Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Irish BlueBagger]

Boy oh boy, you Carlton fans sure are biased. Despite over 100 pages of evidence provided by highly respected and fact oriented pies fans that contradict your positions, you continue to cite ladder positions and recent results that conveniently support your pro-Carlton agenda. It's disgusting.







his thread is 421

Nice melt mate. You'll be going off on another one in September.

 

[PizzaPie]

Let's not use ladder positions and recent results to support an argument that Carlton will be better than Collingwood in 2024. How biased and disgusting .
Should we use the ladder in 2023 in a 2024 thread ? Would that make you happier ? Ladies and gentleman, we have a live one here

Wooooosh

 

[PizzaPie]

Nice melt mate. You'll be going off on another one in September.

Goddam the internet is so deranged sarcasm is undetectable.

 

[Worm4]

Supporters of a team with Harry McKay in it calling another player soft .

Doubt there has been a bigger player that goes down as fast as a $2 hooker on Barkly St.

Do any of your mates actually agree that Harry McKay is soft and are willing to back up this comment ?
Or are you all going to keep quiet and simply shake your heads ?
It's an interesting observation

 

[Cyclops]

Blues fans fizzing like a can of warm fanta after beating....Geelong...

I guess this is as good as it gets.

Do any of your mates actually agree that Harry McKay is soft and are willing to back up this comment ?
Or are you all going to keep quiet and simply shake your heads ?
It's an interesting observation

Nice to know you need Collingwood supporters to tell you if your players are soft or not. The answer is yes.

Is McKay as tough as Daicos? Not in a million years. Daics gets kicked, scragged, hard tagged every week and shines.

Marshmallow McKay hides behind Curly Curnow (another small game specialist) and still gets ragdolled.

Actual footage of Hopeless Harry in the gym getting saved by Curly yet again.

 

[Worm4]

Blues fans fizzing like a can of warm fanta after beating....Geelong...

I guess this is as good as it gets.


Nice to know you need Collingwood supporters to tell you if your players are soft or not. The answer is yes.

Is McKay as tough as Daicos? Not in a million years. Daics gets kicked, scragged, hard tagged every week and shines.

Marshmallow McKay hides behind Curly Curnow (another small game specialist) and still gets ragdolled.

Actual footage of Hopeless Harry in the gym getting saved by Curly yet again.

That's actually funny. Not bad for you my little one eyed monster friend

 

[TW Sherrin]

No doubting your market research.

I offered your mum $1 but she said $2 or keep walking

 

[TW Sherrin]

Do any of your mates actually agree that Harry McKay is soft and are willing to back up this comment ?
Or are you all going to keep quiet and simply shake your heads ?
It's an interesting observation

He gets brushed and hits the deck like prime Pickett ran through him.

 

[NetworkNerd]

If any team could still do it, it's Carlton.

Mathematically possible

 

[Worm4]

He gets brushed and hits the deck like prime Pickett ran through him.

Can you show us vision of this or is it made up in your head ?

 

[CCurnow3votes]

I offered your mum $1 but she said $2 or keep walking

You’re classy in so many ways.

Don’t forget to clean your tooth.

 

[Fadge]

You did call it binary or something to that effect.
Yeah that was it.
You attempted to lesson the significance of the brownlow medal by using that word.
Not imagining

Yes, I have indeed called Brownlow winners, Norm Smith Medal winners, etc. Binary.

Because they are.

Lachie Neale wasn't the best player in the competition in 2023 on the strength of his surprise Brownlow win.

But highlighting the fact Daicos is currently forecast (for the second consecutive year) to win one of the game's individual awards is simply another pointer to his GOATness. We all know he'll rack up multiple Brownlows along his journey, it's merely a matter of in which years he wins them.

GAJ has said his best individual year was 2010 - a year in which the 5 x AFLPA MVP, 3 x AFLCA Coaches Award and 2 x Brownlow Medal winner won exactly zero individual awards.

 

[blueiris]

Yep because Carlton has to be on Friday night every week

 

[RPCB]

Sad that there are Collingwood supporters who call him the GOAT. He isn’t even fit enough to lace his dad’s boots. Never has been and never will be.

 

[Fadge]

Sad that there are Collingwood supporters who call him the GOAT. He isn’t even fit enough to lace his dad’s boots. Never has been and never will be.

Good to see you've made up your mind 2.5 years into the kid's career...

 

[RPCB]

Good to see you've made up your mind 2.5 years into the kid's career...

GOAT means Greatest of all Time. That is your thing. So you’re basically calling him better than everyone in Collingwood’s history, 2.5 years into his career.

Let’s revisit in 10 years if need be.

 

[Fadge]

GOAT means Greatest of all Time. That is your thing. So you’re basically calling him better than everyone in Collingwood’s history, 2.5 years into his career.

Let’s revisit in 10 years if need be.

No, I'm not.

If you've seen the thread, it is a question of tracking his career.

GOATcos is more about taking the p1ss out of people like you, as we know how precious you are about it...

 

[kreuze_missile]

Yep because Carlton has to be on Friday night every week

We should be.

Kick 100 points most weeks.

Have players that are enjoyable to watch.

Large supporter base.

Etc.

 

[RPCB]

No, I'm not.

If you've seen the thread, it is a question of tracking his career.

GOATcos is more about taking the p1ss out of people like you, as we know how precious you are about it...

Precious about what? I think I’ve been on this thread for about 6 weeks. Have never posted on past iterations.

I am also taking the piss out of your supporters. I know Nick Daicos is a very good player, I am not so “biased” that I won’t admit that.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

No, I'm not.

If you've seen the thread, it is a question of tracking his career.

GOATcos is more about taking the p1ss out of people like you, as we know how precious you are about it...

Aren't you the guy who was crying to mods that the thread was full of bullying and unnecessary ridicule? We aren't even allowed to type in "Nicki" over there anymore due to ur band of cretins Fudgey

 

[BennyGFunk]

I would love Carlton in a QF at the G.

You sure about that?

Are Carlton the same team you played earlier in the year or even last year

 

[BennyGFunk]

Mathematically possible

View attachment 2028613

Mathematically possible

View attachment 2028613

Fadge has wet his pants with excitement..

 

[carlton_99]

Mathematically possible

View attachment 2028613

2 games between 3rd and 16th - extraordinary parity

 

[PizzaPie]

I know Nick Daicos is a very good player, I am not so “biased” that I won’t admit that.

Your bias is on full display for the mere fact that you didn't address him by his full title; "Nick of the House Daicos, the First of His Draft Year, The Un-umpired, King of the AFL, the Rising Stars and First 100 Gamers, King of the MCG, Returned Hero of the Greater Western Sydney Prelim, Protector of the Premiership, Sir Regnant of the Eighteen Clubs, Breaker of Tackles, and Son of the Macedonian Marvel".

 

[CarmenSandiego]

I'm a big Daics fan but geez I haven't seen this. How's the throwing the head back like that, not a good look for a supposed contested beast. That's Weightman & Mathieson like.. gross.