Who would you keep out of the 13 uncontracted players this year?

Who do you offer a contract extension to this year?

  • Brayden Cook

    Votes: 95 96.9%

  • Brodie Smith

    Votes: 4 4.1%

  • Chris Burgess

    Votes: 13 13.3%

  • Elliot Himmelberg

    Votes: 25 25.5%

  • Hugh Bond

    Votes: 19 19.4%

  • James Borlase

    Votes: 80 81.6%

  • Lochie Gollant

    Votes: 37 37.8%

  • Lochie Scholl

    Votes: 81 82.7%

  • Ned McHenry

    Votes: 4 4.1%

  • Patrick Parnell

    Votes: 4 4.1%

  • Sam Berry

    Votes: 86 87.8%

  • Taylor Walker

    Votes: 81 82.7%

  • Will Hamill

    Votes: 88 89.8%
  • Total voters
    98

Remove this Banner Ad

Cleric

Cleric

Brownlow Medallist
Veteran 10k Posts
Oct 14, 2011
14,879
16,757
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
We have thirteen unsigned players on the list at this point.
What's your view on if they re-sign or not with the club.
The player are.
1. Brayden Cook
2. Brodie Smith
3. Chris Burgess
4. Elliot Himmelberg
5. Hugh Bond
6. James Borlase
7. Lochie Gollant
8. Lochie Scholl
9. Ned McHenry
10. Patrick Parnell
11. Sam Berry
12. Taylor Walker
13. Will Hamill

I think we keep Cook (2-3 years), Gollant ( 1 year or Rookie), Berry (2 year), Walker (1 year), Scholl (2 year), Hamill (2 year), Borlase (Rookie extension), Bond (1 year), Ned (1 year)

What say ye?
 
Cleric said:
We have thirteen unsigned players on the list at this point.
What's your view on if they re-sign or not with the club.
The player are.
1. Brayden Cook
2. Brodie Smith
3. Chris Burgess
4. Elliot Himmelberg
5. Hugh Bond
6. James Borlase
7. Lochie Gollant
8. Lochie Scholl
9. Ned McHenry
10. Patrick Parnell
11. Sam Berry
12. Taylor Walker
13. Will Hamill

I think we keep Cook (2-3 years), Gollant ( 1 year or Rookie), Berry (2 year), Walker (1 year), Scholl (2 year), Hamill (2 year), Borlase (Rookie extension), Bond (1 year), Ned (1 year)

What say ye?
Click to expand...
Not sure but I think Burgess who was contracted for 2024 at the Suns probably got a 2 year contract to move?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

1. Brayden Cook - yes
2. Brodie Smith - no
3. Chris Burgess- no
4. Elliot Himmelberg - yes but happy to trade
5. Hugh Bond - yes, at least give him a go at senior level
6. James Borlase - yes, solid depth
7. Lachie Gollant - no
8. Lachy Sholl - yes
9. Ned McHenry - abso fn lutely no
10. Patrick Parnell - no
11. Sam Berry - yes
12. Taylor Walker - yes
13. Will Hamill - yes
 
Last edited:
Cleric said:
We have thirteen unsigned players on the list at this point.
What's your view on if they re-sign or not with the club.
The player are.
1. Brayden Cook
2. Brodie Smith
3. Chris Burgess
4. Elliot Himmelberg
5. Hugh Bond
6. James Borlase
7. Lochie Gollant
8. Lochie Scholl
9. Ned McHenry
10. Patrick Parnell
11. Sam Berry
12. Taylor Walker
13. Will Hamill

I think we keep Cook (2-3 years), Gollant ( 1 year or Rookie), Berry (2 year), Walker (1 year), Scholl (2 year), Hamill (2 year), Borlase (Rookie extension), Bond (1 year), Ned (1 year)

What say ye?
Click to expand...
yes to Cook, Himmelberg, Borlase, Scholl, Berry, Walker, Hamill
 
The player are:

KEEP
1. Brayden Cook
6. James Borlase
8. Lochie Sholl
11. Sam Berry
12. Taylor Walker
13. Will Hamill

GONE
2. Brodie Smith
3. Chris Burgess
4. Elliot Himmelberg
5. Hugh Bond
7. Lochie Gollant
9. Ned McHenry
10. Patrick Parnell
 
