Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Irish BlueBagger]

On top of that, Dockers first rounder received from the Pies is looking like a top 10 draft pick. Pies have royally screwed themselves with the Schultz selection.

It's going to be lovely watching that shower slide down the ladder into obscurity.

They are in serious trouble when their older players finally retire.

 

[kreuze_missile]

Surprise surprise.. all the Collingwood flogs disappeared (again) after a loss (again).

May as well rename this thread to “Carlton supporter main board hangout”

Worst premiership defence and supporter base ever

 

[Worm4]

They are in serious trouble when their older players finally retire.

Those conversations will go down well.
Due to inept list management, the older brigade will need to stick around for an extra year or 2 whilst they attempt to accumulate some early picks. Pendles will be playing his 500th in 2029

 

[kreuze_missile]

Those conversations will go down well.
Due to inept list management, the older brigade will need to stick around for an extra year or 2 whilst they attempt to accumulate some early picks. Peddles will be playing his 500th in 2029

They will be fine.

Rory Lobb is coming.

 

[Worm4]

Surprise surprise.. all the Collingwood flogs disappeared (again) after a loss (again).

May as well rename this thread to “Carlton supporter main board hangout”

Worst premiership defence ever

Some dude called heathysure come in Mr tough guy banging on about Cripps last 2 games of efficiency, showed some stats, and off he went like a fart in the wind

 

[Worm4]

Surprise surprise.. all the Collingwood flogs disappeared (again) after a loss (again).

They have social lives. Out partying possibly ?

 

[BennyGFunk]

They will be fine.

Rory Lobb is coming.

The cavalry…

 

[Muddiemoose]

Perfectly highlights my points from yesterday,

3 of the 4 over 30 and two of them probably gone next year

Who is stepping up at Collingwood to fill the gaps these old timers will leave?

 

[Worm4]

pies aren’t cold, they’re off 🤢 | Daniel Gorringe | danielgorringe_ · Original audio

pies aren’t cold, they’re off 🤢. danielgorringe_ · Original audio

www.facebook.com

 

[kreuze_missile]

Perfectly highlights my points from yesterday,

3 of the 4 over 30 and two of them probably gone next year

Who is stepping up at Collingwood to fill the gaps these old timers will leave?



View attachment 2039640

Daicos career trajectory from here is looking identical to Ablett Jr at Gold Coast.

Lots of stats. Lots of losses. Not sure he gets to September again until at least 2028.

If I was him I’d request a trade to a genuine contender in a dynasty window (ie. Carlton).

Would be a good depth player for us

 

[Fadge]

Yep, we are playing very ordinary at the moment, hunger isn’t there it seems

Slash … talent.

Both of these are accurate statements.

Far too much premiership talent on the sidelines.

 

[Fadge]

Perfectly highlights my points from yesterday,

3 of the 4 over 30 and two of them probably gone next year

Who is stepping up at Collingwood to fill the gaps these old timers will leave?



View attachment 2039640

Hang on, so GOATcos was one of our best despite having three different players rotate through him to quell his influence?

 

[kreuze_missile]

Both of these are accurate statements.

Far too much premiership talent on the sidelines.

Wondered what the angle would be.

Good to know

 

[kreuze_missile]

Hang on, so GOATcos was one of our best despite having three different players rotate through him to quell his influence?

41% disposal is local level footy quality.

Kid cannot handle a tag.

He’s Tom Stewart cooked.

 

[Fadge]

41% disposal is local level footy quality.

Kid cannot handle a tag.

He’s Tom Stewart cooked.

That's nice, dear.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Both of these are accurate statements.

Far too much premiership talent on the sidelines.

There is that of course - but that’s a part of most teams’ season.

Carlton enjoyed an injury list of 15 not long ago & got through.

It’s clear Collingwood’s depth is poor.

Not looking great for them to make the 8 now.

 

[Fadge]

As of now i'm more than delighted to write them off as flag contenders in 2024.

Explain this to me....

Would this mean Collingwood were never premiership contenders in 2024, or that they were through until round 16 (and possibly can be at some point later in the season)?

 

[Fadge]

Carlton enjoyed an injury list of 15 not long ago & got through.

There's injuries, and injuries to premiership players.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Hang on, so GOATcos was one of our best despite having three different players rotate through him to quell his influence?

Wrong thread chickadee

This is the who will be better Collingwood or Carlton thread

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Explain this to me....

Would this mean Collingwood were never premiership contenders in 2024, or that they were through until round 16 (and possibly can be at some point later in the season)?

I rule you out from this point onwards, unless the Pies pull a flag out of their arses despite finishing in the lower half of the eight!

Nah i think you're done for this year and some of your Magpie brethren also share these views.

 

[Fadge]

I rule you out from this point onwards, unless the Pies pull a flag out of their arses despite finishing in the lower half of the eight!

Nah i think you're done for this year and some of your Magpie brethren also share these views.

Oh, so we were premiership contenders in 2024, regardless of whether we actually contend for the premiership.

Interesting assessment.

Does that mean every team is a premiership contender at the start of a season, until you rule them out?

 

[Worm4]

There's injuries, and injuries to premiership players.

Come in, be brave and lick your wounds.
Pies had 17 premiership players out there last night. Enough you would have thought.
Missing Cox isn't the problem

 

[Arr0w]

"Here they go again, blaming injuries"

 

[Franc de Borges]

Two lucky draws where the opposition had shots at goal late, plus two umpire assisted wins over Adelaide and North. Their best recent performance was the bye

 

[CCurnow3votes]

There's injuries, and injuries to premiership players.

The Dirty Birds just aren’t good enough.

Blame injuries all you like - no depth is a sign the team isn’t great.

They got lucky last year - this year the lack of depth & talent is coming to bare.