Autopsy Round 5, 2023: Collingwood v St.Kilda

[triggering bro]

Phillipou robbed of the rising star

The crows bloke had 10 disposals and 4 tackles…LMAO.

And how’s that weak Pies campaigner creating a fuss and drumming up a suspension on a young kid despite being the instigator. Surely a ‘man’ would concede that he deserved what he got. Piss poor effort from a very weak human being.

 

[gringo2011]

Intresting only 8 players registered over 2 tackles. In those 8 are 2 key defenders in Wilkie and Battle, and our ruckman.

11 players combined for 5 tackles.

Part is how the Pies play. They are a hard to tackle side.

 

[StFly]

Media already hanging Hammer for at least four weeks. What a laugh.

Trial by media, MC is so soft and limp that he just spun in his chair whilst reading the doc report and threw the book literally so it stuck. Was always going to happen when princess Murphy spends his evenings cowered in a corner sobbing uncontrollably how he's a weak prick who got gazumped cause they found his glass jaw.

Surely they don’t hit him for more than four though right???


Suddenly really worried now. Much worse than I expected

The hand of god mark II! Revenge of the Geich, can;t wait for his rap album about how this is the most heinous thing that existed in AFL footy thus far this season.

Legit, I want to see the mental hurdles here you could literally launch yourself at and utterly neck someone with flying elbows, and it's less then that hit. I want tosee it so we can all see why no one takes baths any more and why the Geich drunk it all cause F me it'll be beautiful in its insanity.

 

[phantom13]

Would be absolutely amazing if the Tribunal follows its current trend of throwing out the direct referrals but I doubt it.

Honestly this system is idiotic, if MC as the MRO had any ****ing balls he’d just be allowed to grade it and we could challenge if we didn’t like it, instead we get the sideshow of the tribunal.

 

[Plugger35]

The crows bloke had 10 disposals and 4 tackles…LMAO.

And how’s that weak Pies campaigner creating a fuss and drumming up a suspension on a young kid despite being the instigator. Surely a ‘man’ would concede that he deserved what he got. Piss poor effort from a very weak human being.

Macrae said last week that they don't boo in his household but apparently dobbing is OK, dobbing is way worse than booing imo.

Being accused of being a dobber at school was about as low as you could get and would probably result in a beating from anyone you dobbed on.

 

[phantom13]

The crows bloke had 10 disposals and 4 tackles…LMAO.

And how’s that weak Pies campaigner creating a fuss and drumming up a suspension on a young kid despite being the instigator. Surely a ‘man’ would concede that he deserved what he got. Piss poor effort from a very weak human being.

Yeh purely on statistics Pou smashed him.

19, 1 goal, 3 marks, 2 tackles.

 

[triggering bro]

Seriously, Nathan Murphy

28

Nathan Murphy

Age

24

Ht

192cm

Wt

90kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.5

3star

K

6.5

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.5

3star

T

1.5

3star

MG

176.5

3star

No current season stats available

D

11.5

3star

K

6.5

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.5

3star

T

1.5

4star

MG

176.5

3star

has embarrassed not only his self, but his club, and the AFL as a sport. Anyone else in world sport would say he got what he deserved and move on. How tough is this weak campaigner for hitting a teenage kid from behind, getting an appropriate response and then sooking. I bet his parents are embarrassed by him.

 

[PoppedCorn]

Im a little dark about it.

Usually this shit doesnt bother me but the whole him instigating it then dropping the knees is shit

The lip from the bench is what pisses me off the most i think

 

[SaintyMcSaintface]

Part is how the Pies play. They are a hard to tackle side.

One of the reasons we lost. Couldn't hold on to them and force stoppages.

 

[pebblesofsand]

Two weeks

 

[PoppedCorn]

Two weeks

View attachment 1663446

No concussion

 

[Pakenhamsaint]

Two weeks

View attachment 1663446

It's always outcome based. No concussion less penalty.

 

[SaintyMcSaintface]

Yeh purely on statistics Pou smashed him.

19, 1 goal, 3 marks, 2 tackles.

If he had kicked that goal in the last RS would probably be his this week

 

[gringo2011]

I read a lot more than I post on the forums & one of the things that I read a lot that p1sses me off is so much blame towards the umpires for our losses. I'm not sticking up for the umpires so much but I think they have some sh1thouse rules to deal with.