Last edited:
skam85 said:
1. Brayden Cook - yes
2. Brodie Smith - no
3. Chris Burgess- no
4. Elliot Himmelberg - yes but happy to trade
5. Hugh Bond - yes, at least give him a go at senior level
6. James Borlase - yes, solid depth
7. Lochie Gollant - no
8. Lochie Sholl - yes
9. Ned McHenry - abso fn lutely no
10. Patrick Parnell - no
11. Sam Berry - yes
12. Taylor Walker - yes
13. Will Hamill - yes
Click to expand...
With Gollant, I think he is good for depth. Walker is maybe in his last year, or one more, Welsh won't be up and running next year, if we even take him, and so any injury to Fog or RT puts us at a disadvantage. If we can get him onto the Rookie list that would be a good outcome.
As for Ned, again, just for a depth reason of we lose Rankine or Roch.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cleric said:
With Gollant, I think he is good for depth. Walker is maybe in his last year, or one more, Welsh won't be up and running next year, if we even take him, and so any injury to Fog or RT puts us at a disadvantage. If we can get him onto the Rookie list that would be a good outcome.
As for Ned, again, just for a depth reason of we lose Rankine or Roch.
Click to expand...
Really.... keeping Ned for depth.....
I rather keep him fishing out somewhere along Aldinga than anywhere near Team.
Absolute spud..... I also wish Murphy could be in that category but unfortunately he is contracted.
 
ClaudeCurlsCrow said:
Really.... keeping Ned for depth.....
I rather keep him fishing out somewhere along Aldinga than anywhere near Team.
Absolute spud..... I also wish Murphy could be in that category but unfortunately he is contracted.
Click to expand...
If we trade in a player of his type, or we know we are going to get a quality replacement in the draft, then I just think he can play a role for another 12 months. He knows the club, he knows the plays, and we know what he can do.
To me list management is about having depth and role players, as much as the legit stars.
 
Cleric said:
With Gollant, I think he is good for depth. Walker is maybe in his last year, or one more, Welsh won't be up and running next year, if we even take him, and so any injury to Fog or RT puts us at a disadvantage. If we can get him onto the Rookie list that would be a good outcome.
As for Ned, again, just for a depth reason of we lose Rankine or Roch.
Click to expand...
I'd rather Himmelberg and Borlase ahead of Gollant in that order, as depth.

McHenry is one of the worst players currently on an AFL list so he is absolutely worthless in every way.
 
Cleric said:
If we trade in a player of his type, or we know we are going to get a quality replacement in the draft, then I just think he can play a role for another 12 months. He knows the club, he knows the plays, and we know what he can do.
To me list management is about having depth and role players, as much as the legit stars.
Click to expand...
Yeah, f*ck all

He’s not even remotely useful depth, we should be cutting the cord ASAP
 
I think only three players have shown enough either this year or over their career to definitely deserve a contract extension

1. Taylor Walker
2. Brayden Cook
3. Lachlan Sholl

A few more need to show more throughout the year to get a contract

1. Will Hamill - trending towards a 1 year extension
2. Sam Berry - trending towards a 1 year extension
3. James Borlase - as depth

Then the group that hasn't shown enough and should be delisted

1. Patrick Parnell
2. Ned McHenry
3. Hugh Bond
4. Lachlan Gollant
5. Brodie Smith
6. Chris Burgess - though potentially keep as depth

And trade bait

1. Elliot Himmelberg - delist if not traded
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
  • Poll
Who could you tolerate winning the flag this year?
2 3 4 5
Replies
105
Views
3K
Rabish Binney
Rabish Binney
cmndstab
What would be your goal celebration song?
2 3 4
Replies
79
Views
2K
Samcro24
Samcro24
Moe Ron
Who was more impressive last year - Walker or Curnow?
Replies
11
Views
486
1970crow
1970crow
spenze
Review Good, Bad, Keeping shape, keeping shat - Crows V Bombers
19 20 21 22 23
Replies
555
Views
21K
Bay62
Bay62
Executive Landlord
NICKS OUT
2 3 4
Replies
82
Views
4K
BrissyCrow
BrissyCrow
crow2crow
Who are you taking?
Replies
7
Views
911
Scorpus
Scorpus
dogs105
Opinion One young player you would like from other clubs
Replies
11
Views
732
Carn The Texan
Carn The Texan
Back
Top