Who are the Hawks 8 untouchables?

[RECORDS!]

According to news reports, Clarkson has said anyone is up for trade at the club other than 8 players. Any ideas??

Obviously Buddy, Hodge and Mitchell...........

 

[HFC082]

Buddy
Mitchell
Hodge
Sewell
Brown
Roughead
Lewis
Rioli
Bateman

9 Untouchables for mine

 

[badius]

...add Roughy, Lewis (they added him at the last minute apparently) and Bateman to that list, I think. Maybe Ellis too

 

[badius]

Buddy
Mitchell
Hodge
Sewell
Brown
Roughead
Lewis
Rioli
Bateman

9 Untouchables for mine

Yep, that's better than mine. Do they have to add Rioli though? He is entering his second year as a draftee...aren't there rules around that?

 

[HFC082]

Yep, that's better than mine. Do they have to add Rioli though? He is entering his second year as a draftee...aren't there rules around that?

I'd add him regardless. He is right up there.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Buddy, Hodge , Mitchell, Bateman, Roughead, Osbourne, Williams,, ummm Maybe Rioli.

 

[well left]

Was reported on SEN this morning that the Swans requested a direct swap for Jordan Lewis so you can probably assume he is one of the 8.

 

[mollyfud]

And don't mistaken, there list doesn't mean that they would do a straight trade for O'Keefe. It could be that if they want say Croad, the hawks would exprct a draft pick from the swans as well.

 

[kreuze_missile]

Depends which paper you read mate. Apparently Hawthorn has never been in the picture and hes going to the PSD if Carlton cant get a last minute deal done. Cant wait for the speculation to end and the trades to finally come through.

 

[HFC082]

Thorp, Williams and Ellis would also be on my untouchable list.

 

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Considering the Hawks lack of decent KP backmen, I would suggest Croad would be untouchable.

I doubt very much Clarkson would have said that anyway.

 

[melb_will]

Depends which paper you read mate. Apparently Hawthorn has never been in the picture and hes going to the PSD if Carlton cant get a last minute deal done. Cant wait for the speculation to end and the trades to finally come through.

Or maybe he'd stay at Sydney? ................

I'd lay fairly large money that Thorp isn't on that list.

 

[Unsociable]

This idea of players being untouchable is rubbish (with out taking into account spiritual leaders). Any player has a price. Heck, if you give us Ablett, Judd and three first round picks we might give up Buddy

 

[FisherHawk]

I have no doubt this would be the list.

Mitchell
Hodge
Franklin
Sewell
Brown
Bateman
Roughead
Rioli

If anybody wanted to get their hands on Croad, Young, Lewis, Ladson, Williams, Birchall and Ellis, they would have to come up with a very good pick or a special player. The reality is, there're all required players for Hawthorn.

 

[RECORDS!]

This idea of players being untouchable is rubbish (with out taking into account spiritual leaders). Any player has a price. Heck, if you give us Ablett, Judd and three first round picks we might give up Buddy

Of course, but obviously this thread is in relation to the O'Keefe trade.

 

[Hawker 44]

Load of rubbish from the media.
There simply is no list.

S.Maxfield:

"First of all, we said we were prepared to do a straight player-for-player swap," Maxfield said. "Then it was for their first pick and a player, and we're yet to see the list of players they were sending us. We'll have to wait and see what happens. No deal is done, so I suppose Ryan is entering a bit of a grey area."

 

[iGNITER]

Franklin
Roughead
Hodge
Mitchell
Lewis
Sewell
Bateman
Rioli
Brown

(i know there are 9 but these are players i would not trade if i were hawthorn)

 

[amos]

Franklin
Roughead
Croad
Brown
Hodge
Mitchell
Sewell
Lewis


I'm off the belief that as a 1st year rookie, Rioli can't be traded so I left him off.

 

[Ruiner]

Any of the 38 listed players depending on who you ask for

 

[KennyHunter9]

Pretty funny (if The Age is to be believed) that the Pelican wrote down seven "untouchables" and then added Lewis only after the Swans suggested a direct swap.

Pelican: "here's the seven untouchables guys"

Roos: "mmm, great, ok, then we'll go for Lewis - a direct swap"

Clarko: "you idiot Pelch!"

Pelican: "aw yeah, he's on the list too ... so it's eight untouchables"

Roos: "you sure about that?"

Pelican (looks to Clarko): "um, yeah, I think so, maybe ... dunno"

 

[juddola]

a team that just won a premiership and was built from the ground up and could now possibly win them another 1 or 2 premierships with those players is not gonna say there is only 8 players you cant touch i would say the 22 players that were on that field for the grand final would be regarded as untouchables.

 

[slippery crow]

Buddy
Mitchell
Hodge
Sewell
Brown
Roughead
Rioli
Croad

 

[Zvim]

I think the untouchable list is about 25-30. They will just say the player doesn't want to be traded unless it is one of the guys they want to trade.

 

[STFUJEFF]

Its a rubbery list
changes depending on who Sydney wants

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

I would have thought the sacred list would be the following 12:

Buddy
Hodge
Mitchell
Sewell
Roughie
Lewis
Rioli
Ellis
Brown
Bateman
Williams
Birchall