Every game I watch, Saints playing or not, the umpiring is generally atrocious. I think mostly the lower teams get the rawest deal. I don't know why that is but that is my observation over the years. And yes, that includes The Saints, they often get shafted but not often to the point where it cosst them the game. We lost against The Pies because they made fewer mistakes, it was a game of high pressure & riddled with errors. I screamed "FFS" so many times at the tele.

For most of the game we were equal to, if not better than The Pies. Out of all the non Saints games I've watched this year, The Pies look like the best team. So to be on an even footing with them at this stage of the season is very encouraging in my view, even though we lost. We were just one Himmelberg type mark away from a draw. A great effort in my view. Another day of being a proud St Kilda supporter.

I thought they were shit. 14 to 4 at three quarter time or something, never pinged for HTB and paid against us. We were made play on immediately without leaving our line, they got ages. I get that there is a shitness tax but it'd not right. They contributed to our loss, despite the Pies being the better side. If the best side won every game this wouldn't be a sport. The umpires shouldn't be a factor for either side and they often are.

 

[Munga]

Bucks says it should be 2 weeks and I agree. Gary Lyon says they will make an example of Caminiti and give him 4+. Absolutely sickening treatment. Who the f!@# would want to play AFL with this crap going on? Caminiti misses 4+ weeks because Murphy is a moronic squib. I do hate AFL. Love the Saints. Hate AFL. Coming up 20 years since Sirengate and Whispers in the Sky, the moment it started to die inside me.

 

[Plugger35]

Would be absolutely amazing if the Tribunal follows its current trend of throwing out the direct referrals but I doubt it.

Honestly this system is idiotic, if MC as the MRO had any ******* balls he’d just be allowed to grade it and we could challenge if we didn’t like it, instead we get the sideshow of the tribunal.

Michael Christian is a Collingwood man too so that doesn't help our chances.

I wish they would go back to a panel to decide on incidents rather than leaving it to just one person, especially when that person is a certified idiot.

I know this suspension will be decided by a tribunal now but no doubt Michael Christian would have some input as to what the suspension should be.

.

 

[Squirtles]

Well Gaff got what 6 weeks for breaking Brayshaws jaw so maybe 4

 

[gringo2011]

Im a little dark about it.

Usually this s**t doesnt bother me but the whole him instigating it then dropping the knees is s**t

The lip from the bench is what pisses me off the most i think

Hopefully Junior G-train has taught the little bitch to step back before starting shit. He'd better buy a helmet if we play them in finals.

 

[triggering bro]

I suspect he will get 4 weeks. I’m sure the club will get behind in though. Give him assurances for a longterm contract.

 

[botts]

If he had kicked that goal in the last RS would probably be his this week

The other bloke got it for body of work. I would argue phillipous body of work has been better.

 

[Plugger35]

Bucks says it should be 2 weeks and I agree. Gary Lyon says they will make an example of Caminiti and give him 4+. Absolutely sickening treatment. Who the f!@# would want to play AFL with this crap going on? Caminiti misses 4+ weeks because Murphy is a moronic squib. I do hate AFL. Love the Saints. Hate AFL. Coming up 20 years since Sirengate and Whispers in the Sky, the moment it started to die inside me.

Being persecuted by the umpires and the tribunal is just part and parcel of being a Saints supporter, as much as I hate it this adversity fuels our fire.

 

[PoppedCorn]

Hopefully Junior G-train has taught the little bitch to step back before starting s**t. He'd better buy a helmet if we play them in finals.

Im still a little old skool G.
Youd tell him at the start, im gonna lay you flat today lol

 

[sammm]

I suspect he will get 4 weeks. I’m sure the club will get behind in though. Give him assurances for a longterm contract.

I hope so, however, there are no guarantees

 

[PostmanBish]

I suspect he will get 4 weeks. I’m sure the club will get behind in though. Give him assurances for a longterm contract.

Deserves a 5 year deal for that one action, IMHO.

 

[Murraj1966]

It's always outcome based. No concussion less penalty.

Unless you're Ben Long playing for St Kilda and they introduce the "potential to cause injury" once and then never reference it again