List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020

[JB007]

Pies are open to trading Cox

And sorry, its 850k for Moore.

Is this from Tom Browne Jen?

 

[Seedsfan]

We’ve really f’ed out selves. Instead of drafting Chol and Artts we have Beams, Dunn, Broomhead, Reid who may as well be replaced with cheer squad members and our list would be in exactly the same spot.

Chol has played less than 20 games in 5 years like hardly ****ed ourself by not taking him

 

[Thefly38]

Premiership player and 4x AA what's he on?

1 million plus

 

[HFF]

Pay $800k for Jordy that much. No thanks.Moore is AA Jordy doesn’t rip apart games consistently enough


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Forget what they are. Jordy has also won more games off his own boot than Moore has since 2018.
If we do a 2yr deal--we will be shooting ourselves in the foot when he is eligible for free agency.

 

[BEEG]

850 for a key back ooof

Supporters wonder why where in the salary cap shit where in.

 

[manicpie]

Looking to trade Cox, that's interesting, must have someone else coming to the club

 

[Matt_352]

So if Cox and Lynch both leave that leaves us with just Grundy and Cameron as ruck options.

 

[HFF]

Looking to trade Cox, that's interesting, must have someone else coming to the club

Or they've realised he just isn't that good to begin with.

 

[manicpie]

Forget what they are. Jordy has also won more games off his own boot than Moore has since 2018.
If we do a 2yr deal--we will be shooting ourselves in the foot when he is eligible for free agency.

That's fair enough but how much would you pay JDG per year over 5 years?

 

[partypie]

You already talked about his disposal efficiency but your really underselling how bad it is. He has a below average disposal efficiency which is 60% and his kicking efficiency being 49% which is so much worse then someone like Phillips who has 67% and 60% respectively. I only mention phillips cause he is a well known bad user and gets clowned for it. While also averaging 4.9 turnovers. Also mentioning your defensive half touches, he averages 2 intercept possessions which is below average, 6 defensive pressure acts which is average, 14 pressure acts which is below average and only .7 one percenters which is below average.

Edit: forgot to add he is average (almost below average) for centre clearances but yes he is elite for stoppages around the ground

Treloar's raw DE% hasn't been great this year, but you'd have to think it's at least partially a reflection of how poor our ball movement has been overall. You compare him to Phillips who is the king of the short 15-20m chip kick, often backwards or sideways, so I think the comparison between him and Treloar is a little loose at best.

For reference even Pendles has ben ordinary this year with his disposal at times, which overall has dropped nearly 7 percent compared to last couple of years.

The other fact you're also glossing over is that Treloar has been much improved with his disposal over 2018-19 especially with his kicking, so that should be noted in any sort of assessment like this. From where I sit he's often been one of the very few players in black and white who have been trying to break the lines and get it into our F50 quickly this season, often after a chain of 5-10 possessions which have gone nowhere, so personally I'm giving him a mulligan on 2020.

 

[BEEG]

What's Andrews and Weitering on?

 

[manicpie]

Or they've realised he just isn't that good to begin with.

I doubt it. Cox has been servicible for us, won a few games off his own boot and we don't have anyone else to replace him so i imagine we are bringing in a key forward

 

[Jen2310]

DEES KEY FORWARD UP FOR GRABS



Melbourne forward Tom McDonald is “officially up for grabs” despite having two years to run on his contract with the club.

McDonald struggled to cement his place in the side this year, managing only nine games.

Speaking on 3AW Sportsday, AFL reporter Sam McClure said the 28-year-old’s future was uncertain, with Collingwood one club asking the question.

“Tom McDonald is officially up for grabs,” he said.

“He’s got two years left on his deal, the Magpies have reached out and just asked some questions. I’m not sure whether they’ll be the ones he eventually goes to ... I don’t think he’ll be at Melbourne next year.”

Former Demon and Brownlow Medallist Gerard Healy agreed that McDonald could be out the door, with the club and player mutually looking for a suitable deal.

“I think they’ve made their minds up. It sounds like that relationship is just about broken,” he said.

