Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Robertio]

And if you take away the ic from moronic you get moron. Or if you take the fish out of a goldfish you get gold right?.

Carlton folk say the darnedest things.

Stick to the thread title mate or go to the goldfish board.

 

[Fadge]

Pies still not winning this thread though.

I've already acknowledged Carlton won the June Participation Trophy as the second best team in the competition (behind Sydney) as at the end of June.

 

[Aphrodite]

View attachment 2037469

The following week after the above banner went viral all over social media in 2018, this was their cheer squads response:-

 

[DopeMaster]

At least the comment is relative to the thread title, while your analysis is based on history is indicative of the present or future

You know " 2023 Carlton won't make the 8, due to past events"

Then "2023 was an exception to the rule, Carlton won't make finals in 2024, will finish 13th then 16th"

It is entertaining though

In which case, your inability to make any future predictions aside from broad-brush vagaries should preclude you from participation.

But I reckon you should stick around anyway as you're good value.

 

[Fadge]

With their aging list they won't see a grand final for decade or more.

Dejavu, all over again.

We heard all this after 2021, but it was aging list AND a shot club culture...

And guess what happened?

 

[Worm4]

And if you take away the ic from moronic you get moron. Or if you take the fish out of a goldfish you get gold right?.

Carlton folk say the darnedest things.

What the phuc ?
Keep it to 2024 levels and all will be forgiven. If you want to bring up past events, go and create a new thread I'm sure you will make lots of friends over in that

 

[Robertio]

I've already acknowledged Carlton won the June Participation Trophy as the second best team in the competition (behind Sydney) as at the end of June.

As you should.

 

[Robertio]

Dejavu, all over again.

We heard all this after 2021, but it was aging list AND a shot club culture...

And guess what happened?

Tassie coming in too, make that 2 decades.

 

[RPCB]

The following week after the above banner went viral all over social media in 2018, this was their cheer squads response:-

I think they were taking the piss out of themselves here.

 

[Worm4]

Dejavu, all over again.

Like Geelong after 2022. De ja vu alright

 

[Fadge]

Like Geelong after 2022. De ja vu alright

Who is Geelong's equivalent of Nick Daicos?

 

[DopeMaster]

View attachment 2037469

Haha **** I love our banner people. Here's a good one from the fine Carlton banner folks. They then went on to lose by 43 points with Dusty getting 3 votes in a 33 disposal, 4 goal performance

 

[Aphrodite]

I think they were taking the piss out of themselves here.

They were after the response they received over social media from the previous week's banner.

 

[Aphrodite]

Haha **** I love our banner people. Here's a good one from the fine Carlton banner folks.

View attachment 2037506

This one is my all time fav and I was there

 

[RPCB]

They were after the response they got from the previous banner.

So since these banners were in 2018, that means they ****ed two banners that year not intentionally. The other was the GF banner.

 

[doppleganger]

Cherry picking....the ammo of those who have a weak argument to begin with.
Can always spot them a mile away...usually very few teeth and slightly cross-eyed.

LoL at having a crack at cherry picking

Poor Bagger fans love running with the since 1960 or some other random time frame that ensures it includes their 20 year purple patch back in VFL days.

Pies have the most flags - 16
Pies have the most finals wins - 85
Pies have the most overall wins - 1608
Pies have the H2H record against Carlton
Pies won our only match-up in 2024

No need for cherry picking if you are a Pie.

 

[Aphrodite]

LoL at having a crack at cherry picking

Poor Bagger fans love running with the since 1960 or some other random time frame that ensures it includes their 20 year purple patch back in VFL days.

Pies have the most flags - 16
Pies have the most finals wins - 85
Pies have the most overall wins - 1608
Pies have the H2H record against Carlton
Pies won our only match-up in 2024

No need for cherry picking if you are a Pie.

Really since when.

Oh and you forgot - Pies have the most GF losses record of all time - 27



As it's 2024 -

Overall attendances

​	2024 AFL Attendance
	Team Games Total Average Carlton Blues​ 15​ 878,351​ 58,557​ Collingwood Magpies​ 15​ 839,435​ 55,962​

 

[Worm4]

Who is Geelong's equivalent of Nick Daicos?

Zac Tuohy

 

[RPCB]

Who is Geelong's equivalent of Nick Daicos?

Nick Daicos this and Nick Daicos that.

I know Josh is the shit brother, but show some respect to the only Daicos brother with the Collingwood BNF.

 

[Worm4]

LoL at having a crack at cherry picking

Poor Bagger fans love running with the since 1960 or some other random time frame that ensures it includes their 20 year purple patch back in VFL days.

Pies have the most flags - 16
Pies have the most finals wins - 85
Pies have the most overall wins - 1608
Pies have the H2H record against Carlton
Pies won our only match-up in 2024

No need for cherry picking if you are a Pie.

Congratulations. You currently have the same amount of wins as Hawthorn who are currently 13th. I dip my lid to the supremo's of the 2024 edition of AFL football

 

[Fadge]

Really since when.

Oh and you forgot - Pies have the most GF losses record of all time - 27



As it's 2024 -

Overall attendances

​	2024 AFL Attendance
	Team Games Total Average Carlton Blues​ 15​ 878,351​ 58,557​ Collingwood Magpies​ 15​ 839,435​ 55,962​

Indeed.

Which equates to most Grand Final appearances and most finals won.

I expect it's much better than collecting wooden spoons and number 1 draft picks (though as a Collingwood supporter, I can't really comment on that).

 

[Worm4]

Really since when.

Oh and you forgot - Pies have the most GF losses record of all time - 27



As it's 2024 -

Overall attendances

​	2024 AFL Attendance
	Team Games Total Average Carlton Blues​ 15​ 878,351​ 58,557​ Collingwood Magpies​ 15​ 839,435​ 55,962​

Collingwood also hold the record for the most grand final losses against Carlton.

 

[Aphrodite]

Congratulations. You currently have the same amount of wins as Hawthorn who are currently 13th. I dip my lid to the supremo's of the 2024 edition of AFL football

But but they have the most flags - 16

 

[Fadge]

Congratulations. You currently have the same amount of wins as Hawthorn who are currently 13th. I dip my lid to the supremo's of the 2024 edition of AFL football

Congratulations - you have the same amount of Grand Final appearances since the turn of the century as Gold Coast.

And behind St. Kilda!

 

[Arr0w]

In which case, your inability to make any future predictions aside from broad-brush vagaries should preclude you from participation.

But I reckon you should stick around anyway as you're good value.

Made plenty of future predictions