Recruiting Trade & Free Agency VI

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Like Ben Long. Wont cost too much. We need a small forward to replace Josh Green and Baguley on the list depth for small forwards. His pressure can be great. We would also be buying pretty low for him.

Like it alot.

Ruck Depth is fine if Leuy stays on. TBC, Leunberger, Draper, Mckernan and Daniher as PLAN E worse case scenario and then the option of mature age recruits mid way through the season

Future 3rd rounder gets it done youd think
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Like Ben Long. Wont cost too much. We need a small forward to replace Josh Green and Baguley on the list depth for small forwards. His pressure can be great. We would also be buying pretty low for him.

Like it alot.

Ruck Depth is fine if Leuy stays on. TBC, Leunberger, Draper, Mckernan and Daniher as PLAN E worse case scenario and then the option of mature age recruits mid way through the season

Future 3rd rounder gets it done youd think
Future 3rd? You've lost your marbles.

Was pick 25 last year and has shown plenty, i believe he kicked 6 against our VFL team in a final a year or two ago.
He also was a RS nomination earlier this year.

Not too mention he is one of the few St Kilda players capable of running through the wing/midfield that isnt one paced. St Kilda amd Long dont seem tha eager so o I doubt it goes anywhere. Would be a high second at least.
 
Future 3rd? You've lost your marbles.

Was pick 25 last year and has shown plenty, i believe he kicked 6 against our VFL team in a final a year or two ago.
He also was a RS nomination earlier this year.

Not too mention he is one of the few St Kilda players capable of running through the wing/midfield that isnt one paced. St Kilda amd Long dont seem tha eager so o I doubt it goes anywhere. Would be a high second at least.

Or we are offering up fringe players like Laverde whom they wanted a few seasons back and rated highly.
 
Or we are offering up fringe players like Laverde whom they wanted a few seasons back and rated highly.
No idea. In all honestly i dont know how keen we are.

Although of it goes anywhere, it will be late in trade week after we have done the deal for Shiel. After which our resources will be quite depleted to make a deal happen.

The article also say he isnt really looking to move.
If the player doesnt want to move and the club he is at doesnt have an interest in moving him - how often does deal get done?
Never.
 
How are North fitting in all these midfielders.

Ziebell, Cunnington, Higgins, Jacobs, Tyson, Dumont, Polec, Ahern, LDU, L.Mcdonald

Probably forgot some aswell
Captain Jack will play forward
 
No idea. In all honestly i dont know how keen we are.

Although of it goes anywhere, it will be late in trade week after we have done the deal for Shiel. After which our resources will be quite depleted to make a deal happen.

The article also say he isnt really looking to move.
If the player doesnt want to move and the club he is at doesnt have an interest in moving him - how often does deal get done?
Never.

I'm not too concerned about rumours now - was only yesterday morning the reporters were asking Shiel as he hopped off the plane whether it be Carlton or the Hawks.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remember when Sam Mclure said he thought Shiel would go to hawks because he didnt know how Essendon would get the deal done?
 
Last edited:
Future 3rd? You've lost your marbles.

Was pick 25 last year and has shown plenty, i believe he kicked 6 against our VFL team in a final a year or two ago.
He also was a RS nomination earlier this year.

Not too mention he is one of the few St Kilda players capable of running through the wing/midfield that isnt one paced. St Kilda amd Long dont seem tha eager so o I doubt it goes anywhere. Would be a high second at least.

Was pick 25 in 2016 not 2017

Has played 14 games in 2 years. Many average players have kicks bags in the VFL ie J.Merrett, J.Green its weight is nothing

At AFL level he kicks 7 goals in 10 games and had just one scoring shot per game.

Hes also had injuries.

No way has he held his weight with a 2nd rounder. A 3rd rounder is his worth to us. Anything more and im not interested ie pick 35 this year for him
 
Was pick 25 in 2016 not 2017

Has played 14 games in 2 years. Many average players have kicks bags in the VFL ie J.Merrett, J.Green its weight is nothing

At AFL level he kicks 7 goals in 10 games and had just one scoring shot per game.

Hes also had injuries.

No way has he held his weight with a 2nd rounder. A 3rd rounder is his worth to us. Anything more and im not interested ie pick 35 this year for him

damn straight, where does Grizz get off saying high 2nd rounder?

Hibberd and Melksham went for picks in the 20's in a weaker draft supposedly?

Gary Rohan went pick 60 to Cats?

High 2nd rounder for a fringe player because what he did in VFL??? LOL
 
I'm not too concerned about rumours now - was only yesterday morning the reporters were asking Shiel as he hopped off the plane whether it be Carlton or the Hawks.
So you say something in response cordially,
Then mere minutes later...
damn straight, where does Grizz get off saying high 2nd rounder?

Hibberd and Melksham went for picks in the 20's in a weaker draft supposedly?

Gary Rohan went pick 60 to Cats?

High 2nd rounder for a fringe player because what he did in VFL??? LOL
Im mean seriously - If you are going to bad mouth me, at least have the stones to tag me in.

Melksham and Hibbo were out of contract and requested trades. Long is contracted and doesnt want to leave.
Apples and oranges.

The guy got a Rising star nomination this year, is under contract, doesnt want to leave, and more importantly - there is no indication that the Saints have any interest in moving him.

You reckon a third still gets it done?
How many 21 yo, contracted RS star nominees get traded for future 3rd rounders?

Francis has played 9 games since being drafted in 2015 - before Long.
He only played 5 this year, but was a rising star and is under contract just like Long.

I take it then all you would ask is a 3rd rounder if a club came knocking?

Nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top