Phil Carmen v the rest of the Collingwood list. Carmen didn't fit in by his own admission and was was not liked. The players wouldn't kick to him yet he dominated at CHF. He'd train early and by the time the rest of the team, who had day jobs, got onto the track he'd reckon he done enough. Amazing talent but so wasted.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Well known rifts or blues between players of same club.
- Thread starter 1980GFVideo
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No body's mentioned _______________-K Sheedy and D Kickett yet.
Brad Hardie and Mick Malthouse . i remember seeing Mick drag Hardie one day and Hardie pulled his jumper off his head and waved it up to the coaches box and tossed it on the ground . no love lost there 
- Dec 8, 2004
- 22,762
- 156
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Post Count: heaps
- Banned
- #54
Blues_Man said:Brad Hardie and Mick Malthouse . i remember seeing Mick drag Hardie one day and Hardie pulled his jumper off his head and waved it up to the coaches box and tossed it on the ground . no love lost there
mick punched glen jakovich in the players race after a game once too.
- Sep 22, 2000
- 62,351
- 41,703
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Ford
rick James said:
So there is something to like about Mick
SainterX1 said:
You're probably right..... I was at a meeting in the city with an Aboriginal organisation in 1988 and Winmar was there with Kelly looking for a job. One of the staff there told me what had happened between Winmar and the Cunninghams. I had no first hand knowledge. And remember, we are posting what we've heard, not what actually transpired. No one except the people involved would truly know.
- Banned
- #58
Mick Malthouse & Scott Watters after '91 grand final. Malthouse blaming a player for playing poorly in a position he doesn't normally play. He has a bit of a history of this. Pies supporters will have noticed that Malthouse is never wrong...
WA ROO said:
Mick Malthouse and Robbie West...
T Shaw thumped L Matthews and put him on his ars# in the change rooms while the team looked on toward the end of Matthews' time at the Pies. Matthews was apparently giving a few of the team a spray and T Shaw stepped forward and cracked him, vocalising apparently that the coaches' extra curricular activities were causing the club troubles more than the guys getting the spray.
Tony Shaw denied it and as far as I know no one has had the balls to ask Mathews about it. It was a strong rumour at the time though. Allegedly after Mathews questioned his commitment to a contest and the jumper. Whatever anyone thinks of Shaw his commitment is beyond question. Interestingly the same question put to Matty Ryan ended his career. If true Shaw went on to captain a premiership under Mathews after this incident.
mocaholic
Norm Smith Medallist
I heard Shaw on the radio about this - apparently Lethal did question Shaw's commitment etc, and Shaw absolutely gave him both barrels.....at 3.00 one morning, over the phone, after about 1000 beers. Lethal was OK about it - showed the commitment he wanted sort of thing.MarkT said:
mocaholic
Norm Smith Medallist
Agreed, but that was really all I heard....thought it was wife no. 3. Quite prepared to be WAY way off.Jimmy said:who cares, they are both ********wits anyway. But i havent heard that one, enlighten me
- Banned
- #67
Cummings suffered from second year blues badly.Powerstufff said:
Essendon year 1- Gun
Year 2 Pistol
Port Year 1 - GUN
Year 2 - water pistol
West Coast Year 1 - GUN
Year 2 PopGun
Collingwood
Year 1 thats it I;m done
On a Crows topic I have heard and its persistent is that Modra was dropped because of who he dropped on a coaches doorstep
- Dec 8, 2004
- 22,762
- 156
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Post Count: heaps
- Banned
- #68
jourgo said:
so it's true, i just didnt' mention WHY it happened.
mocaholic
Norm Smith Medallist
Thanks.Ford Fairlane said:
- Feb 1, 2005
- 2,642
- 298
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray Football Club
- Banned
- #72
I was at that game. Hardie can thank Malthouse for his Brownlow. He came across as a half forward but Mick played him in defence where he chased kicks to his heart's content. In the last game for the year, Malthouse instructed the Footscray players to look for Hardie who was nominally in the back pocket but chased kicks all day.Blues_Man said:Brad Hardie and Mick Malthouse . i remember seeing Mick drag Hardie one day and Hardie pulled his jumper off his head and waved it up to the coaches box and tossed it on the ground . no love lost there
Back to the topic.
Malthouse and Doug Hawkins had their moments, too. Malthouse was at Doug about his drinking. Once when injured, Doug stood below the elevated coaches Box in the outer at the Western Oval and slowly drank can after can all day, saluting Mick with the empties. Malthouse didn't hurt Doug's career either. He played him for 4 quarters on the outer wing. The wind always favoured that side of the ground so Doug saw plenty of action.
Otto
- Dec 8, 2004
- 22,762
- 156
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Post Count: heaps
- Banned
- #73
jourgo said:
that's what he says...
Can A Weagles fan elaborate on the Kerr Vs Cousins situation
Similar threads
