Teams Your 2014 SC team Ver 2.0 (Pre NAB)

[Super Hans]

Changed my team a fair bit since I last posted it, pretty happy with it atm.

Mitchell, Hodge, Simpson, B.Smith, Kolodjashnij, McDonald
(Fuller, Giles)

Ablett, Pendles, Watson, Cotchin, Beams, Tyson, Sheed, Ellis
(Dunstan, Robertson)

McIntosh, Sandilands
(Thurlow, Mitchell)

Dangerfield, Martin, Rioli, Pavlich, Lamb, Garlett
(Kersten, Kennedy-Harris)

Thoughts fellas?

 

[Purple_Voice]

Hey guys/gals. This is my first year playing supercoach so any feedback would be appreciated.

 

[toxic]

Okay have changed my mid bench, now I have cheyenne woods and ice on it. OMG the things that could be done on that bench

 

[toxic]

Hey guys/gals. This is my first year playing supercoach so any feedback would be appreciated.

View attachment 42694

Get rid of barlow for fyfe or dayne beams.
Std guns n rookies side. Good starting point

 

[Purple_Voice]

Get rid of barlow for fyfe or dayne beams.
Std guns n rookies side. Good starting point

Thank you
Because of the bye rounds, I changed Barlow for Fyfe.

I did have Suckling/Young in there at one point, but as a newbie I decided to stick to the guns n rookies basics

 

[copthat]

Hey guys/gals. This is my first year playing supercoach so any feedback would be appreciated.

View attachment 42694

Maybe Longer > Currie/Brown to free up some cash.

 

[gessdoss]

final team any thoughts still waiting nab to lock it all in.

 

[gessdoss]

Go ahead. Grill me.

View attachment 42585

$40,700 change.

Would not pay 500 for Taylor in the back maybe Simpson or SAM Mitchell better bang for buck

 

[hawker92]

final team any thoughts still waiting nab to lock it all in.
View attachment 42708

Downgrade Savage to a rookie and upgrade Geary IMO. Having Clark, Rohan and Bock is risky.

 

[toxic]

final team any thoughts still waiting nab to lock it all in.
View attachment 42708

Geary NO

 

[karaoke]

Changed my team a fair bit since I last posted it, pretty happy with it atm.

Mitchell, Hodge, Simpson, B.Smith, Kolodjashnij, McDonald
(Fuller, Giles)

Ablett, Pendles, Watson, Cotchin, Beams, Tyson, Sheed, Ellis
(Dunstan, Robertson)

McIntosh, Sandilands
(Thurlow, Mitchell)

Dangerfield, Martin, Rioli, Pavlich, Lamb, Garlett
(Kersten, Kennedy-Harris)

Thoughts fellas?

Not a fan of the Sandi/Hmac combo - only one IMO,

Also not a fan of playing the lottery that is 'breakout' players - BSmith,

Rioli> Chappy?

 

[Krujan]

You should only have 1 premo-break out candidate in your initial team, no more! Any more than that and you will be looking at a 50-100k finish.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Geary NO

Heavily agree.

final team any thoughts still waiting nab to lock it all in.
View attachment 42708

Savage > Sheed or someone around that. Should leave you an extra 180k use it to upgrade Geary and Clark. Bock down to someone cheaper should free up space.

 

[Super Hans]

Not a fan of the Sandi/Hmac combo - only one IMO,

Also not a fan of playing the lottery that is 'breakout' players - BSmith,

Rioli> Chappy?

With Sandi/Hmac, I have almost no confidence in any premium ruck men so might as well take the risk on these two. This will change if NicNat plays round 1.

Brodie Smith I'm just a massive fan of, originally had Adcock in this position but I reckon that Mitchell, Simpson and to a lesser extent Hodge are all very reliable to average atleast 95+ so I can take the risk on Smith. I see him a lot like Sam Gilbert 2009.

Rioli is changing between Chapman and Parker, nab will solve this one.

 

[karaoke]

Geary NO

Can go huge, but can also 'spud it' (SC style) due to run with roles he gets,

Range of SC scores last year was 41-144 (ave 80), too much variance,

 

[Bombers13]

Hi guys... Thoughts on my team? Any advice would be great

Backs: Bartel, Mitchell, Malceski, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Fuller, Cutler)

Midfield: Ablett (c), Pendlebury, Rockliff, D.Beams, M.Murphy, Martin, Sheed, Dunstan (Gartlett, Honeychurch)

Rucks: Luenberger, Sandilands (Thurlow, Smith)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Buddy, Wingard, Caddy, Lamb, Lennon (Taylor, Kerstan

Still got 71,000 left

 

[karaoke]

Hi guys... Thoughts on my team? Any advice would be great

Backs: Bartel, Mitchell, Malceski, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald (Fuller, Cutler)

Midfield: Ablett (c), Pendlebury, Rockliff, D.Beams, M.Murphy, Martin, Sheed, Dunstan (Gartlett, Honeychurch)

Rucks: Luenberger, Sandilands (Thurlow, Smith)

Forwards: Dangerfield, Buddy, Wingard, Caddy, Lamb, Lennon (Taylor, Kerstan

Still got 71,000 left

Solid,

If it were mine;

Lamb > Rookie
Caddy > Chappy/Zorko the magnificent/Gray/Pavlova

IMO&FWIW

 

[elMM]

note: Jack Riewoldt is a non-negotiable - I'm playing him to win a bet
Rookies will be resolved after the NAB Challenge; I'm also strongly considering not playing J. Martin

comments on structure and premiums which I have (and have not selected) greatly appreciated

 

[NM bound]

Thoughts on my current setup?

 

[NM bound]

note: Jack Riewoldt is a non-negotiable - I'm playing him to win a bet
Rookies will be resolved after the NAB Challenge; I'm also strongly considering not playing J. Martin

comments on structure and premiums which I have (and have not selected) greatly appreciated

VERY strong team. IMO crouch wont get enough games to make money off

Not much I would change tho aside from riewoldt. Good job

 

[longytap]

final team any thoughts still waiting nab to lock it all in.
View attachment 42708

Like it, risky rucks but I'm sure your aware of that.

 

[TheOz]

Can go huge, but can also 'spud it' (SC style) due to run with roles he gets,

Range of SC scores last year was 41-144 (ave 80), too much variance,

It really depends on the role he is given, when used as a tagger or defender, he is next to useless in supercoach, when given some license away from defensive duties, he can rack up some high scores.

 

[Purple_Voice]

Maybe Longer > Currie/Brown to free up some cash.

Thank you for feedback. After the Barlow > Fyfe change, I have$66,400 remaining. Is this not enough?

 

[Deliverance]

It really depends on the role he is given, when used as a tagger or defender, he is next to useless in supercoach, when given some license away from defensive duties, he can rack up some high scores.

Ummm, you've just paraphrased what krk just said.

 

[TheOz]

Ummm, you've just paraphrased what krk just said.

Didn't read his post before replying, oops