Worst player to play in a grand final??

[Football God]

1. He wasn't a dud, he was a freakish talent, who just lacked motivation.

2. I'm pretty sure he never played in a granny.

Fail much?

1. i never rated him so i didnt know thats why i had the question mark you spud

2. he played for essendon and brisbane so i would've thought he might've play in atleast 1

 

[Shane Clayton]

Shane Clayton.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

1. i never rated him so i didnt know thats why i had the question mark you spud

2. he played for essendon and brisbane so i would've thought he might've play in atleast 1

Oh, OK you had the question mark up because you didn't actually know whether he was a dud or not. Silly me, I assumed it was because you weren't sure if he played in a GF or not.

So you didn't know whether or not he was actually a dud, because i'm guessing you've never seen him play.

And you didn't know whether or not he played in a GF. I'm pretty sure he hasn't.

Question mark or not, why would you even bother?

Oh and if you think I am the spud from this exchange, then you have some strange logic going on.

 

[Vixen]

richard cole?

 

[wotdoiput]

Travis Gaspar, Aaron Keating, Ben Marsh.

 

[Surkin]

Collingwood's 2003 Grand Final included the following players:
Tristan Walker (1 possession)
Matthew Lokan (2 possessions)
Ben Kinnear (4 possessions)
Jason Cloke (4 possessions)
Ryan Lonie (4 possessions)
Rhyce Shaw (8 possessions)
Brodie Holland (8 possessions)
Richard Cole (9 possessions)
Leon Davis a.k.a. Mr September (10 possessions)
Shane O'Bree (13 possessions)
Alan Didak (13 possessions)
Shane Woewodin (13 possessions)
Heath Scotland (14 possessions)

There have never been a bigger collective bunch of spuds assemble on the MCG on Grand Final day. You know you are in trouble when Presti is half way up the list of your possession winners.

 

[wotdoiput]

Collingwood's 2003 Grand Final included the following players:
Tristan Walker (1 possession)
Matthew Lokan (2 possessions)
Ben Kinnear (4 possessions)
Jason Cloke (4 possessions)
Ryan Lonie (4 possessions)
Rhyce Shaw (8 possessions)
Brodie Holland (8 possessions)
Richard Cole (9 possessions)
Leon Davis a.k.a. Mr September (10 possessions)
Shane O'Bree (13 possessions)
Alan Didak (13 possessions)
Shane Woewodin (13 possessions)
Heath Scotland (14 possessions)

There have never been a bigger collective bunch of spuds assemble on the MCG on Grand Final day. You know you are in trouble when Presti is half way up the list of your possession winners.

Malthouse must be Jesus to get a team featuring some of those guys anywhere near a Grand Final, let alone in one.

 

[Pendles!]

milne

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Varcoe and Stokes are pretty poor footballers and wouldn't get a touch in a mid table side.

 

[Illinois Nazi]

Is Steve Johnson the only player ever to have been both BOG and WOG in a Grand Final?

 

[Generalissimo]

No, because worst on ground in 2009 was clearly Steven Milne.

 

[spiraldiver]

Threads like this remind me why footy was so much better before the internet.

 

[Harry Crumb]

Collingwood's 2003 Grand Final included the following players:
Tristan Walker (1 possession)
Matthew Lokan (2 possessions)
Ben Kinnear (4 possessions)
Jason Cloke (4 possessions)
Ryan Lonie (4 possessions)
Rhyce Shaw (8 possessions)
Brodie Holland (8 possessions)
Richard Cole (9 possessions)
Leon Davis a.k.a. Mr September (10 possessions)
Shane O'Bree (13 possessions)
Alan Didak (13 possessions)
Shane Woewodin (13 possessions)
Heath Scotland (14 possessions)

There have never been a bigger collective bunch of spuds assemble on the MCG on Grand Final day. You know you are in trouble when Presti is half way up the list of your possession winners.

