List Mgmt. Trade Hypotheticals (opposition posters post here)

[DaTBird187]

So Jack Steele. What's the asking price?

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Josh Kelly....Is he an untouchable in your opinion?

YES!!!!!!!!!!


You can't have him!!!!!!!

 

[coniglio_number1]

Assuming you guys end up getting pick 5, would you guys be open to 5 & 7 for our pick 1?

Only if there was a once in a generation player rated at pick 1. There isn't so that's why your club wants to sell it but pick 1 isn't worth more than 2 picks in the teens. Not 2 picks in the top 10

 

[coniglio_number1]

If we floated a trade in the shape of pick 6 this year and Ben Lennon/Brandon Ellis for Josh Kelly, would that be looked at as fair? Just trying to get an idea of what GWS fans would consider fair market value at this stage of his career?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

We gave up Tyson and pick 9 to get kelly. Why the actual would we sell him for pick 6 and a spud

 

[BarryAglett]

If we floated a trade in the shape of pick 6 this year and Ben Lennon/Brandon Ellis for Josh Kelly, would that be looked at as fair? Just trying to get an idea of what GWS fans would consider fair market value at this stage of his career?

 

[combaning]

Not for sale.

If he was,

Martin or Cotchin and 40-60% of their salary would be an equitable trade.

 

[Bokonon]

Not for sale.

If he was,

Martin or Cotchin and 40-60% of their salary would be an equitable trade.

Ahhhhhh
The Horror.

 

[JC100]

Greetings GWS folk!
Loved the way your lads have gone about it this year, excellent brand of footy and really exciting to watch.

I've been watching Josh Kelly since he got drafted pretty closely, and would love him at the Tigers.
Is he an untouchable in your opinion?

If we floated a trade in the shape of pick 6 this year and Ben Lennon/Brandon Ellis for Josh Kelly, would that be looked at as fair? Just trying to get an idea of what GWS fans would consider fair market value at this stage of his career?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Kelly would be untouchable unless he wanted out considering what we traded to get him in the first place.

If he did want out it would be treloar like trade. 2 first picks would be involved


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[JC100]

Greetings GWS folk!
Loved the way your lads have gone about it this year, excellent brand of footy and really exciting to watch.

I've been watching Josh Kelly since he got drafted pretty closely, and would love him at the Tigers.
Is he an untouchable in your opinion?

If we floated a trade in the shape of pick 6 this year and Ben Lennon/Brandon Ellis for Josh Kelly, would that be looked at as fair? Just trying to get an idea of what GWS fans would consider fair market value at this stage of his career?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Kelly would be untouchable unless he wanted out considering what we traded to get him in the first place.

If he did want out it would be treloar like trade. 2 first picks would be involved


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[IanW]

Kelly would be untouchable unless he wanted out considering what we traded to get him in the first place.

If he did want out it would be treloar like trade. 2 first picks would be involved


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

aka 'Start with making his manager a Toyd-style offer he cant refuse. Then back the truck up with trade currency'.

 

[prodigy]

Okay, well at least I got a solid answer lol. He is so good


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[coniglio_number1]

Okay, well at least I got a solid answer lol. He is so good


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes he is.

I assume it's why you want him

 

[prodigy]

Yes he is.

I assume it's why you want him

Indeed. Will be the best player in the comp in two years.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[reload141]

Good old Robbo tweeting we are after Patton & pick 7 for pick 1. Just passing it along guys!

 

[coniglio_number1]

Good old Robbo tweeting we are after Patton & pick 7 for pick 1. Just passing it along guys!

 

[reload141]

View attachment 291893

Robbo is usually 15 drinks deep at this time making outrageous claims like that

 

[Determinant]

Good old Robbo tweeting we are after Patton & pick 7 for pick 1. Just passing it along guys!

lol

 

[dlanod]

Robbo is usually 15 drinks deep at this time making outrageous claims like that

He tweeted it at 9:04am then?

 

[IanW]

Good old Robbo tweeting we are after Patton & pick 7 for pick 1. Just passing it along guys!

Absolutely.

But no one has yet explained why GWS would do that ...

 

[Drummond]

Why are so many people asking about Kelly? What's his contract situation? Because unless he wants out, there is no way you guys would ever trade him!

He's amazing. Skillful, poised, quick, pretty much has everything to be a top 10 player in this comp. Jet.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Only if there was a once in a generation player rated at pick 1. There isn't so that's why your club wants to sell it but pick 1 isn't worth more than 2 picks in the teens. Not 2 picks in the top 10

It comes down how each club rates players. Not everyone rates everyone the same. On your end, apparently you're specifically trying to trade up because of how highly you rate a certain player.

 

[Bokonon]

Why are so many people asking about Kelly? What's his contract situation? Because unless he wants out, there is no way you guys would ever trade him!

He's amazing. Skillful, poised, quick, pretty much has everything to be a top 10 player in this comp. Jet.

I dont get it either, but what can we do? We get the same for Lobb and just chuckle really.

 

[coniglio_number1]

It comes down how each club rates players. Not everyone rates everyone the same. On your end, apparently you're specifically trying to trade up because of how highly you rate a certain player.

The media said the same about petracca. We never even attempted to trade for 1 in the end. I doubt these media types would know who we want to draft this far out before the combine and that we are focused on scouting our own academy players

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

The media said the same about petracca. We never even attempted to trade for 1 in the end. I doubt these media types would know who we want to draft this far out before the combine and that we are focused on scouting our own academy players

That's fair enough. I'm just basing my hypothetical on the media speculation

 

[Determinant]

That's fair enough. I'm just basing my hypothetical on the media speculation

I think the technical term for a double hypothetical is bullshit