Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Corn Cobbers]

I know the Swans have more than a few out (not sure who’s coming back in), so it’s a great time to play them. I wouldn’t be surprised if this game goes either way.

I'm sensing a drubbing, our bellies are full

 

[Worm4]

I don’t think any Carlton supporter is celebrating 8th spot, it’s just the nature of this thread.

There’d still be dick measuring in this thread even if both sides finished in the bottom 2.

I wouldn't want to put anyone to shame if both sides finished bottom 2..

 

[Worm4]

I'm sensing a drubbing, our bellies are full

Swans to improve and only get beaten by 16 goals

 

[CarmenSandiego]

In a poll taken last year, Fadge was selected as the #1 poster on Bigfooty for his formidable knowledge and foresight. Respect greatness when you see it

The Fadge way is easy.

I predict that every game will be either a win, loss or draw, and any of the 18 teams will finish between 1st & 18th, the winner of the GF will play and win on the MCG, after winning in a PF the week prior, that team may or may not be considered a 'contender' throughout the year.

 

[Fadge]

The Fadge way is easy.

I predict that every game will be either a win, loss or draw, and any of the 18 teams will finish between 1st & 18th, the winner of the GF will play and win on the MCG, after winning in a PF the week prior, that team may or may not be considered a 'contender' throughout the year.

I think you have me confused with someone else.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I think you have me confused with someone else.

Yep there's only one mugwump in this thread and it sure ain't you

 

[Worm4]

I think you have me confused with someone else.

 

[JustaBattler]

I dn tknwo why you COllingwobblers have given up the season already - wot a bunch of fair flosses you are.

 

[Fadge]

I dn tknwo why you COllingwobblers have given up the season already - wot a bunch of fair flosses you are.

Interpreting your post....

I understand it doesn't get much more exciting than challenging for a spot in the finals for Carlton, but when your team has played in one third of all Grand Finals, and you have sufficient finals experience to be aware that you can't genuinely contend for a premiership from outside the top 4, it's a lot easier to get a grasp on reality.

 

[Worm4]

In a poll taken last year, Fadge was selected as the #1 poster on Bigfooty for his formidable knowledge and foresight. Respect greatness when you see it

Voted for by the nuffies, for the nuffies

 

[JustaBattler]

Interpreting your post....

I understand it doesn't get much more exciting than challenging for a spot in the finals for Carlton, but when your team has played in one third of all Grand Finals, and you have sufficient finals experience to be aware that you can't genuinely contend for a premiership from outside the top 4, it's a lot easier to get a grasp on reality.

path -etic Fudgey - LIFT FFS!

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Interpreting your post....

I understand it doesn't get much more exciting than challenging for a spot in the finals for Carlton, but when your team has played in one third of all Grand Finals, and you have sufficient finals experience to be aware that you can't genuinely contend for a premiership from outside the top 4, it's a lot easier to get a grasp on reality.

Plus our form is pure rubbish, haven't played a good game since Queen's Birthday

De Goey gone, it's over for this year

 

[Arr0w]

In a poll taken last year, Fadge was selected as the #1 poster on Bigfooty for his formidable knowledge and foresight. Respect greatness when you see it

I just snorted my wine

 

[Blues177]

Just a fun fact. In the last 40+ years there has only been 2 players to have had a shot after the siren and had it go out of bounds on the full. That is McGovern and Kernahan.

Malcolm Blight at Arden St against Hawthorn in 1977..

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I have plenty of memories as well. All Grand Finals v Collingwood. Been to and witnessed 3 times the pies getting smacked in the big dance.
All you have is home and away related memories. Oh well.

A distant, faded memory of a better time. A past long gone into an obscured hazy horizon.
Supplanted now by this ignominy, these failures, this decay!

Oh well

 

[Cyclops]

I just snorted my wine

Pretty sure you're s'posed to drink it.

Then again happy accidents etc, is the buzz any good?

I might try snorting my whisky.

 

[Arr0w]

Pretty sure you're s'posed to drink it.

Then again happy accidents etc, is the buzz any good?

I might try snorting my whisky.

I wouldn't recommend it, it was an involuntary reaction

 

[Worm4]

A distant, faded memory of a better time. A past long gone into an obscured hazy horizon.
Supplanted now by this ignominy, these failures, this decay!

Oh well

The good memories far outweigh the bad as they should. Could be worse, we could be Saints supporters after all. They cheer when their team wins a quarter and release footage of it as a father's day gift

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Malcolm Blight at Arden St against Hawthorn in 1977..

They never talk about that one do they

Or the time he walked in a point and thought it was a goal

 

[Corn Cobbers]

GOAT

 

[Blues177]

They never talk about that one do they

Or the time he walked in a point and thought it was a goal

The out on the full one by Blight was played during the worst footy weather and ground condition I have seen. On the same day Carlton kicked only 3 goals against Geelong and still won.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

The out on the full one by Blight was played during the worst footy weather and ground condition I have seen. On the same day Carlton kicked only 3 goals against Geelong and still won.

It was a disgusting day, was still gutted though that my old man wouldn't take me to the Western Oval, soft as butter dad

 

[Madblue]

Plus our form is pure rubbish, haven't played a good game since Queen's Birthday

De Goey gone, it's over for this year

And the next decade to come

 

[Corn Cobbers]

And the next decade to come

 

[DopeMaster]

The good memories far outweigh the bad as they should. Could be worse, we could be Saints supporters after all. They cheer when their team wins a quarter and release footage of it as a father's day gift

You’re aware of which team you follow aren’t you?