How the hell did that group make the Grand Final??? Richmond of 2009 would have flogged that team!
And the Mr September is GOLD!

 

[My Blues]

Jamie Shanahan. I don't think any 1 player has ever been so conclusively flogged in a quarter let alone a game of football, and then we state it was a grand final!! StKilda could have played 5 extra men up forward and still would have lost the game this man was so inept and pathetic. The only thing more cooked than his goose that day was Stan Alve's brain who left him on the field for some reason only he will ever know. The moron then went and demanded a long term contract, which I'm still surprised to say that StKilda didn't agree to. LOL

 

[Claude Balls]

Lewis Roberts-Thompson
Sean Dempster
Stephen Doyle

LRT was almost BOG in the Swans 2005 premiership wasn't he?

Collingwood's 2003 Grand Final included the following players:
Tristan Walker (1 possession)
Matthew Lokan (2 possessions)
Ben Kinnear (4 possessions)
Jason Cloke (4 possessions)
Ryan Lonie (4 possessions)
Rhyce Shaw (8 possessions)
Brodie Holland (8 possessions)
Richard Cole (9 possessions)
Leon Davis a.k.a. Mr September (10 possessions)
Shane O'Bree (13 possessions)
Alan Didak (13 possessions)
Shane Woewodin (13 possessions)
Heath Scotland (14 possessions)

There have never been a bigger collective bunch of spuds assemble on the MCG on Grand Final day. You know you are in trouble when Presti is half way up the list of your possession winners.

Gee, that really is a bad reflection on Brisbane... they had an extra $600K to play with and they played the abovementioned hacks!

 

[Catsace]

LRT was almost BOG in the Swans 2005 premiership wasn't he?



Gee, that really is a bad reflection on Brisbane... they had an extra $600K to play with and they played the abovementioned hacks!

A worse reflection on Port Adelaide...they somehow lost to this bunch of chumps!!

 

[The Chiefton]

Ben Beams.

 

[shaolinmastah]

Malthouse has to be a genius he continually got his team into the finals and even a few Grand Finals with absolute hacks in their team I truly don't know how he does it.

 

[Trjn]

Collingwood's 2003 Grand Final included the following players:
Tristan Walker (1 possession)
Matthew Lokan (2 possessions)
Ben Kinnear (4 possessions)
Jason Cloke (4 possessions)
Ryan Lonie (4 possessions)
Rhyce Shaw (8 possessions)
Brodie Holland (8 possessions)
Richard Cole (9 possessions)
Leon Davis a.k.a. Mr September (10 possessions)
Shane O'Bree (13 possessions)
Alan Didak (13 possessions)
Shane Woewodin (13 possessions)
Heath Scotland (14 possessions)

There have never been a bigger collective bunch of spuds assemble on the MCG on Grand Final day. You know you are in trouble when Presti is half way up the list of your possession winners.

I'd like to see that stats for Port's 07 GF side.

 

[ams4crows]

Re: Worst player to to play in a grand final??

aaron keating - adelaide 1997

grand final was his 3rd game and he went statless. Only played 3 more games in his career.

win!

 

[iluvparis]

great call. forgot about him. he tried to rough up long, and a few of our other players in the first quarter. think he spent a bit of time tagging long (norm) as well.

did he play another game after that?

He never played another AFL game.

 

[BLPC08]

Spiro Malakellis,Russell Merriman,Steven Handley,Shayne Breuer.

all cat players from late 80's early 90's,no wonder they lost 4 gf's in 7 years

Shayne Breuer had a heap of talent. Don't know what your on about there.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Any1 who doesn't say Keating doesn't know otherwise.

Even his own supporters would admit that.

 

[footyfreak]

keating by a mile. Played 3 games for the crows, one regular game, and then in 2 weeks played in a prelim win and a GF win followed up by a SANFL GF win.

 

[The Panther]

In 93', Carlton had Tim Powell, Mark Athorn & Brett Sholl on the same field.