“He’s moving and they’re happy for him to move ... it looks to me like he’s just lost that confidence that he had.

“Maybe he’s destined to return to the backline. I’m not sure where Collingwood see him fitting in but they recruited Jeremy Howe as a forward and turned him into one of the great defenders of the last five or six years.”

 

[manicpie]

What's Andrews and Weitering on?

Exactly

 

[Matt_352]

That's fair enough but how much would you pay JDG per year over 5 years?

700

 

[gopies123]

850 for Moore. Bye JDG


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Matt_352]

DEES KEY FORWARD UP FOR GRABS



Melbourne forward Tom McDonald is “officially up for grabs” despite having two years to run on his contract with the club.

McDonald struggled to cement his place in the side this year, managing only nine games.

Speaking on 3AW Sportsday, AFL reporter Sam McClure said the 28-year-old’s future was uncertain, with Collingwood one club asking the question.

“Tom McDonald is officially up for grabs,” he said.

“He’s got two years left on his deal, the Magpies have reached out and just asked some questions. I’m not sure whether they’ll be the ones he eventually goes to ... I don’t think he’ll be at Melbourne next year.”

Former Demon and Brownlow Medallist Gerard Healy agreed that McDonald could be out the door, with the club and player mutually looking for a suitable deal.

“I think they’ve made their minds up. It sounds like that relationship is just about broken,” he said.

“He’s moving and they’re happy for him to move ... it looks to me like he’s just lost that confidence that he had.

“Maybe he’s destined to return to the backline. I’m not sure where Collingwood see him fitting in but they recruited Jeremy Howe as a forward and turned him into one of the great defenders of the last five or six years.”

Upgrade on Roughy

 

[gopies123]

Hello Logan Macdonald


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Matt_352]

Hello Logan Macdonald


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yes please now we talking

 

[manicpie]

700

Yeah, that would by absolute maximum I would pay him also. i would pay him 650k for the first 3 years and then scope for more in the last 2 years if he meets the criteria

 

[TakingThePies]

I followed him as a junior. He went from being a rookie prospect as a forward, to being a second round selection after being switched to defence. He’s an excellent intercept defender and great field kick.

Ben Reid went from a pretty average forward to a AA back, Howe went from an okay forward to a gun back. Regardless of where those two were it can still happen.

 

[TakingThePies]

They've obviously done something if Moore went from rumoured two year deal to a long term 800k deal.


I think De Goeys gone.

 

[manicpie]

DEES KEY FORWARD UP FOR GRABS



Melbourne forward Tom McDonald is “officially up for grabs” despite having two years to run on his contract with the club.

McDonald struggled to cement his place in the side this year, managing only nine games.

Speaking on 3AW Sportsday, AFL reporter Sam McClure said the 28-year-old’s future was uncertain, with Collingwood one club asking the question.

“Tom McDonald is officially up for grabs,” he said.

“He’s got two years left on his deal, the Magpies have reached out and just asked some questions. I’m not sure whether they’ll be the ones he eventually goes to ... I don’t think he’ll be at Melbourne next year.”

Former Demon and Brownlow Medallist Gerard Healy agreed that McDonald could be out the door, with the club and player mutually looking for a suitable deal.

“I think they’ve made their minds up. It sounds like that relationship is just about broken,” he said.

“He’s moving and they’re happy for him to move ... it looks to me like he’s just lost that confidence that he had.

“Maybe he’s destined to return to the backline. I’m not sure where Collingwood see him fitting in but they recruited Jeremy Howe as a forward and turned him into one of the great defenders of the last five or six years.”

I would not hesitate to take him. A good pre season and he could kick 40 plus goals for us

 

[MagpieJoel]

Forget what they are. Jordy has also won more games off his own boot than Moore has since 2018.
If we do a 2yr deal--we will be shooting ourselves in the foot when he is eligible for free agency.

Inconsistency does nothing for me.

Moore is dependable. De Goey is not.

 

[10571z]

800k for an all Australian defender is probably ok.

Good on him, he earnt it.