Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Player 20: Peter Wright

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Feels like that’s the answer but also feels ridiculous. Almost asking for him to get injured instead
Agreed, but it is sort of where we are at. Had he put his arms up to the ball he may have no case to answer but might be out for weeks with a broken rib. A very fine line.
 
Agreed, but it is sort of where we are at. Had he put his arms up to the ball he may have no case to answer but might be out for weeks with a broken rib. A very fine line.
This is the argument to make (because it’s true) - basically asking for leniency. He will still get weeks.

I’m glad we don’t blame the victim in ones like this as it would ruin the game.

Having said that, the injury is clearly mainly the fault of the guy who jumps backwards & sideways into the path of a 100kg + unit who is sprinting at the footy

Wright turned and will get weeks. But if he went the footy the contact would have been elbows and knees and the same injury or worse
 
Last edited:
Plugger made a career on owning that space at the scg that's, why he always had leading room at the scg, my initial feeling was pride that 2mp had owned his leading corridor and he'd finally made a physical statement, then the commentary kicked in and ruined it! ...and those nuffy Sydney fans who cried a river when their triple Brownlow medalist was booed a bit sure have a good booing voice when they want it, was like a punch and Judy play
.
 
Plugger made a career on owning that space at the scg that's, why he always had leading room at the scg, my initial feeling was pride that 2mp had owned his leading corridor and he'd finally made a physical statement, then the commentary kicked in and ruined it! ...and those nuffy Sydney fans who cried a river when their triple Brownlow medalist was booed a bit sure have a good booing voice when they want it, was like a punch and Judy play
.

Goodes being racially vilified is very different to normal people booing football acts
 
I don't really know what else he could've done. I feel like he needed to protect himself in this situation as Cunningham was coming in on an angle.
Not turn his shoulder into the oncoming Cunningham?

If he had put his hands out to mark it, or kept his body square and his arms low for a chest mark, he is probably able to argue he was legitimately contesting the ball.

Whether he did it in self defence or not, his duty of care meant the one thing he couldnt do was forsake the ball and turn his shoulder into Cunninghams head.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Not turn his shoulder into the oncoming Cunningham?

If he had put his hands out to mark it, or kept his body square and his arms low for a chest mark, he is probably able to argue he was legitimately contesting the ball.

Whether he did it in self defence or not, his duty of care meant the one thing he couldnt do was forsake the ball and turn his shoulder into Cunninghams head.
You’ve also good a duty of care to yourself. You can’t expect players to change their duty of care within milliseconds, he didn’t know Cunningham was going to be there until he was already at full speed and off the ground.
 
You’ve also good a duty of care to yourself. You can’t expect players to change their duty of care within milliseconds, he didn’t know Cunningham was going to be there until he was already at full speed and off the ground.

Don't you know the new rules of AFL? If you get there first everyone else has to stop and let you have it
 
You’ve also good a duty of care to yourself. You can’t expect players to change their duty of care within milliseconds, he didn’t know Cunningham was going to be there until he was already at full speed and off the ground.

Best not to try to apply football logic to these things
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Turn will hang him.
If he had thrown the arms out for the mark, he'd probably get 1-2
lack of carlton jumper doesnt help either

Still, i dont mind us playing on edge.
If he throws his arms out Cunningham shatters his ribs, dunno what they expect of him.
 
I like all the BS about him leaving the ground, from here on out all marking contests must have at least one foot firmly planted on the ground. If 2MP was late to the contest this is obviously a very different story but they hit the ball at the same time, the reckless act is from the player coming back with the flight, it is also why it is seen as courageous to take marks going back with the flight, the player running at the ball can and does have every right to protect themselves, the player going back with the flight is leaving themselves wide open and is a consequence of running back with the flight
 
Yep, feel the same.

Bracing for contact is risky these days. At least he didn't lift the elbow.
I don't understand what players in Wright's position are supposed to do? I don't think he 'decided' to brace for impact, he instinctively reacted that way (there was no decision process).
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Player 20: Peter Wright


Write your reply...

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top