WORST ruckman in the last 10 years??

[meekaboy]

Simon Feast would have to get a nomination here.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Peter Street
'

At your club yes.
No way near it now.
If he is the worst ruckman in 10 years then we have had some mighty fine ruckmen.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

David Loats

How the hell did we manage to offload Loats to Geelong

How did we get a 2nd rd pick for Paul Chambers

Mind you, I did see him do some good things....when he was at the cats.

 

[Generalissimo]

David Loats by a whisker from Paul Chambers.

Chambers gave it everything, and you knew you'd get at least a contest every time he went up, he was just hopeless around the ground.

 

[stanga]

i think his name was nickname was odie was a bloodnut for melbourne ans another one would be richard lounder for richmond

 

[Mitchell Madness]

A FEW CANDIDATES:

Aaron Keating (I know he didn't play 20 games, but how did he get a premiership medal again?)
Peter Street
David Loats
Robert Campbell
Nick Stone (Surely he's played 20 by now)
Paul Dooley (Not 20 but still)
Nick Bruton (See Dooley)
James Mieklejohn (See Bruton)
Stephen Doyle
Ricky Mott
Lazar Vidovic

The list is endless.

DID you watch any hawthorn games this season? Robbie dominated the ruck.

 

[Ported]

Daryl Poole

Wash your mouth out. Also, he wasn't a full time ruckman. Played at CHF.

Fun article on Pooley.

 

[topdon]

Illija Grigic

I'll raise you a Judd Lalich.

 

[SweetLeftFoot]

Randall Bone.

 

[kane249]

DID you watch any hawthorn games this season? Robbie dominated the ruck.

Did you take note of the fact that post was done 2 years ago?

 

[giantsully]

"Torture" Chambers by the length of the street. I saw him go up for a ruck tap and use his head. Twice! Admittedly that takes some sort of courage but it ain't the epitome of great ruckwork.