Who would you give??

[lukedarcy14]

Ok being a bulldogs supporter i am wondering what you would trade from your club for the folowing players.
Matthew boyd
Ryan hargrave
Nathan eagleton
Shane birss
Daniel bandy
patrick bowden
lindsy gilbee

And a couple that i hope are never traded but am wondering
Daniel giansiracusa
Robert murphy
Luke darcy
Scott west


This is just a thread i thought id put up to see what some of theese players may be worth to other clubs and who there worth

 

[lukedarcy14]

Also you dont have to do all the players if you dont want. Just a few.

 

[ChrisL]

giansiricusa is good value but west is too old to get any interest from opposition clubs

 

[lukedarcy14]

Yes i know but i was just wondering what people would give for him, hes a superstar!!!

 

[Stan.]

We were after gilbee at one stage last year, might give you a third round draft pick for him this time around.

 

[feher]

how do you guys rate gilbee, bowden and hargraves? the only one that i am real intrested in is bowden, also how do you rate sam power?

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

i'd take West for Mark Johnson and a first rd draft pick.

 

[junior27]

Lindsay Gilbee added significant value to his trading stocks late in the year.
Patrick Bowden is inconsistent.

I'd like to see Gilbee at the Hawks possibly for our second round pick (#21)

 

[Star]

Ok being a bulldogs supporter i am wondering what you would trade from your club for the folowing players.
Matthew boyd
Ryan hargrave
Nathan eagleton
Shane birss
Daniel bandy
patrick bowden
lindsy gilbee

And a couple that i hope are never traded but am wondering
Daniel giansiracusa
Robert murphy
Luke darcy
Scott west


This is just a thread i thought id put up to see what some of theese players may be worth to other clubs and who there worth

Patrick Bowden has been linked to Richmond

Murphy is all class and would command a round one pick, IMO number 6 to 12 depending on how desperate a club was for his services.

West wouldn't go now so pretty irrelevant. You would never get what you wanted for a 30-something 6 time B&F winner and it destroys the fabric of a club.

Bandy - 4th round if anything

Birss - just started showing something last this year but I dont think he will make it long term

Giansiracusa is all class, needs to bulk up. Would be worth a second round pick IMO

 

[Prebble]

How bout Whitnell to the bulldogs for west?

cheers
prebble

 

[Total Package]

Ok being a bulldogs supporter i am wondering what you would trade from your club for the folowing players.
Matthew boyd
Ryan hargrave
Nathan eagleton
Shane birss
Daniel bandy
patrick bowden
lindsy gilbee

Not being a smartass here... but I honestly could not see us wanting to have any of those players. Maybe Daniel Bandy for a 4th round.. thats about it.

 

[Thewlis Dish]

The two blokes I'd want from the Dogs are Mitch Hahn and Matthew Robbins, but can't see Eade letting either go.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

How bout Whitnell to the bulldogs for west?

cheers
prebble

who would want Whitnell.

 

[jivey]

robbins is out of contract!

id like to see cross, at essendon

boyd, gilbee, birss maybe!

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Matthew boyd
Ryan hargrave
Nathan eagleton
Shane birss
Daniel bandy
patrick bowden
lindsy gilbee

Hargrave is the only one i'd consider, but wouldn't give up a great deal given we already have a surplus of his type.

 

[godees]

Bowden for our 2nd pick (29ish I think)
Would you take it?

 

[OldSchool]

Bowden for our 2nd pick (29ish I think)
Would you take it?

I wouldn't have thought so.

All this speculation about trading Bulldog players for draft picks or other players is just academic really. Eade has made it clear that we will be non players during the trade period unless a team wants to pay a premium for a player.

 

[lukedarcy14]

i'd take West for Mark Johnson and a first rd draft pick.

I acually shouldnt have put west in this or murphy because i wouldnt trade them unless a name like judd or reiwolt popped up (UNLIKLEY) also dont just say draft picks just throw em in if needed the quote above is the only trade ive seen so far

 

[EssendonPride]

LOL MJ Plus our first rounder?


No Thanks Wests a little too old for a trade like that
Dont want him, we need young players, we're rebuilding here, not a west away from a flag.

 

[Scham]

I'd give you Antoni Grover for Hargraves.
And Headland for Giansirracusa.

 

[ryan2000]

Eagleton.

I rate this guy. Reckon he'd do well at a new club. What would want for him?

Straight swap for Darren Hulme?

 

[lukedarcy14]

Eagleton.

I rate this guy. Reckon he'd do well at a new club. What would want for him?

Straight swap for Darren Hulme?

No we dont want darren hulme, He isnt the type of player we need. Id prefer whitnall and wed throw in our 2nd round pick 24 i think. Would you do that?

 

[ryan2000]

Yeah! I like your thinking, but pick #24 isn't enough for Whitnall IMO. (although many people think that's pretty good and that Whitnall isn't worth anything - those people are kiddin themselves.)

Tell you what? With Whitnall Included, what would we have to give up to get your pick#6?

 

[ryan2000]

Oh, and while we're on the subject. I got a very bad feeling that we're gonna trade Karl Norman to you guys.

 

[lukedarcy14]

Oh, and while we're on the subject. I got a very bad feeling that we're gonna trade Karl Norman to you guys.

Well i dont think i want karl norman But whitnall i think would be very valuble to the bulldogs. but for pick 6 theres nothing really at carlton that we would be able to get with pick 6, maybe whitnall norman and hulme but i cant see that happening. Pick six i think is big trade bate imo but if dogs do something stupid with it again i will almost cry!

Would you do whitnall for power and eagleton?