Worst premiership player of all time - Nominations thread

[goldfinger]

The same Stevie J who won the Norm Smith in '07 and kicked 4 goals on one leg in '11? Yeah, definitely the worst premiership player running around.

As for Cyril, what has he done since '08? Sweet FA, that's what.

Yep, the very self same front running showboating soft as butter one.

Although I will concede he probably ain't the worst going around.... I was merely responding to a ridiculous suggestion by one of your esteemed scat brethren with a clearly less ridiculous one. It has to be a tie between Mooney and Renouf.

 

[newcs]

If Cameron Mooney wasn't drafted by Geelong he would have most likely owned this thread.

 

[Sound]

Leon Davis received a premiership medallion didn't he?

 

[Freomaniac]

I cant believe this.... After 100 odd posts, No one has ever mentioned Rowan Jones of the West Coast 2006 team.

If any of you flogs ever saw him play in his 150 games from 1999-2007, you would notice he was the worst kick in the AFL by a mile.

 

[Freomaniac]

Also I agree both Crows teams of 1997-8 had a few spuds as well.

 

[Kabanna]

Going back to 2002, Beau McDonald and aaron Shattock donutted for Brisbane ( I don't remember if they were injured) but it makes the 2002 GF all the more mirthful if Brisbane had 20 blokes who got possessions but still beat Collingwood ( mind you collingwood had both nick and Leon Davis, Steinfort and Jarrod Molloy who between them got 8 possessions).

Beau McDonald was off the field and transported to hospital after he did his shoulder in the first couple of minutes... That's what makes 2002 so awesome to watch. Beating those Collingwood dickheads with a 3 man bench and 1 ruckman

 

[Freomaniac]

Beau McDonald was off the field and transported to hospital after he did his shoulder in the first couple of minutes... That's what makes 2002 so awesome to watch. Beating those Collingwood dickheads with a 3 man bench and 1 ruckman

and If the sub rule was introduced in 2002, lions would of still won the grand final anyway.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Cameron Mooney, worst premiership winner and AA of all time. Provided many laughs but, such a woeful set shot

Please provide facts on why this is the case.

 

[Turly]

Shitroll Crapoli or Cruddy Shanklin for mine. Overrated flogs whose team plays better without them.

LOL brahhh why you still hurtin? It's been over 4 years already.....

 

[WCErevival]

I cant believe this.... After 100 odd posts, No one has ever mentioned Rowan Jones of the West Coast 2006 team.

If any of you flogs ever saw him play in his 150 games from 1999-2007, you would notice he was the worst kick in the AFL by a mile.

 

[Bayer_]

Gotta be Brent Renouf.

 

[captain blood 17]

 

[Mutant]

I agree, he lacks the neccessary criteria of being more shit than Hansen.

Hansen, Premiership Player couldn't probably give a Fcuk what you or Pav think of him. Takes a team to win a premiership, sadly the cockers rely on too few to do too much.

 

[tacopavlich]

Hansen, Premiership Player couldn't probably give a Fcuk what you or Pav think of him.

Well that's good. Not caring what people think must be pretty handy when you're shit.

 

[Mutant]

Well that's good. Not caring what people think must be pretty handy when you're shit.

As a cockers supporter you would know, following a club that has been shit since inception.

 

[Kabanna]

The only player Freo fans could really relate to in this thread is Des Headland*, who ironically only really had one good year.

* such a shame for them that when he won his medal, he was playing for my club and not theirs. Lol

 

[Freomaniac]

You call that good?

I remember times at set shots at goal he kicked it like a helicopter punt.

 

[Bloods 1874]

Hadlee's a w@nker.... How much did he hate that

I was only a tacker, but I seem to remember Hadlee saying that the w***er chants were an indictment on the Vic education system. Great way to endear yourself to a truth speaking public.

 

[Mutant]

Cockers swallowers, would feel pretty safe in this thread, no chance of any of their premiership players getting a mention.

 

[Bigeasy]

Here's one thread Saint and Bulldogs posters can rest up and grab some popcorn.

 

[Barkly St End]

Here's one thread Saint and Bulldogs posters can rest up and grab some popcorn.

I disagree. We are best positioned to nominate the duds with a good deal of detachment and objectivity.

For instance, we are better positioned to notice that North had plenty of passengers in both 1996 and 1999.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Luke Hodge.





*Edit - Sorry thought it was worst performance to win a Norm Smith thread. My bad.

 

[cammo78]

For instance, we are better positioned to notice that North had plenty of passengers in both 1996 and 1999.

I'd suggest the "Fridge" Roberts and Stuart Anderson are two at the very pointy end of the list.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Shannon Byrnes? Matthew Stokes? OP clearly doesn't watch much footy, mod lock topic plz.

Bit harsh on Byrnes. While I think he's a very limited footballer, he was crucial in the last quarter against St Kilda in '09. He along with Varcoe and Ablett were the only ones with any pace left in their legs.

Stokes and Blake may be fair calls if you're naming Geelong players, I'd probably throw Wojcinski in the mix too.

 

[the_interloper]

Aaron Shittock.