-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Who are our top 10 most important players??
- Thread starter njac3
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,679
Agree with Campbell, Fraser is our #1. We wont lose all our games without Dids so I cant see him as our #1, just yet.njac3 said:
1. Josh Fraser (Our ruck, most important)
2. Alan Didak (Flair. Best player at Collingwood)
3. James Clement (Holds the backline)
4. Nathan Buckley (Presence alone)
5. Heath Shaw (Run from the backline, underestimated)
6. Anthony Rocca (Similiar to Bucks, up forward)
7. Simon Prestigiacomo (Same as Clement)
8. Leon Davis (Not in our best 18 for some, but I see him as an important player)
9. Ben Johnson (Our main running midfielder/HB)
10. Dale Thomas (Like 'Magic', his presence and lightening plays, aswell as his excitment, makes him very important, even if he may not be in the best 10 players at the club)
Yeh when Dale went out of the side for those couple of rounds we didn't really miss him that much. Don't get me wrong he will be a great player for the club and will be in the top 5 in the next couple of years.
1. Dale Thomas
2. Nathan Buckley
3. James Clement
4. Ryan Lonie
5. Dane Swan
6. Ben Johnson
7. Alan Didak
8. Josh Fraser
9. Heath Shaw
10. Leon Davis
2. Nathan Buckley
3. James Clement
4. Ryan Lonie
5. Dane Swan
6. Ben Johnson
7. Alan Didak
8. Josh Fraser
9. Heath Shaw
10. Leon Davis
In terms of winning in round 1 Rocca is number 1 from Clement. In terms of who I’d keep for future success Didak is number 1 from Thomas.
I reckon we could get 20 players to ruck about as well as Josh. Around the ground and versatility are another story.
I reckon we could get 20 players to ruck about as well as Josh. Around the ground and versatility are another story.
lot of people sneaking leon davis in, although he was very good before he got injured this year, i wouldnt put him in top 10. replace him with obree or holland, they are both important in the midfield (although holland is a bit dumb) adn can both go foward and crumb
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,679
Understood. I actually thought that we did go missing a little past the 60 metres when Thomas injuried himself, thats why I added him. He was the flair that was missing. He definitely isnt in our top 10 best yet, but I added him because he is in the top 10 in regards to importance on the field.campbell023 said:
Heath over Pebbles is debateable, not sure that was a wise choice.
- Oct 8, 2004
- 12,316
- 3,954
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
Seeing as everyone has done theirs for now, here's my 10 most important players in our side for the future:
#1: Dale Thomas (Legitimately the biggest potential match-winner on our list - We need him to become our new superstar)
#2: Heath Shaw (Brings that family tradition with him, and is a potential captain)
#3: Alan Didak (Like Daisy, a matchwinner - We need him to become a solid, consistent veteran)
#4: Travis Cloke (Needs to become a key forward that stands up and takes over games)
#5: Josh Fraser (Will become more wily as he ages - Could be another potential captain)
#6: Dane Swan (Can do almost everything, so will probably be used all over the place to help us)
#7: Scott Pendlebury (All class, looms as one of our more consistent ball winners for the future)
#8: John Anthony (Will hopefully develop as the backman that does our rebounding from defence)
#9: Sean Rusling (Hopefully he can become someone capable of kicking 50+ goals a year)
#10: Harry O'Brien (Quite possibly the most physically talented player we've got - If he develops, he could be magnificent)
#1: Dale Thomas (Legitimately the biggest potential match-winner on our list - We need him to become our new superstar)
#2: Heath Shaw (Brings that family tradition with him, and is a potential captain)
#3: Alan Didak (Like Daisy, a matchwinner - We need him to become a solid, consistent veteran)
#4: Travis Cloke (Needs to become a key forward that stands up and takes over games)
#5: Josh Fraser (Will become more wily as he ages - Could be another potential captain)
#6: Dane Swan (Can do almost everything, so will probably be used all over the place to help us)
#7: Scott Pendlebury (All class, looms as one of our more consistent ball winners for the future)
#8: John Anthony (Will hopefully develop as the backman that does our rebounding from defence)
#9: Sean Rusling (Hopefully he can become someone capable of kicking 50+ goals a year)
#10: Harry O'Brien (Quite possibly the most physically talented player we've got - If he develops, he could be magnificent)
for 07 our 10 most important players are
1. J.Fraser
2. A.Rocca
3. D.Swan
4. J.Clement
5. B.Johnson
6. H.Shaw
7. S.O'Bree
8. T.Cloke
9. S.Prestigiacomo
10. N.Buckley
1. J.Fraser
2. A.Rocca
3. D.Swan
4. J.Clement
5. B.Johnson
6. H.Shaw
7. S.O'Bree
8. T.Cloke
9. S.Prestigiacomo
10. N.Buckley
- Banned
- #15
vinnie_vegas69 said:
Spot on. I might have included Maxwell
- Oct 8, 2004
- 12,316
- 3,954
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
Doubt it - He's a 3rd tall defender, and he doesn't have superb athleticism, strength or skill.Invigoration said:
Unless he can defy the odds, he's in danger of losing his spot to Harry or JA, IMO.
altonapiefan
Debutant
vinnie_vegas69 said:
Love your work Vinnie_Vegas69, add to that draft picks 8 and 10 of this years draft and pretty much sums up our future. Massive gamble to get pick 8 and lose Tarrant, but believe it was the right time seeing talk of this super-draft. Lets just pray that Pies don't pull any surprises, I believe they should go for best available, they must. Cannot go picking what would be a no. 13 at 8, otherwise Trade week would haunt us for many many years.
legitimatic
Premiership Player
I'd say Medhurst hahaha 
My top 10 and im hoping that its our top 10
Dale is easily my fave
Dale is easily my fave
DThomas said:
Its your opinion but Lonie would be lucky to be in our top 22 let alone top 10, he is our weakest link im still spewing he is at the club. The whole of the AFL knows this (even his team mates) just look at last years final against the dogs, when they gave it to the soft P@!$# not 1 of our players said boo to them becuase thay all thought "gee he has a point Lonie"!
Skoff
Senior List
legitimatic said:I'd say Medhurst hahaha
Not as funny as it seems. With Didak out for a fair bit of the season and Leon Davis just not that consistant. Medhurst will be a very important player for the pies this coming season.
1. nathan buckley
2. bob rose
3. peter daicos
4. nuts coventry
5. tony shaw
6. jack regan
7. darren millane
8. **** lee
9. phonse kyne
10. derek shaw
2. bob rose
3. peter daicos
4. nuts coventry
5. tony shaw
6. jack regan
7. darren millane
8. **** lee
9. phonse kyne
10. derek shaw
dicknose said:
er. they cut my d-i-c-k out !
