amount of Centre Bounce Attendances per game that Cripps does.

In fact he attends more Centre Bounces than anyone else in the Collingwood team (except for Darcy Cameron)

He’s a hybrid HBF/mid

He played HBF this year didn’t he?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

He’s a hybrid HBF/mid

He played HBF this year didn’t he?

Not really.

 

[RonnieRaven]

By Brownlow
1. Swans
Heeney 28
Gulden 25
Warner 23

2. Freo
Serong 28
Brayshaw 22
Young 12

3. Port
Butters 29
JHF 19
Rozee 12

4. Dogs
Treloar 26
Bont 19
Libba 10

5. Blues
Cripps 45
Walsh 16


Pretty exciting for the top 3 teams with only Heeney (28yr) over 24

 

[JPetro83]

Port are a key forward and a key backman away from dominating. They will have the best midfield if not already

 

[Blackhawk42]

By Brownlow
1. Swans
Heeney 28
Gulden 25
Warner 23

2. Freo
Serong 28
Brayshaw 22
Young 12

3. Port
Butters 29
JHF 19
Rozee 12

4. Blues
Cripps 45
Walsh 16

5. Dogs
Treloar 26
Bont 19

Pretty exciting for the top 3 teams with only Heeney (28yr) over 24

If you take out Carlton and the Dogs to make it a genuine 3 midfielder set up, does that change or anything?

 

[RonnieRaven]

If you take out Carlton and the Dogs to make it a genuine 3 midfielder set up, does that change or anything?

I based it off a min of 10 votes because I don’t know the ins and outs of every team as far as time in midfield and so forth
And just realised I missed libba

 

[Cleansweep17]

If Freo get Bolton and give him some midfield time I’d say they do.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

By Brownlow
1. Swans
Heeney 28
Gulden 25
Warner 23

2. Freo
Serong 28
Brayshaw 22
Young 12

3. Port
Butters 29
JHF 19
Rozee 12

4. Dogs
Treloar 26
Bont 19
Libba 10

5. Blues
Cripps 45
Walsh 16


Pretty exciting for the top 3 teams with only Heeney (28yr) over 24

Add a fit Cerra to Carltons mix and they look a lot different. But I agree too much is relied on Cripps and Walsh normally.

For what its worth though we still ended up with the 3rd highest votes across those midfields even if we only take Cripps and Walsh.

 

[Blackhawk42]

I based it off a min of 10 votes because I don’t know the ins and outs of every team as far as time in midfield and so forth
And just realised I missed libba

All good.

For the Hawks boys, I know it was...
Newcombe 24
Worpel 14
Day 9

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Clearly Carlton. They have a midfielder that is twice as good as Bont.