Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Scritchyscroony]

Pies fans going off like they won the flag when they cant even make the 8

You don't get it so I'll explain it for you...

Hierarchy of "fun things" for Pies supporters:
1. Winning the flag ( the warm glow is well and truly still with us)
2. Beating Carlton twice in the season and watching them implode and miss finals.
3. Winning a prelim
4. Winning a final.
5. Making the 8
6. Winning Anzac day (half a tick)
7. NOT winning the wooden spoon and NOT getting the #1 pick.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

With the 2024 spoon, Richmond are set to become the second 'winningest' wooden spooner since the turn of the century, behind only Carlton...

Any wonder those two supporter bases are joined at the hip.

'Misery needs company'.

Both clubs have won 16 flags between them since 1958 though.

 

[Cleansweep17]

You don't get it so I'll explain it for you...

Hierarchy of "fun things" for Pies supporters:
1. Winning the flag ( the warm glow is well and truly still with us)
2. Beating Carlton twice in the season and watching them implode and miss finals.
3. Making a prelim
4. Winning a final.
5. Making the 8
6. Winning Anzac day (half a tick)
7. NOT winning the wooden spoon and NOT getting the #1 pick.

8. Licking Eddie’s boots

 

[Fadge]

Both clubs have won 16 flags between them since 1958 though.

That's nice.

How many since 2022?

 

[adammania9]

8. Licking Eddie’s boots

Who’s Eddie?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

8. Licking Eddie’s boots

Unlike Carlton, Richmond aren't on our radar sorry... Just not important at all.

I know you wanna be allowed to play with us big boys but nah. Good on you for trying though

 

[Cleansweep17]

Who’s Eddie?

McGuire

 

[Robertio]

That's nice.

How many since 2022?

Just say 3 in 60 years and cut the crap.

 

[beerbandit]

Both clubs have won 16 flags between them since 1958 though.

I can pick and choose dates too.

Carlton have won 0 flags since 1996

 

[Madblue]

You don't get it so I'll explain it for you...

Hierarchy of "fun things" for Pies supporters:
1. Winning the flag ( the warm glow is well and truly still with us)
2. Beating Carlton twice in the season and watching them implode and miss finals.
3. Winning a prelim
4. Winning a final.
5. Making the 8
6. Winning Anzac day (half a tick)
7. NOT winning the wooden spoon and NOT getting the #1 pick.

Nice deflection from your pathetic season

 

[RPCB]

To show how important Collingwood are compared to Richmond.

Since 1961

Hawthorn 13 flags
Carlton 8 flags
Richmond 8 flags
Bombers 6 flags
Geelong 5 flags
Melbourne 3 flags
North Melbourne 4 flags
West Coast (founded 1986) 4 flags
Brisbane Lions (1996) 3 flags

Collingwood 3 flags

At least Collingwood have won the “reigning premiers” trophy. I guess someone has to win it every year.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Pies fans going off like they won the flag

We did!! Already forgotten?

 

[Madblue]

To show how important Collingwood are compared to Richmond.

Since 1961

Hawthorn 13 flags
Carlton 8 flags
Richmond 8 flags
Bombers 6 flags
Geelong 5 flags
Melbourne 3 flags
North Melbourne 4 flags
West Coast (founded 1986) 4 flags
Brisbane Lions (1996) 3 flags

Collingwood 3 flags

At least Collingwood have won the “reigning premiers” trophy. I guess someone has to win it every year.

But, but, but they are a powerhouse

 

[beerbandit]

To show how important Collingwood are compared to Richmond.

Since 1961

Hawthorn 13 flags
Carlton 8 flags
Richmond 8 flags
Bombers 6 flags
Geelong 5 flags
Melbourne 3 flags
North Melbourne 4 flags
West Coast (founded 1986) 4 flags
Brisbane Lions (1996) 3 flags

Collingwood 3 flags

At least Collingwood have won the “reigning premiers” trophy. I guess someone has to win it every year.

oh my!

Going back to the 60s !!

 

[RPCB]

oh my!

Going back to the 60s !!

I know. It’s so irritating that I am ****ing defending Richmond.

 

[Fadge]

I know. It’s so irritating that I am ****ing defending Richmond.

We know.

As I said earlier... Carlton and Richmond supporters are peas in a pod.

Empathising with how you deal with multiple consecutive decades of complete ineptitude and irrelevancy.

 

[Madblue]

We know.

As I said earlier... Carlton and Richmond supporters are peas in a pod.

Empathising with how you deal with multiple consecutive decades of complete ineptitude and irrelevancy.

At least we dont have to deal with only 3 flags in seven decades. Blues & Tigers more than happy with our succes over the same time

 

[Corn Cobbers]

But, but, but they are a powerhouse

All time powerhouse, top of the table, Bombers 2nd, Carlton 3rd, not up for debate

 

[Robertio]

I can pick and choose dates too.

Carlton have won 0 flags since 1996

We won the millennium match which was bigger than a GF.

 

[Crankyhawk]

I will wait until we have a season that wasn't ravaged by injuries before judging this Carlton team.

So 4 more years then?

 

[Robertio]

We know.

As I said earlier... Carlton and Richmond supporters are peas in a pod.

Empathising with how you deal with multiple consecutive decades of complete ineptitude and irrelevancy.

You seem to latch on to anyone that agrees with you, needy as.

 

[Cleansweep17]

To show how important Collingwood are compared to Richmond.

Since 1961

Hawthorn 13 flags
Carlton 8 flags
Richmond 8 flags
Bombers 6 flags
Geelong 5 flags
Melbourne 3 flags
North Melbourne 4 flags
West Coast (founded 1986) 4 flags
Brisbane Lions (1996) 3 flags

Collingwood 3 flags

At least Collingwood have won the “reigning premiers” trophy. I guess someone has to win it every year.

Ewww!!!, honestly would rather follow St Kilda than the Pies at least they have Lockett

 

[Robertio]

So 4 more years then?

Come back and play with the big boys when your team has one 16 flags.

 

[Robertio]

All time powerhouse, top of the table, Bombers 2nd, Carlton 3rd, not up for debate

View attachment 2077334

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I know. It’s so irritating that I am ****ing defending Richmond.

You'd be a lot less irritated if Walsh had the speed to run with Daicos and if McGovern didn't get the blue shakes in the shot after the siren.
8 points just blown right there in the most Carlton way possible.
I mean you'd be comfortably in the 8 with a top 4 chance if it hadn't been for Collingwood doing a number on you both times again. Must be frustrating to think about.