Votes - Rd 5 Carlton v Adelaide

[Blue Bawls]

5 Murphy
4 Judd
3 Walker
2 Ellard
1 Jamison

BYP - Garlett. Again stood up under the enormous expectations placed on his slight shoulders.

 

[james Dean]

5 - Murphy
4 - Walker
3 - Judd
2 - Robinson
1 - Tambling

 

[AndyWalkersGirl]

Murphy
Jamo
Ellard
Walker
Judd

 

[HARKER]

5 Murphy
4 Judd
3 Walker
2 Jamison
1 Curnow.

 

[BowerTower]

5. Jamison
4. Walker
3. Ellard
2. Murphy
1. Judd

Murphy ran around on his own today, can't really rate his game based on that.

 

[jimsta10]

5. Walker
4. Curnow
3. Murphy
2. Ellard
1. Juddy

 

[Shaunus]

5 Murphy
4 Judd
3 Walker
2 Jamison
1 Waite

 

[Alpha1]

5 Murphy
4 Jammo
3 Waite
2 Walker
1 Betts

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

5. Murphy
4. Jammo
3. Waite
2. Walker
1. Curnow

W.O.G Carrots(Again), Hampson(Again) Russell and Gibbs

 

[bigboyblue]

Was at the game so haven't seen any stats at all, but from one look at it with no radio to help I would go:

5. Jammo - thought he stood up really well all night, took the game on, made great decisions and only made one or two blues.
4. Walks - kicked a few, set a couple up and generally looked pretty good. Not sure what his numbers were like but loved his game.
3. Ellard - just thought he was generally really good. Like the way he goes about it, couple of handy goals.
2. Murph - good all night, missed a couple of goals which would've seen him bbe one of the top two on ground.
1. Judd - judged on a higher standard than others, so his mistakes cost him!!

 

[JuddyBuddy]

5. Murphy
4. Walker
3. Judd.
2. Simpson
1. Ellard

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Jamison - busted his arse
Murphy - busted his arse
Walker - Took his spekky, kicked 4 by half time, sat back and thought he was Kouta.
Judd - utterly r*ped every time he got the pill, busted his arse.
Yarran - the best player on the ground 'til he went off.

 

[juddsentant517]

5 - Jamison - Star! That one on one contest with Tippett was the highlight of the season for mine

4 - Yaz/Laidler/ Duigan - Provided cool, calm and collected run out of back 50.

3- Walker - Provided the only option, kick 4. Nice that he took the ****ing mark for once, hopefully he can be content with that and never do it ever again

2 - David Ellard - Admire this guy. With limited talent and lack of height, he keeps going and going

1 - Judd - Great in and under. But his kicking skills are ****ing average, and his goal kicking is terrible. Still, awesome in the clinches

Special Mention to Waite (Provided an option all game), Robinson (His perceived pressure is incredible. Love the murderous aggression), Murphy (Got a lot of it) Curnow (Consistent)

Love winning, but that game was shit.

 

[michael69]

5. Murphy
4. Jamison
3. Walker
2. Judd
1. Curnow

 

[Stamos]

5. Walker
4. Waite
3. Jamison
2. Yarran
1. Judd

BYP: Yarran

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

5. Jamison - ridiculously good start to the year and was absolutely enormous tonight.
4. Walker - haven't been a big fan of his but he really made his possessions count and was critical up forward.
3. Murphy - Gun.
2. Judd - Great in close.
1. Ellard - love what this bloke brings to the team.

 

[BluesMan]

Judd was average...

5. Jamison- amazingly good, needs some mates to help him out.
4. Ellard- Thats why this guy is in our F***n best 22!! He's a gun!
3. Waite- tryed hard as always
2. Murphy- silky
1. Curnow- busts his arse non stop!

 

[blue gunslinger]

Judd was average...

5. Jamison- amazingly good, needs some mates to help him out.
4. Ellard- Thats why this guy is in our F***n best 22!! He's a gun!
3. Waite- tryed hard as always
2. Murphy- silky
1. Curnow- busts his arse non stop!

i hear ya

5 murph-stuffed without him
4 walker-would not have been in it without his goals
3 waite-tried hard and kept cool
2 ellard-shut the doubters up and for me:won the game
1 jamo-not perfect but we would have been dead without him

so tempted for worst on ground again

 

[Warsaw]

5. Walker.
4. Jamison
3. Murphy
2. Ellard
1. Waite

 

[Polo]

5. Walker
4. Jamison
3. Murphy
2. Simpson
1. Yarran

 

[blues4flag]

Rookie of the player still happening for those keeping count.

5. Marc Murphy
4. Chris Judd
3. Michael Jamison
2. Andrew Walker
1. David Ellard

 

[blues4flag]

Judd was average...

Assume that you watched it on TV judging from your location but from the ground Judd was a step above. Disposal let him down at times but was shoulders clear of the next best around the stoppages.

 

[KoutoufidesGhost]

5 - Murphy
4 - Ellard
3 - Walker
2 - Judd
1 - Simpson

 

[reg_lower91]

Was at the game tonight and thought the following:
5 - Judd: watched him closely after the first quarter, he wasn't as impacting as in the first but his work rate just kept increasing. 1st quarter set it up, was just magnificent.
4 - Murphy - was just continuing his great form tonight.
3 - Jamison - was so so solid down back tonight
2 - walker - finally took one of his screamers!!
1 - curnow - what a pick up this guy is!!

 

[mediumsizered]

5. Murphy - Yet another outstanding game from Murph. IMO has now overtaken Judd as our best player.
4. Judd - Worked hard all game, but didn't use the ball as well as Murphy.
3. Walker - A great game up forward. An inspired move by Ratts to persist with him up forward this season.
2. Ellard- Early in the game made some ordinary skill errors, but got better as the game wore on.
1. Curnow - The recruit of the season. There is a lot of Brett Ratten about the way he plays.

BYP - Curnow, again.