Which team In the AFL has the best logo?

[The Fireman]

Tiger one looks best.

Best mascot we have so we are charmed along with the best song and jumper Richmond paddock(the G) and Richmond pubs across the road from the G.

Yes,it's good to be the king!

It looks like a faded Bombers jumper.

I like Ports but the Saints jumper is by far the best

 

[Sloth]

I hate having the Aussie flag on the magpie logo. pointless really. Not to mention it's backwards.

 

[The Fireman]

I hate having the Aussie flag on the magpie logo. pointless really. Not to mention it's backwards.

The Magpie logo looks good but yeah that was an odd decision.
Surely they could have dug up a different black and white type flag.

 

[Joe Mama]

I think that Richmond's logo is the best out of all of them ahead of Collingwood (would look better with two black & white flags, for a sense of balance, and not to be P.C like J_Moore), St Kilda & the Western Bulldogs (because both of them are bold & simple).

Fremantle's & Port Adelaide's are the worst out of the modern ones, but I've always liked the old 70's logo's especially the Fitzroy one.http://bomberblitz.com/~rmered/images/Fitzroy-Logo-1977.gif

 

[Seethus]

I like the look of Hawks and Geelongs style of Integrating the Animal into a shield looks modern but not all over the place.
Melbourne and Freo have by far the worst.
Everyone knows why Freo's is crap
Melbourne dont take advantage of having a badass mascot, they could make it look so much better!

 

[Vegas.]

I reckon the one on our playing jumper is better than the corporate one:

However nothing beats two-tone busta move Cat from the 70's:

 

[El_Scorcho]

The best:

Carlton - just the CFC lettering. Simple, elegant, timeless. Getting rid of the wreath and motto surrounding it made it perfect.

Adelaide - Simple yet effective

Geelong - I didn't like this to start with, but it's definitely grown on me.

The worst:

Brisbane - The lion is excellent, but it's drowned out by bad fonts and bad gradients in a bad logo. Looks pretty amateur for an AFL logo IMO.

Essendon - Just doesn't suit the club at all. Historic, proud club with a tacky, modern logo that already looks out of fashion. Essendon could do a lot better.

Edit: I realise we probably fall under the same category as i've put Essendon in there, but I don't have any idea how i'd change our logo.

 

[Burzum]

Hate Essendon's.

Like Carlton's and Sydney's.

 

[Big Fozza]

i rate the saints - and as a supporter / member of a team that is one of the oldest of any codes i got to admit i am a bit disappointed with ours. doesn't reflect our history well enough i think

 

[Philth]

I prefer 1950's / 1960's style ones. Before copywrite laws and everything having to be 'official' and of a certain size.
Similar to.....

Awesome. I love all that old stuff.

I reckon the Kangas new logo looks pretty good, also like Eagles & Essendon.

 

[Pie eyed]

There actually was a problem with the original design as it did not comply with flag protocol. They initially had the Australian flag on the right and the black and white thing on the left with both flags flying from central poles, the Aus flag falling to the right and the other going left. However flag protocol states that where 2 flags are flown, the Aus flag must always fly on the left. And the Aus flag cannot be reversed so even though it's on the left, it cannot fall to the left of the pole and become a mirror of itself. Therefore they had to have the flag flying from the wrong side, the right of the flag rather than the left.

http://www.afana.com/netpaper/sep20-04238.html

It may have been against "flag protocol" but it was changed in answer to a request from the RSL ( and resulting media outrage) in 2005 (I believe).
I know because I did some of the initial graphic work.

 

[Joelong]

Here are the original official VFL/AFL logos for a comparison...

Adelaide

Brisbane - I have no idea why the bears failed with a colour scheme like this...

Fitzroy - This is my favourite of the old logos.

Carlton

Collingwood

Essendon

Western Bulldogs/Footscray

Fremantle - only a slight change since 1995

Geelong

Hawthorn

Melbourne

North Melbourne

Port Adelaide - slight change since 1997

Richmond

St Kilda - Is this the same logo as in the Roger Moore TV show called The Saint?

Sydney/South Melbourne

West Coast

credit to mero for posting the logos on his site.

 

[Philth]

I reckon the one on our playing jumper is better than the corporate one:

However nothing beats two-tone busta move Cat from the 70's:

Two tone must have been all the rage back then, its on my avatar too. Nowhere near as cool as busta move cat though. I assume you have a tattoo of him on your person somewhere??

 

[Vegas.]

Afraid not, but it is definitely on my to-do list. However, I do dance just like that.

Not too sure why the Tiges went with blue in their logo!

 

[Zagg]

St Kilda and Carlton well clear at the top for me. Both clean and classy.

 

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

Tigers from North for mine.

 

[aneale]

Afraid not, but it is definitely on my to-do list. However, I do dance just like that.

Not too sure why the Tiges went with blue in their logo!

For a period there,all of the 'shield' logo's were blue on the top. It was a Victorian blue thing between 77 & 79

 

[aneale]

This was by far the best looking Kangaroo, why they changed the look of it when they flipped it around to face the right is anyone's guess. Much better than the current logo.

 

[tesseract]

I quite like the Crows logo

I liked all the late 80's/early 90's logos so much more, when they were all on shields.

+1

I prefer to have logo's on shields too. Even if they remade logo's, they should fit them onto shields.

 

[Rohan25]

Of the 15 clubs I don't have an emotional attachment to, I actually really like Sydney's. Simple and elegant.

 

[footyfreak]

 

[tesseract]

I have always like this shield the crows have.
Sorry but this is the only pic of it I could find

I like Adelaide's current home jumper, but the one your showing here is a ghey pride jumper.

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

I liked the consistency of the shield designs.

Currently, I like Collingwood and Richmond logos the best. GC17 is horrid.

 

[Exe Gesis]

St Kilda's current logo is EASILY the best by a very long way.

 

[Royal Flush]

Are you going to start lighting flares?

I thought Eddie wanted to shut the site where these logos originated from?